CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rushcliffe Borough Council
Council, Thursday 7 March 2019 at 7.00pm

Scrutiny Review

Noted Committee 3 papers

Council noted this item on Thursday 7 March 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item49

Resolved

RESOLVED that: a) the CfPS Review of Scrutiny report be noted b) the current scrutiny structure is disbanded at the end of the municipal year c) the creation of the transitional model of scrutiny including the Corporate Overview Group and three themed scrutiny groups of growth, communities and governance be agreed and operational from 1 June 2019 d) the size and proportionality of the new scrutiny groups as outlined in paragraphs 4.13 and 4.16 is agreed e) the Chief Executive explores options for independent support during the transitional period as outlined in paragraph 4.18 f) the Chief Executive to bring forward Terms of Reference for all scrutiny groups to Annual Council to allow nomination to groups to be made.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting. Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rushcliffe's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council

Purpose of report

1.1Between September 2018 and February 2019, the Council has undertaken a review of its scrutiny function with independent assistance from the Centre for Public Scrutiny. A copy of their report is attached at Appendix One.

1.2Following clarification and discussion with officers and the Cabinet, changes to the scrutiny structure are being proposed. It is also proposed that in line with the recommendations of the report that there should be improved training for scrutiny members following the 2019 local elections.

1.3To minimise risk and ensure continuity, a managed and transitional approach to changing the structure was supported and is, therefore, being recommended to Full Council. It is envisaged that the transitional period which involves members of scrutiny will require between 12 and 18 months before fully moving to a revised scrutiny model.

1.4General support for the revised and transitional models, and a willingness to change, was identified in a briefing session with scrutiny chairmen and vice chairmen and, subsequently, an open invitation session for all scrutiny group members. A copy of the main discussion points raised is shown at Appendix Two.

Recommendation

It is RECOMMENDED that Council:

a) Notes the CfPS Review of Scrutiny report contained at Appendix One b) Agrees to disband the current scrutiny structure at the end of the municipal year c) Gives approval for the creation on the transitional model of scrutiny including the Corporate Overview Group and three themed scrutiny groups of growth, communities and governance effective from 1 June 2019 d) Agrees the size and proportionality of the new scrutiny groups as outlined in paragraphs 4.13 and 4.16 e) Requests the Chief Executive to explore options for independent support during the transitional period as outlined in paragraph 4.18 f) Requests the Chief Executive to bring forward Terms of Reference for all scrutiny groups to Annual Council to allow nomination to groups to be made 3. Reasons for Recommendation

3.1The independent review of scrutiny at Rushcliffe Borough Council has identified a number of strengths and areas for improvement with the current structure and operation. To fully ensure that scrutiny is supporting the overall aims of the authority changes, to the structure, training, remit and workload of scrutiny groups are proposed.

4. Supporting Information

Background to the review

4.1Following earlier planning and corporate peer challenges, the Council questioned whether the current scrutiny function (shown below and introduced in 2007) was really adding value to the decision-making process. The reasons for this were: growing frustration of scrutiny members, continuing financial pressures the authority is experiencing, the desire for greater transparency and accountability, and the growing need to ensure resources and members’ skills are utilised more flexible and responsively.

Corporate Community Governance Development Group Group

Performance Partnership Management Delivery Group Board

4.2The Centre for Public Scrutiny (CfPS), an independent consultancy focused on helping public sector organisations deliver effective scrutiny and governance, was engaged to undertake a review of scrutiny between September and December 2018.

4.3The review included desk research looking at what we currently do as well as best practice from around the sector and the recommendations of the Government Select Committee into Scrutiny within Local Government; interviews with a range of councillors and officers; an online questionnaire open to all councillors; and a feedback and scoping session with Cabinet and management team.

4.4Key lines of enquiry provided to the CfPS included:  Is Scrutiny performing as efficiently as it could be?  Is Scrutiny contributing to the overall success of the authority?  Is Scrutiny fulfilling its purpose – i.e. to hold the Executive to account publicly?

Review findings

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendix 1Appendix 1 225 KB Download
PDF
Appendix 2Appendix 2 112 KB Download
PDF
Scrutiny ReviewReport 208 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

39 of 50 attended
TC
Tracey CoopOfficer, in attendance
MM
Councillor Mrs Maureen StockwoodChairman, present
MC
Councillor Mrs Christine JeffreysVice-Chairman, present
RA
Councillor Reg AdairCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Sarah BaileyCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Kevin BeardsallCommittee Member, present
MB
Councillor Martin BuckleCommittee Member, present
BB
Councillor Brian BuschmanCommittee Member, present
RB
Councillor Richard ButlerCommittee Member, present
HC
Councillor Hayley ChewingsCommittee Member, present
TC
Councillor Tina CombellackCommittee Member, present
BC
Councillor Barrie CooperCommittee Member, apologies

All 50 on the meeting page

More from Rushcliffe Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Sep 2026 Appointment of Director and Designated Monitoring OfficerRESOLVED that Elizabeth Warhurst be designated as the Council’s Monitoring Officer from the termination of the term o... Decided Open
17 Sep 2026 Establishment of an Independent Remuneration PanelRESOLVED that: a) the establishment of the Independent Remuneration Panel for the purposes of reviewing the Council’s... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 West Bridgford Community Governance ReviewRESOLVED that: a) the process involved for the delivery of a Community Governance Review and the proposed timetable b... Noted Open
2 Jul 2026 Appointment to the Monitoring Officer Role (Interim)RESOLVED that [name removed] be designated as the Council’s Monitoring Officer (Interim) from Thursday, 2 July 2026. ... Decided Open
21 May 2026 Election of Mayor 2026/27RESOLVED that Councillor Butler be elected as Mayor of the Borough of Rushcliffe for the civic year 2026/27. Councill... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies