Resolved :- (1) That areas of concern raised in external inspections or reviews be referred to the relevant Select Commission on a timely basis alongside a plan detailing what action was proposed to address identified areas of improvement. (2) That the Corporate Performance, Intelligence and Improvement Team ensure that learning from the reporting of areas of concern and, in particular the issues arising from the spotlight review, be applied to inform how performance management information was shared and acted upon. (3) That future performance reports and scorecards should signpost Members clearly to areas of declining performance and actions taken to address these. (4) That further details be provided to the Improving Places Select Commission to clarify how Council priorities linked to the skills agenda and community engagement would be delivered by Rotherham and North Notts College and how outcomes would be reported to Members. (5) That the Council’s representatives on the Sheffield City Region Combined Authority Scrutiny Panel be asked to keep oversight of the devolution of adult education provision to ensure good outcomes for Rotherham learners.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
4.1This paper outlines the outcomes of the spotlight review following the Ofsted Inspection of Adult Community Learning (ACL) by members of Improving Lives Select Commission.
5 Context
5.1In June 2017, an Ofsted inspection of RMBC Adult and Community Learning provision delivered a judgement “that the quality of teaching, learning and assessment is now inadequate and the proportion of learners who stay to the end of their course and achieve a qualification is low”. Delivery of this service has since been transferred from the local authority to Rotherham and North Notts College (RNN). Of the approximate 1400 learners registered for the 2016/17 academic year, the majority were enrolled on non-accredited courses, which included family learning, with approximately 25% enrolled on courses leading to qualifications, including functional skills or English for speakers of other language. The ACL Ofsted reported concerns about the monitoring of progress and assessment; poor standard of teaching provision and inadequate support and guidance.
5.2It was agreed that a small cross-party working group would be established to examine what actions had been taken to address the issues raised by the Ofsted inspection. In undertaking the review, Members wanted to seek assurance: That there was a clear understanding of the issues leading to the inadequate judgement in June 2017; That the issues raised in the 2017 Ofsted inspection of Adult and Community Learning have been addressed; and That there are clear plans in place to ensure that adult learners have pathways to secure employment or skills training.
5.3The following Members undertook the spotlight review on Tuesday 6th March 2018: Cllr Chris Beaumont; Cllr Maggi Clark (Chair); Cllr Victoria Cusworth.
Cllr Peter Short also contributed to the planning meeting which determined key lines of enquiry for the spotlight review.
5.4The conclusions and recommendations made by Members are based on information gathered during the course of the review and examination of related documentation. This documentation included: Ofsted: Further education and skills inspection report – Rotherham Borough Council (20 -23 June 2017, published 28 July 2017)
5.5The review group thanks the following Cabinet Member for Children and Young People’s Services and officers for their co-operation with this inquiry. Cllr Gordon Watson, Deputy Leader (Lead Member Children and Young People Services) Ian Thomas, Strategic Director for Children and Young People Services (CYPS)1 Dean Fenton, Head of Service – School Planning, Admissions & Appeals, CYPS Aileen Chambers, Head of Service - Early Years and Childcare, CYPS
6 Key Issues
6.1The Ofsted report flagged areas of concern arising from the previous inspection which had not been addressed in a timely manner. It further identified that quality improvement plans had not been enacted quickly enough and Elected Members had not received clear information about performance. Members sought explanation as to the circumstances behind these issues. Whilst acknowledging that ACL is a small part of CYPS provision overall, in light of previous Council governance failings outlined in the Casey Report2, Scrutiny Members wanted to be assured that wider issues around oversight and governance had been addressed.
6.2Events leading to the inadequate judgement in June 2017:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of the Previous Meeting- That the Minutes of the meeting of the Improving Lives Select Commission, held on 15 September 2026, be approved as...
Minutes of the Previous Meeting- That the minutes of the meeting of the Improving Lives Select Commission, held on 21 st July, 2026 be approved as a...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.