AI summaryRushmoor council agrees not to enforce age restriction on Flat 2 Phoenix Court, Aldershot, allowing the estate executor to sell without the pensionable age condition.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedRelates to Flat 2 Phoenix Court only
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextLegal Services to advise requesterWritten confirmation of non-enforcement
Who it affectsFlat 2 Phoenix CourtOne of six age-restricted flats in the block
What was decided
The council is minded not to enforce the Section 52 Agreement age restriction or take action on the breach of Condition 11 of planning permission RSH/04631/1, in respect of Flat 2 only at Phoenix Court. Report 6.1
The Corporate Manager Legal Services is authorised to advise the person making the request of this position. Report 6.1
Why
The request came from the executor of the late Flat 2 occupier, who has had difficulty selling the flat and obtaining probate. Report 3.1
The age restriction was originally imposed because the developer could not provide enough parking to meet the minimum standards of the time, not for social mix reasons, and current parking standards no longer make that distinction. Report 2.1, 5.1, 5.2
The site has 26 parking spaces for 23 flats, more than adequate for its town centre location, so retaining the restriction no longer serves a planning purpose. Report 5.3, 5.4
What happens next
Corporate Manager Legal Services to write to the requester confirming the council will not enforce the age restriction for Flat 2. Report 6.1
Relaxations for three other age-restricted flats at Phoenix Court (Flats 7, 13 and a previous Flat 2 occupant) have already been agreed, and this continues that approach. Report 2.5, 2.7
Options considered
Chosen: Agree not to enforce the age restriction for Flat 2. Parking standards have changed and restriction no longer serves a planning purpose; approach already used for three other flats. Report 5.4, 5.5, 6.1
Rejected: Continue to enforce the age restriction. Original planning reason (insufficient parking under old minimum standards) no longer applies. Report 5.2, 5.3
Implications
Legal: A personal, non-permanent relaxation was previously given in 2005; this decision extends non-enforcement beyond that individual occupant. Report 2.5, 3.2
Other: Five of the six original age-restricted flats would, with this decision, no longer be subject to the restriction in practice. Report 2.7, 5.1
Risk: Earlier refusals in 1989 and 1995 cited on-street parking and highway safety concerns, which officers now consider addressed by the site's current parking provision and town centre location. Report 2.3, 2.4, 5.3
Who and where
The executor of the estate of the late occupier of Flat 2 Phoenix Court Report 3.1
The owner of Flat 5 Phoenix Court (objected, requesting status quo) Report 4.1, P16
Merlin Estates, the management company for Phoenix Court (supported the relaxation) Report 4.1, P17
All 23 flat occupiers at Phoenix Court, who were notified Report 4.1
Timeline
December 1987: Planning permission RSH/04631/1 granted with Section 52 age restriction on six flats. Report 2.1
1989: Application to relax age restriction for Flats 2, 8 and 13 refused. Report 2.3
February 1995: Application to vary Condition 11 for Flat 13 refused on parking and amenity grounds. Report 2.4
February 2005: Personal non-enforcement agreed for then-prospective Flat 2 purchaser, lasting only their period of residence. Report 2.5
August 2006: Development Control Committee agreed relaxations for Flats 7 and 13. Report 2.7
2025-10-08: Committee resolves to advise non-enforcement of age restriction for Flat 2.
Plain English for the jargon
Section 52 Agreement: A legal agreement attached to a planning permission under the Town and Country Planning Act 1971, later replaced by Section 106 agreements.
Condition 11: The planning condition backing up the Section 52 Agreement, requiring occupation of six specified flats to include at least one person of pensionable age.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item37
Resolved
RESOLVED : That the Corporate Manager Legal Services be authorised to advise the person making the request that the Council is minded not to enforce the terms of the Section 52 Agreement, or to take enforcement action in respect of the breach of Condition No.11 of planning permission No. RSH/04631/1, relating to Flat No. 2 only within Phoenix Court.
Word for word from the decision Rushmoor published for this meeting.Source: democracy.rushmoor.gov.uk
2.1Phoenix Court comprises 23 flats divided between a larger three-storey building and a smaller two-storey building. Planning permission for the development was granted under ref.RSH04631/1 in December 1987 and the development was subsequently constructed in about 1989. Attached to the planning permission was a legal agreement under Section 52 of the Town & Country Planning Act 1971 (the pre-cursor to Section 106 agreements in the 1990 Act). One clause of this Agreement placed an age restriction on the occupants of 6 ground floor flats in the three-storey block (Flat Nos.1, 2, 7, 8, 13 & 14) to the effect that they should be occupied by at least one person of pensionable age. The reason for this was that at that time the parking standards were based on minimum standards. The developer proposed provided less than the full parking provision at the time, as the flats were for the elderly and therefore the parking requirement was less.
2.2The legal agreement was also backed-up by the imposition of Condition No.11 of the planning permission, which states:-
“Unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority, the occupation of six specified units of accommodation provided within this scheme shall be limited to include at least one person of sixty years of age minimum or any lower age which is for the time being defined as “pensionable age” in the Social Security Act 1975 or such age as shall replace “pensionable age” in any subsequent statute.”
The reason for the imposition of this condition was “To ensure that the requirement for parking does not exceed the capacity of the site.”
2.3There has been some history of applications seeking the lifting of the age restriction from some flats in Phoenix Court. In 1989 an application for relaxation of the elderly occupancy clause of the legal agreement and planning condition in respect of Flats 2, 8 and 13 was refused (ref.RSH/06230 refers) for the following reason:- “The development as originally permitted was for specialised housing for the elderly. The proposal to convert this partially to general-purpose accommodation, which cannot provide adequate on-site parking, is likely to have an adverse impact upon on-street parking and the visual amenities of the area, which is contrary to policy. Furthermore, the resultant on-street parking would be likely to be a hazard to highway safety in the area.”
2.4In February 1995 planning permission was then refused for the formation of two additional parking spaces, enlargement of bin store and variation of Condition No.11 of planning permission RSH/04631/1 restricting occupancy to those of pensionable age to allow use of Flat 13 as a general purpose flat (ref.95/00021/FUL refers). The reasons for refusal were:-
“Having regard to the:- i) existing lack of residents’ parking which would not be addressed by the proposal; ii) loss of on-street residents’ parking; iii) relationship of the proposed additional parking spaces to flat 1; and iv) the inappropriate location of the bin store; it is considered that the development would result in overflow parking on the public highway, noise and disturbance to Flat 1 and inconvenient refuse disposal arrangements to the detriment of highway safety and residential amenity. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy TR15 and unacceptable when assessed against the criteria in Policy G9 of the Rushmoor Local Plan.”
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.