CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rushcliffe Borough Council
Corporate Overview Group, Tuesday 16 June 2026 at 7.00pm

Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work Programmes

Agreed Scrutiny 4 papers

AI summaryRushcliffe Corporate Overview Group agreed to scrutinise management of open spaces on new build estates, after hearing concerns about unfair charges. A second scrutiny request was deferred until national policy changes become clearer.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedUnanimous decision to progress open spaces review
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextScope review and set timetableRealistic timetable to follow scope and workload work
Who it affectsResidents on new build estatesPaying varying management charges for open spaces

What was decided

The Group unanimously agreed to progress a scrutiny request on management of open spaces on new build estates, with further work needed to scope the review and identify a timeframe.

A second scrutiny request was not considered suitable at this time and will be revisited when national changes are clearer, with the Group to be kept informed of national consultation progress.

Existing scheduled work programme items were noted to remain in place.

Why

Residents on new build estates face increasing and sometimes inequitable management charges, with concerns about infrastructure maintenance, drainage and adoption of open spaces.

The Assistant Director for Corporate Services and Interim Monitoring Officer noted the issue has been scrutinised multiple times and that limited local powers restrict what the Council can change.

Councillors were supportive of further work to identify local actions, including engagement, policy review and support for residents.

What happens next

Scope the open spaces review and identify an appropriate timeframe, noting it will require significant officer input.

Develop a realistic timetable for scrutiny groups after further consideration of scope and workload.

Keep the Group informed of progress from national consultation and any future changes to legislation that may allow the deferred item to be reconsidered.

Options considered

  • Chosen: Progress open spaces management on new build estates to scrutiny. Councillors supportive of further work to identify local actions including engagement, policy review and resident support
  • Chosen: Defer the other scrutiny request until national changes are clearer. Issue largely driven by national policy and legislation; national consultation may provide a more appropriate basis for scrutiny
  • Rejected: Refer to July 2025 Cabinet Report and lobby central government. Acknowledged as an option but the Group instead chose to progress local scrutiny

Implications

  • Financial: No direct financial implications arising from the recommendations of this report. Report P18
  • Legal: No direct legal implications; report supports effective overview and scrutiny. Report P19
  • Equalities: No direct equalities implications arising from the recommendations of this report. Report P20
  • Other: No direct Section 17 Crime and Disorder, biodiversity net gain, or Local Government Reorganisation implications. Report P22, P24, P26
  • Staffing: The new scrutiny on open spaces will require significant officer input.

Who and where

  • Residents on new build estates in the Borough paying management charges
  • Management companies operating on new build estates
  • The Council's Growth and Development, Communities and Governance Scrutiny Groups Report 4.1
  • Officers supporting scrutiny, led by the Assistant Director for Corporate Services Report P32

Timeline

  • July 2025: Cabinet Report considered the open spaces management issue.
  • February 2026: Work programmes for all scrutiny groups reviewed and agreed by the Corporate Overview Group. Report 1.3, 4.3
  • 2026-06-16: Corporate Overview Group meeting considered two new scrutiny requests and reviewed the work programmes.
  • 2026/27: Scrutiny group work programme year to which any agreed items will be added. Report P7, P30

Plain English for the jargon

  • Corporate Overview Group: Rushcliffe scrutiny group responsible for setting work programmes for the three thematic scrutiny groups, with terms of reference accepted at Council in May 2019.
  • Scrutiny Request Form: Form used by Councillors and Officers to put forward potential items for scrutiny consideration.
  • Cabinet Forward Plan: Schedule of upcoming decisions to be made by the Council's Cabinet, used as a source for scrutiny work programming.
  • Section 17 (Crime and Disorder Act 1998): Statutory duty on local authorities to do all they reasonably can to prevent crime and disorder.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item8

Resolved

It was agreed that the item was not suitable for scrutiny at this time and should be revisited when national changes are clearer. The Group requested to be kept informed of progress from national consultation and any future changes to legislation on the basis that this may allow for this item to be reconsidered. The Group considered a scrutiny request relating to Management of Open Spaces on New Build Estates Cllr Way and Cllr Thomas joined the meeting to present the case for this potential scrutiny. They presented the following: Residents face increasing and sometimes inequitable management charges Charges can vary significantly between estates and residents Concerns include infrastructure maintenance, drainage systems and adoption of open spaces There is growing national attention and local impact on residents The Group expressed a range of views: Strong concern about fairness and impacts on residents, particularly about having to pay twice for service, often poor service from management companies Recognition that issues are largely driven by national policy and legislation Consideration of whether local scrutiny could deliver meaningful change, or would be interacted positively by management companies The Assistant Director for Corporate Services and the Interim Monitoring Officer highlighted that: The issue has previously been scrutinised multiple times Limited local powers restrict the Council’s ability to effect change National consultation may provide a more appropriate basis for future scrutiny Referenced the Cabinet Report of July 2025 which considered this issue, and acknowledged that the Council could lobby central government Councillors were supportive of further work to identify what actions could be taken locally, including engagement, policy review and support for residents. Unanimously, the Group agreed to progress the request to scrutiny, with further work required to scope the review and identify an appropriate timeframe. The Group reviewed the scrutiny work programme. It was noted that: Existing scheduled items remain in place The new scrutiny relating to open spaces will require significant officer input A realistic timetable will be developed following further consideration of scope and workload It was RESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group: a) considered any additional items for scrutiny from the current Cabinet Forward Plan, ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting. Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rushcliffe's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Corporate Overview Group

Purpose of report

1.1The terms of reference for the Corporate Overview Group accepted at Council in May 2019 clearly state that a key responsibility of this Group is to:

• Create and receive feedback on work programmes for the Growth and Development, Communities, and Governance Scrutiny Groups based on the Cabinet Forward Plan, Corporate Strategy, Medium Term Financial Strategy, Capital and Investment Strategy and Transformation and Efficiency Programme.

1.2Each meeting of the Corporate Overview Group considers the work programmes for the Growth and Development, Communities, and Governance Scrutiny Groups as well as any new Scrutiny Requests put forward by Councillors and Officers. Those items that are agreed for scrutiny are included on a future work programme for one of the four Scrutiny Groups.

1.3Work programmes for each of the groups were reviewed in February 2026 to ensure they reflected the current priorities of the Council.

Recommendation

It is RECOMMENDED that the Corporate Overview Group:

a) consider any additional items for scrutiny from the current Cabinet Forward Plan, Corporate Strategy, Medium Term Financial Strategy, Capital and Investment Strategy and Transformation and Efficiency Programme (Appendix One)

b) determine any additional topics to be included in a scrutiny group work programme for 2026/27 for each of the scrutiny groups as presented on newly submitted scrutiny requests (Appendix Two)

c) review the current work programme for each of the scrutiny groups (Appendix Three).

Reasons for recommendation

3.1To fulfil the requirements of the terms of reference for the Corporate Overview Group and ensure effective scrutiny of decisions. 4. Supporting Information

4.1The Council’s scrutiny structure comprises of one Corporate Overview Group and three additional Scrutiny Groups focused on Growth and Development, Communities, and Governance. The Corporate Overview Group is responsible for setting the work programmes for all scrutiny groups based on the Cabinet Forward Plan, Corporate Strategy, Medium Term Financial Strategy, Capital and Investment Strategy and Transformation and Efficiency Programme. Links to these documents can be found at Appendix One.

4.2The Corporate Overview Group considers potential items for scrutiny (submitted by officers and Councillors on a Scrutiny Request Form) at each meeting of the Corporate Overview Group. There are two scrutiny requests submitted for consideration at this meeting as outlined in Appendix Two.

4.3Appendix Three shows the work programmes for all scrutiny groups as agreed in February 2026 by the Corporate Overview Group. The Group is asked to consider if the work programmes remain appropriate and achievable for the current year.

4.4Any additional items identified from the Cabinet Forward Plan, Corporate Strategy, Medium Term Financial Strategy, Capital and Investment Strategy and Transformation and Efficiency Programme, highlighted by members of the Group or raised by officers, should be assessed against the scrutiny request form to inform the decision to include them on a scrutiny group work programme.

4.5It is important to note that the purpose of scrutiny is to: • scrutinise a topic in more depth than the Cabinet can in advance of a Cabinet decision with the purpose of informing the decision to be made by Cabinet • investigate topics of concern to residents resulting in recommendations to Cabinet with the purpose of improving Council services • monitor the progress of the Corporate Strategy to ensure the Council is meeting its stated priorities accepting that this may require more in-depth scrutiny of specific strategic projects at appropriate times • hold the Executive to account on behalf of the residents of the Borough to ensure sound decisions are made.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesReport 182 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Enc. 1 for Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work Programmes?Report 127 KB Download
PDF
Enc. 2 for Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work Programmes?Report 184 KB Download
PDF
Enc. 3 for Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work Programmes?Report 173 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

6 of 17 attended
GW
Councillor Gareth WilliamsChair, present
JB
Councillor Jason BillinCommittee Member, present
AB
Councillor Andy BrownCommittee Member, present
TC
Councillor Tina CombellackCommittee Member, apologies
MG
Councillor Mike GauntCommittee Member, present
LP
Councillor Liz PlantCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor David SimmsCommittee Member, present
KB
Katie BrennanOfficer, in attendance
CC
Charlotte Caven-AtackOfficer, in attendance
SS
Sebastian SoarOfficer, in attendance
RC
Rachel ClackOfficer, expected
ER
Emma RichardsonOfficer, expected

All 17 on the meeting page

On this subject at Rushcliffe

Search all
  1. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesThis decision
  2. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesAgreed
  3. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesDecided
  4. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesDecided
  5. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesDecided
  6. Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesDecided

More from Rushcliffe Corporate Overview Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Sep 2026 Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesIt was agreed that the Assistant Director for Growth, Property and Projects would meet with Councillor’s Combellack a... Agreed Open
16 Jun 2026 Diversity Annual Report and update on the Equality and Diversity StrategyRESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group: a) considered and endorsed the information provided for the Diversity Ann... Decided Open
24 Feb 2026 Mid-point Review of the Corporate StrategyRESOLVED that Corporate Overview Group: a) Considered the information provided outlining the Council’s progress towar... Approved Open
24 Feb 2026 Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesRESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group: a) Considered any additional items for scrutiny from current Cabinet Forw... Decided Open
18 Nov 2025 Financial and Performance ManagementRESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group scrutinised: a) The projected revenue budget efficiency for the year of £0... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies