3/2025/0801 - Land to East of Salesbury View, Wilpshire
RefusedPlanning1 paper
AI summaryRibble Valley Planning and Development Committee refused planning permission for 80 homes on land east of Salesbury View, Wilpshire, citing highways safety, accessibility for those with reduced mobility, and visual impact.
What happens nextOfficers to draft refusal reasonsReasons to be brought back to next Committee
Who it affectsLand east of Salesbury View, WilpshireGreenfield allocated housing site of approximately 4.98 hectares
What was decided
The committee resolved to refuse planning permission for 80 dwellinghouses on land east of Salesbury View, Wilpshire on the grounds of highways safety, failure to make provision for those with reduced mobility, and visual impact.
Officers are to draft refusal reasons and bring them back to the next committee meeting.
Why
The application was refused for highways reasons including safety concerns and the failure to make provision for those with reduced mobility, with site gradients of 15-20% identified as problematic. Report 1.3, P7
Visual impact was cited as a refusal ground; the steeply sloping site would require significant earthworks and retaining structures, and the development would be readily visible from surrounding public vantage points. Report P50, P47, P52
Over 160 third-party representations were received objecting to the application on grounds including dangerous topography, overburdened infrastructure, traffic safety, loss of habitats, flooding, and discriminatory gradient against those with limited mobility. Report P6, P7
What happens next
Officers will draft formal refusal reasons and present them at the next Planning and Development Committee meeting.
The money
£89,748 NHS Lancashire and South Cumbria ICB requested contribution towards expansion of Brownhill Surgery, Whalley New Road Report P5
£45,870 LCC Highways requested contribution for pedestrian footbridge over Knotts Brook and to surface and widen the footpath Report P67
Options considered
Chosen: Refuse planning permission on grounds of highways and visual impact. Committee cited highway safety, failure to provide for those with reduced mobility, and visual impact as reasons for refusal
Implications
Legal: Two previous applications on this site have been refused or withdrawn: 3/2023/0614 was refused and dismissed at appeal, and 3/2022/0115 was withdrawn. Report P24, P25
Equalities: Objectors raised that the 20% gradient of the site is way over the 8% maximum within the Equalities Act, which is discriminatory for people with limited mobility. Report P7
Financial: S106 contributions of £89,748 (NHS ICB) and £45,870 (LCC Highways) were discussed as potential developer contributions. Report P5, P67
Climate: Ecological concerns raised over removal of hedgerows, new planting taking 15 years to mature, and potential impact on protected species including otters, bats, and great crested newts. Report P7, P77, P84
Risk: Concerns were raised about ground conditions, with the northern portion of the site found to be saturated at the surface and trial pits recording ingress of water unsuitable for property foundations. Report P7
Who and where
The applicant, seeking full planning permission for 80 dwellinghouses on a 4.98 hectare greenfield site Report P15, 1.1, 2.1
Over 160 third-party objectors, including nearby residents of Wilpshire, Salesbury View, Whalley Road, Hollowhead Avenue and Beaver Close Report P6, P39, P41
Residents of Blackburn with Darwen, given the site's proximity to the borough boundary and potential demand on cross-boundary services Report P3, 1.2
Timeline
2008, 2028: Plan period during which 66 units were assigned to Wilpshire as a Tier 1 Village housing allocation under Policy HAL2 Report P30
2022: Application 3/2022/0115 for 99 new homes was withdrawn Report P25
2023: Application 3/2023/0614 for 84 new homes was refused and the subsequent appeal was dismissed Report P24
2026-07-23: Planning and Development Committee resolved to refuse application 3/2025/0801 for 80 dwellinghouses
Plain English for the jargon
DPD: Development Plan Document, part of the Local Plan setting out planning policies and site allocations
HED DPD: Housing and Economic Development Development Plan Document for Ribble Valley
s106: Section 106 agreement, a legal obligation attached to a planning permission requiring developers to contribute to infrastructure or services
BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a requirement for developments to leave biodiversity in a better state than before
TPO: Tree Preservation Order, a legal protection for specific trees or woodlands
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item217a
Resolved
RESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: To REFUSE planning permission on the grounds of Highways (safety and failure to make provision for those with reduced mobility) and Visual Impact. Officers are to draft refusal reasons to be brought back to the next Committee. Councillor S Bibby returned to the meeting.
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
RECOMMENDATION FOR PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
DEFER AND DELEGATE
DATE: 23 JULY 2026 REF: KH CHECKED BY: LH
APPLICATION REF: 3/2025/0801
GRID REF: SD 368799 431728
DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:
PROPOSED ERECTION OF NEW RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 80 NEW HOMES, INCLUDING 30% AFFORDABLE HOUSING, OPEN SPACE AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AT LAND TO THE EAST OF SALESBURY VIEW, WILPSHIRE. CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
WILPSHIRE PARISH COUNCIL
Object to this application for the following reasons:
1. Persimmon Homes has already been refused planning permission twice on this site. The Planning Inspectorate refused an appeal for the following reasons which are also applicable to this application with only 5 houses less than the previous application. The proposal and house types would fail to deliver a high quality visually attractive development sympathetic to the street scene and will still appear incongruous on the hillside to the detriment of visual amenity and be contrary to paragraphs 129 and 135 of the Framework.
2. The proposed development on a steep hillside at the edge of the Wilpshire settlement adjacent to Green Belt would be viewed for miles around and will spoil the unique character of Wilpshire, the ‘Gateway to the Ribble Valley’ and will lessen the importance of the ribbon of Green Belt that prevents Urban sprawl.
3. The only access and exit to the proposed development are Salesbury View, a short narrow and steep road that will be expected to carry at least 150 cars and multiple times journeys from 80 houses onto Whalley Rd.
4. LCC Highways in the last application stated that they ‘are unable to accept the spine road/site road area gradients as they are steeper than 1 in 12 and require amendments to be made to ensure that the internal carriageway and internal pedestrian links do not exceed this limit. The spine road has not changed and these LCC Highway concerns are still applicable to this application on this site.
5. Warrenside Close and Walden Road were cited by the Inspector as positively contributing to an area are in fact in Blackburn with Darwen, which being a town has an overall higher density of housing with different characteristics to the Ribble Valley.
6. There is a very large volume United Utilities Trunk water main running through the application site the route of this pipe has not been exactly determined by United Utilities and may affect the proposed layout as UU will not allow building over or in close proximity to their infrastructure.
7. There is a significant flood risk due to the steep nature of the site with drainage likely being overwhelmed in times of high rainfall, creating an ice rink in winter.
8. Ribble Valley has exceeded housing numbers required by Government and can demonstrate a supply in excess of the 5-yr requirement, negating the need for housing at Salesbury View which will cause an adverse effect on the wider landscape of the area.
9. It has been reported to residents close to the application by United Utilities engineers that the drainage on the A666 is not of a modern standard and would not be capable of taking the extra water runoff from the application.
10. The house building alongside the RVBC boundary with Blackburn with Darwen along Yew Tree [Drive A6119] and the proposed 1500 houses on the site bounded by Parsonage Road Brownhill Drive [A6119] and Sunnybower is creating a conurbation that should be delineated and separated by Green Belt/fields which this application, if successful, will only add to that pressure.
Further to a re-consultation in respect of amended plans, Wilpshire Parish Council further object to the application for the following reasons:
1. The Parish Council feels that a new application should be submitted as the amended plans show that the types of housing are completely different with different arrangements and configuration.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.