CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rushcliffe Borough Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 12 July 2018 at 6.30pm

Planning Applications

Refused Planning 7 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Thursday 12 July 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item7

Resolved

DECISION REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS 1. The proposal would result in the demolition of the former school and school masters house; these are considered to be non-designated heritage assets. The application has not made a convincing case that these buildings are beyond economic re-use and as such insufficient justification has been provided to support the loss of these buildings. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy 11 of the Rushcliffe Local Plan Part 1: Core Strategy, the NPPF and Policy HOU6 c) of the Rushcliffe Borough Non-Statutory Replacement Local Plan which seek to conserve heritage assets. 2. The proposal would result in the replacement of one dwelling and the erection of an additional dwelling. The replacement dwelling would be significantly larger than the dwelling to be replaced and the second dwelling would represent an additional unit on the site. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Policies EN20, HOU4 and HOU6 e) of the Rushcliffe Borough Non-Statutory Replacement Local Plan and the NPPF which seek to restrict new dwellings in the countryside and that where replacement dwellings are sought there would be no increase in the number of units or in the size or impact of the original dwelling. 3. The proposed dwellings, by reason of size, siting, design, massing and materials, would be visually discordant in this rural location, failing to enhance local characteristics and distinctiveness, and would have a detrimental impact on the visual amenity of the site and surroundings. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy 10 of the Rushcliffe Local Plan Part 1: Core Strategy and the NPPF and policies GP2 d), HOU6 d) and g) and EN20 of the Rushcliffe Borough Non-Statutory Replacement Local Plan which seek to ensure high quality design is achieved, that replacement dwellings and development in the countryside is not visually harmful or represent disproportionate increases in the size or impact of the original dwelling. Note to Applicant Negotiations have not taken place during the consideration of the application but pre-application discussions were undertaken and have resulted in the submission of the revised application which is now deemed to be acceptable and could be recommended for approval. However, having considered carefully the proposals, ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting. Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rushcliffe's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

18/00750/FUL Applicant [name removed] Midway House Main Road Upper Broughton Nottinghamshire LE14 3BG

Proposal Demolition of existing house and buildings, and erection of two new dwellings with existing access (revised scheme)

Ward Nevile and Langar

THE SITE AND SURROUNDINGS

1. The site comprises a roughly square parcel of land to the south of Main Road between Upper Broughton and Nether Broughton. The site accommodates the former school buildings which comprise a single storey brick and slate linear building fronting the site and a two storey rendered attached building, the former school masters house. There are extensive extensions to the rear of the buildings. Access is to the east of the buildings with hardstanding to the rear. The site occupies a countryside location.

DETAILS OF THE PROPOSAL

2. The application comprises the demolition of the existing house and buildings and the construction of two new dwellings. The existing access would be used to serve both dwellings with parking and turning provided within the site. The dwellings would be two storey and each comprise four bedrooms.

SITE HISTORY

3. Application ref: 93/01149/FUL approved the erection of a conservatory, parking area and alteration to the access. Application ref: 96/00132/FUL permitted a garage/store. Application ref: 97/00384/FUL for an extension to form retail shop unit and construction of ventilation flue was permitted.

4. Application ref: 17/02195/FUL for the demolition of the house and buildings and the erection of two new dwellings with a new access was refused on the grounds of the loss of a non-designated heritage asset, the erection of an additional dwelling on the site, the visual impact of the dwellings and the restricted visibility of the additional access.

REPRESENTATIONS

Ward Councillor(s)

5. The Ward Councillor (Cllr Combellack) objects stating she is entirely in agreement with the objections raised. “Paragraphs 55, 135, 61 & 64 of the NPPF are relevant. Para 55 allowing for isolated development under special circumstances - in this case where redundant buildings are re-used leading to enhancement of the setting. However, in this case there is no re-use just destruction of a non-designated heritage asset i.e. a Victorian School House and therefore no enhancement of the setting. No exceptional build quality or design is demonstrated. Para 135 should be considered when proposing the demolition of a non-designated heritage asset - The Victorian School and Head Masters House. Para 61/64 refer again to high quality design which this is not.

6. With regard to the highways issue it is recognised locally that this is a dangerous 50 mph section of road and farmers take added safety measures when accessing the fields around the application site. It should also be noted this residential development would be opposite the change of overtaking priority marked on the road. Regarding the original use - a Victorian school generated very little vehicular traffic and in its day general road usage was light. The light industrial use again generated very little traffic, therefore to say there would be a decrease in traffic is, I would respectfully say, incorrect.

7. As this application varies very little from the previous in all but aesthetics the planning contraventions must remain. The applicant has put forward several alternative proposals in the design and access statement and I feel that options four or five could be achieved. Many buildings, schools, chapels and barns are converted to provide accommodation preserving their original appearance. In todays world the modifications required; insulation, lighting, heating, etc. are all achievable with modern materials and technology.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
1. 18.00750.FUL: Midway house, upper BroughtonReport 334 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
2. 18.00947.FUL: New Dwelling 10 Kneeton RoadReport 297 KB Download
PDF
3. 18.00854.FUL: 70 Studland Way WBReport 136 KB Download
PDF
Map 70 Studland Way, West BridgfordReport 230 KB Download
PDF
Map Midway House, Melton Road, Upper BroughtonReport 188 KB Download
PDF
Map The Old Hall, 10 Kneeton Road, East BridgfordReport 213 KB Download
PDF
Planning ApplicationsReport 231 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 15 attended
RB
Councillor Richard ButlerChairman, present
JS
Councillor John StockwoodVice-Chairman, present
BB
Councillor Brian BuschmanCommittee Member, present
NC
Councillor Neil ClarkeCommittee Member, present
ME
Councillor Martin EdwardsCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
JG
Councillor Jean GreenwoodCommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Sue HullCommittee Member, present
RJ
Councillor Rod JonesCommittee Member, present
MM
Councillor Mrs Marie MalesCommittee Member, present
MJ
Councillor Mrs Jean SmithCommittee Member, apologies
JT
Councillor John ThurmanCommittee Member, present
JB
James BateOfficer, in attendance

All 15 on the meeting page

On this subject at Rushcliffe

Search all
  1. Planning ApplicationsThis decision
  2. Planning ApplicationsDecided
  3. Planning ApplicationsDecided
  4. Planning ApplicationsDecided
  5. Planning ApplicationsRefused
  6. Planning ApplicationsDecided

More from Rushcliffe Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
12 Nov 2026 Planning ApplicationsDECISION PLANNING PERMISSION BE GRANTED SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS SET OUT IN THE REPORT PUBLISHED WITH THE AGENDA Cou... Decided Open
8 Oct 2026 Planning ApplicationsDECISION PLANNING PERMISSION BE GRANTED SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS SET OUT IN THE REPORT PUBLISHED WITH THE AGENDA AND... Decided Open
10 Sep 2026 Planning ApplicationsDECISION PLANNING PERMISSION BE GRANTED SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS SET OUT IN THE REPORT PUBLISHED WITH THE AGENDA Decided Open
9 Jul 2026 Planning ApplicationsDECISION Consent be REFUSED FOR REASONS THE DETAILS OF WHICH ARE DELEGATED TO THE DIRECTOR - DEVELOPMENT AND ECONOMIC... Refused Open
11 Jun 2026 Planning ApplicationsDECISION The Elton No.1 Tree Preservation Order 2026 be confirmed without modification FOR THE SPECIFIED REASONS SET ... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies