Resolved :- That Council’s recommended response to the consultation as set out in the appendix to this report, taking account of any comments expressed by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board at their meeting on 23rd September, 2011 be approved.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
RMBC Response to Localising Support for Council Tax in England
Introduction
Please find below answers to the consultation in respect of localising support for Council Tax in England.
Whilst Members of the Council are supportive of decision making at the most appropriate local level, they see Council Tax Benefit (CTB) as Social Security support for housing costs alongside rent etc, and that any move away from this would be a retrograde step in supporting vulnerable people and tackling poverty, especially child poverty. Notwithstanding the issues arising from a 10% cut in the funding available, they see the removal of CTB and its proposed replacement as a return to an archaic “poor law” approach not befitting the 21st century.
The Authority has not assessed the type of scheme it would like to operate, therefore, the answers are very broad and are constructed in a way that any framework/governance that is set by central government will still provide Authorities with the flexibility it needs to devise a financially viable local scheme.
At the time of writing, it is difficult to consider a scheme other than one that is means tested in some way as it is in the current scheme. Although, this brings with it greater administration requirements it will result in a fairer system where support is withdrawn at gradual rates as income increases.
A scheme where discounts are awarded to certain groups would be easier to administer but would probably result in a less fairer system. It also has to be acknowledged that any scheme that becomes a discount is likely to increase take up for example among pensioners which will lead to pressure on budgets and possibly limit the help Authorities can give to other vulnerable groups.
An alternative suggestion that has been mentioned recently by some stakeholders, although not at this time being promoted by the Council, is adjustments to the single person discount rules, even as far as removing this type of council tax reduction. This would more than save the £500M savings the Government are targeting.
Single Person Discount (SPD) is not income related and allows people to claim 25% off council tax whether they are on income support or a millionaire. This scheme could be changed allowing authorities to vary the discount rate perhaps with a national minimum rate – say 10% and then let authorities agree their own percentages between 10% to 25%. The additional income from this could then contribute to or pay for the localised council tax benefit scheme.
For 2011/12 we are currently reducing council tax for SPD at a total cost of £9.8M. The 10% reduction in benefits is looking to save £2.25M. So if the SPD discount is reduced from 25% to 20% then this may achieve the same level of saving required from the 10% council tax benefit reduction. However, there are people claiming council tax benefit that also claim SPD and therefore, the SPD level would be towards 15% rather than 20%
Draft 12 September 2011 Section 5: Principles of the scheme
5a: Given the Government’s firm commitment to protect pensioners, is maintaining the current system of criteria and allowances the best way to deliver this guarantee of support?
Yes – The Authority cannot see any other way to protect pensioners in the way Government requires without retaining the current criteria. Changes to the current system would invariably lead to winners and losers.
5b: What is the best way of balancing the protection of vulnerable groups with the need for local authority flexibility?
The Authority has taken this question in the context of providing certain guarantees of support to other groups as detailed in 5.6 of the consultation. The Authority feels that should the Government provide further protection to groups laid out in the framework, then it is likely that the scheme would be un-workable given the 10% funding cut.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.