Development Management Committee decided this item on Wednesday 13 September 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Decision Against an Enforcement Notice dated and served on 28 September 2015 requiring the material change of use of the land from use for agriculture to a mixed use comprising: 1. sale of motor vehicles; 2. the storage of motor vehicles; 3. storage of de-polluted motor vehicles bodies and vehicle parts; 4. general storage; 5. siting of a mobile home; 6. siting of portable buildings; 7. the creation of earth bunds; 8. the creation of a hard-core standing area; 9. the creation of a tarmac car park; and, 10. the erection of watchtower/camera gantry cease at land at former Lafarge Site, Hollybush Lane, Aldershot. Re-determined Ground (f) Appeal ALLOWED resulting in further amendments to the requirements of the Enforcement Notice; However the overall appeal decision remains as originally determined : Appeal DISMISSED and Enforcement Notice UPHELD with variations.
Word for word from the decision Rushmoor published for this meeting.Source: democracy.rushmoor.gov.uk
Development Management Committee Planning Report No. PLN1732 13th September 2017
Appeals Progress Report
1. Appeal Decision
1.1Appeal against an Enforcement Notice dated and served on 28 September 2015 requiring the material change of use of the land from use for agriculture to a mixed use comprising: 1. sale of motor vehicles; 2. the storage of motor vehicles; 3. storage of de-polluted motor vehicles bodies and vehicle parts; 4. general storage; 5. siting of a mobile home; 6. siting of portable buildings; 7. the creation of earth bunds; 8. the creation of a hard-core standing area; 9. the creation of a tarmac car park; and 10. the erection of watchtower/camera gantry cease at:
Land at former Lafarge Site, Hollybush Lane, Aldershot
1.2Members will recall that the substantive decision in respect of this appeal, which was, overall, to dismiss the appeal and uphold the requirements of the Enforcement Notice (with minor amendments reducing the area covered by the Notice; modifying the requirements of the Notice; and the timescale for complying with the requirements) was made on 30 November 2016. This followed a Public Inquiry held at the Council Offices on 18, 19 and 20th October 2016. In this respect the appeal was dismissed on all of the grounds lodged by the appellant, namely:-
Ground (a) : that planning permission should be granted for the unauthorised development the subject of the Notice;
Ground (b) : that the specific breach of planning control alleged by the Notice has not occurred;
Ground (f) : that the requirements of the Notice exceed what is necessary to remedy the breaches of planning control that have occurred; and
Ground (g) : that the time period specified by the Notice for compliance is too short.
1.3However, as was reported to this Committee in February 2017, the appellant was successful in making a High Court legal challenge solely in respect of the Ground (f) appeal decision. This was on the basis that the appeal Inspector had failed to make amendments to the requirements of the Notice to reflect their findings concerning whether or not the material arising from the taking down of the unauthorised bunds could be spread out on the land at the appeal site. Instead, the Notice as amended by the original Inspector continued to require the unauthorised bund material to be removed entirely from the appeal site. The Secretary of State (on behalf of the Planning Inspectorate) conceded that the Ground (f) appeal should be re-determined by a new (second) Inspector. This had the effect of putting the Enforcement Notice back into abeyance (and thereby not in effect) pending the re-determination of the Ground (f) appeal. The second Inspector considered the re-determined Ground (f) under the Written Representations procedure, thereby allowing the Council and the appellants to make written comments for their consideration. The second Inspector made an accompanied site visit on 5 June 2017 and issued his decision on 23 August 2017.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.