CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council
Audit Committee, Wednesday 16 February 2011

Court of Appeal Decision - Confidentiality at Audit

Noted Finance 1 paper

Audit Committee noted this item on Wednesday 16 February 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item52

Resolved

Resolved :- That the information be noted.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rotherham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Audit Committee

Summary

To report to Audit Committee a significant recent case regarding the rights of persons interested to inspect documents at audit.

Recommendations

That the report be received.

Page 1 7. Proposals and Details

In the case of R (Veolia ES Nottinghamshire Limited) v Nottinghamshire County Council, the Court of Appeal has recently considered the rights of electors to inspect the documents during the audit of a Council’s accounts.

Section 15 of the Audit Commission Act 1998 provides that at each audit under the Act, any persons interested may:-

(a) inspect the accounts to be audited and all books, deeds, contracts, bills, vouchers and receipts relating to them, and

(b) make copies of all or any part of the accounts and those other documents.

The case concerned the County Council’s Waste PFI Contract that Veolia held. A local elector applied to the Council to exercise his right to inspect and take copies of the contract documents. These included the schedules to the waste contract and Veolia’s monthly invoices for work done under the contract.

The contractor applied for an injunction to prevent the Council disclosing the documents, claiming that they did not fall within the statutory right of inspection and copying and that they had been supplied to the Council on a confidential basis. The information was valuable to commercial competitors and to its sub-contractors and if any of the information were to enter the public domain, it would damage its ability to compete on bids with other local authorities and impair its ability to hold down sub- contract prices under the contract.

At first instance, the Administrative Court reviewed the background to the 1998 Act and relevant case law. The Court held that section 15 gave those with a real and close interest in a Council’s activity the opportunity to scrutinise its accounts, so that they could consider whether the Authority’s arrangements were lawful and secured value for money. Whilst there must be a factual connection between the accounts to be audited and the documents to be inspected and copied, a broad meaning was given to “accounts” as meaning the general ledger and any account feeding into it. Applying this approach, the Court held that the schedules to the Waste Management Contract and the monthly invoices were documents that related to the accounts and so the elector was entitled to inspect and take copies of them.

Regarding confidentiality, it was held that as there was a confidentiality protection in section 15 as regards personal information, this showed that Parliament had addressed the issue and had not considered it necessary to extend protection to commercial cases.

The contractor, Veolia, appealed against this decision. In doing so, they raised two further grounds of challenge. The first was that section15 had to be read, so as to preserve confidential information under domestic law, or under the European Convention on Human Rights. The other was that the public inspection provisions of the 1998 Act, permitted use of disclosed information only for the purposes of the Act itself, so that even if inspection had to be granted, the obligation of confidence remained and was preserved outside the scope of the audit.

Page 2 The Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Administrative Court as regards the scope of section 15. The Court noted that the language of section 15(1) pointed to a wide interpretation. It was clear that payments made under the contract and the contractors’ invoices were embodied in the income and expenditure account, which was the kernel of the Council’s Statement of Accounts. In all the circumstances, the documents did relate to the Council’s accounts.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Court of Appeal Decision: Confidentiality at AuditDecisions 38 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

5 of 5 attended
AS
Councillor Alex SangsterChairman, present
JG
Councillor John GildingMember, present
BK
Councillor Barry KayeVice-Chairman, present
NL
Councillor Neil LicenseMember, present
KS
Councillor Kath SimsMember, present

On this subject at Rotherham

Search all
  1. Court of Appeal Decision - Confidentiality at AuditThis decision
  2. Appeal Decision - Against retrospective permission for raising rear garden 300mm and erection of new front boundary wall at No.11 Hoober Court, Rawmarsh for Mr. G. Watson (RB2011/0404)Noted
  3. Appeal Decision - Against a refusal of a full planning application for a Change of Use to hot food takeaway (Use Class A5) and installation of new shop front and ventilation flue at Unit 3-4, Taylors Court, Parkgate, Rotherham (RB2009/1284)Noted
  4. Appeal Decision - Against refusal of planning permission for the erection of a two-storey building comprising of 6 flats with associated parking and bin store at land at rear of 293 Kimberworth Road, Kimberworth for Robinson Court Properties Ltd. (RB2008/1532)Noted
  5. Appeal Decision – Appeal against refusal of planning permission for the erection of a single storey rear extension at 1 Nabeel Court, Moorgate, Rotherham (RB2006/0215)Noted
  6. Appeal decision - Against condition 3 of planning permission for the erection of dormer windows to front, sides and rear and formation of rooms in roofspace at 5 Pinchfield Court, Wickersley, Rotherham (RB2005/1561)Noted

More from Rotherham Audit Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 Sep 2026 Exclusion of the Press and Public- That, under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the meeting for... Decided Open
24 Sep 2026 Minutes of the previous meeting held on 28th July, 2026- That the minutes of the previous meeting of the Audit Committee be approved as a correct record of proceedings. Approved Open
24 Sep 2026 External Audit Progress Report and Sector Update- That the progress and sector updates be noted. Noted Open
24 Sep 2026 Code of Corporate Governance- That the refreshed version of the be received and noted. Noted Open
24 Sep 2026 Anti-Money Laundering Policy Review- (1) That the revised Anti-Money Laundering Policy be received and noted. (2) That the actions being undertaken to r... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies