DECISION THAT THE OBJECTIONS BE OVERRULED AND THE RADCLIFFE ON TRENT NO.1 TREE PRESERVATION ORDER 2017 BE CONFIRMED AS MADE. Councillor Butler, as ward councillor for Cotgrave, vacated the Chair and withdrew from the meeting for consideration of the next item. Councillor John Stockwood took the Chair for the item.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk
Objection The inclusion of T3, Horse Chestnut, within the Tree Preservation Order
Ward Radcliffe on Trent
THE SITE AND SURROUNDINGS
1. The Radcliffe on Trent No.1 Tree Preservation Order (TPO) protects 3 roadside trees at 7 Cliff Drive, an Oak, Walnut and Horse Chestnut. The site contains an unoccupied dwelling which is barely visible from the road due to an overgrown garden which contains a range of trees and shrubs, the majority are poor quality and are not signification, but the protected trees are prominent mature specimens. The property is located in a corner plot opposite to the turning for Trent View Gardens and the end of Footpath No.9 which links Cliff Drive to Cliff Walk. Cliff Drive contains a range of property styles and ages dating back to the 1940’s; it has a leafy suburban character with roadside grass verges, hedges and scattered trees.
DETAILS OF THE TREE PRESERVATION ORDER
2. The TPO was made following a request for pre-application advice from a firm of planning and property consultants for the construction of 3 dwellings. The layout plan required the majority of the site to be cleared and would have required the removal of all 3 of the large roadside trees. As the trees on the site were visible to the public, not protected and there was a reasonably foreseeable chance they could be felled a TPO was made.
3. The TPO was made on the 7 August 2017. Under the Town and Country Planning (Tree Preservation)(England) Regulations 2012 the TPO takes effect provisionally and needs to be confirmed within 6 months of the date it was made. An objection has been received and the Council is required to consider it before deciding whether the TPO should be confirmed or not, if it is confirmed it is possible to modify it to make changes. 4. Following the making of the TPO planning permission has been granted for 2 dwellings, reference 17/01818/FUL. The application showed all 3 of the protected trees to be retained.
OBJECTION
5. An objection has been made to the inclusion of T3, a Horse Chestnut tree located in the northern corner of the site. The grounds for the objection are that it is not in the interests of public amenity and does not justify long term protection for the following summarised reasons:
The tree has an infestation of Horse Chestnut leaf miner, an insect pest which causes severe damage to the leaves on an annual basis. The impact of repeated infestations will lead to an overall energy loss and negative impact on the tree’s long term vitality and growth.
It is reasonable to assume the tree has, or will eventually succumb to, Bleeding Canker of Horse Chestnut, a serious and widespread problem of Horse Chestnut trees. When the associated cankering lesions become extensive the entire trunk may be girdled and the tree will inevitably die and have to be removed.
The tree is a multiple-stemmed specimen and the form will have led to tight branch unions with partially included bark. Such weak unions are more prone to failure, and failure at weak forks is frequent in this tree species. The tree is currently sheltered by existing buildings and other trees which are to be removed as part of development works. This will lead to an increase in the likelihood of branches or stems snapping.
The crown of the tree is more dominant to the north and is overhanging into the adjacent footpath and road. As such, the tree will require ongoing crown pruning to avoid obstructions with pedestrians and vehicles. This work will reduce the visual amenity provided by the tree and the associated pruning wounds may lead to decay. The tree species has a very soft heart wood with poor resistance to fungal decay.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.