Item10
Resolved
RESOLVED: That the application for the grant of a Premises Licence be granted as requested. Reasons: The Sub-Committee have considered the representations made by all of the parties this morning. Having read the written representations of the interested parties and listened to what they had to say, the Sub-Committee formed the view that those representations related to concerns as to what may happen primarily outside of the store. Neither of the interested parties presented any evidence of issues relating to any of the 4 Licensing Objectives being apparent at this store. The Sub-Committee are aware of the decision in the case of Daniel Thwaites plc -v- Wirral Borough Magistrates Court – a High Court decision. The Honourable Justice Black held that unless a Sub-Committee is presented with real evidence they should not impose regulation. Sefton Borough Council’s own Licensing Policy states that supermarkets shall generally be permitted to sell alcohol for consumption off the premises throughout the hours they intend to open unless there are good reasons, based on Licensing Objectives for restricting those hours. The Sub-Committee can see no reason to depart from that policy. The Sub-Committee are mindful that the store will need to conform with Sunday Trading hours. The Sub-Committee have noted that [name removed] has withdrawn her objection to the hours requested for the provision of late night refreshment, following the assurance given by the applicant that the provision will only be used for the sale of retail items such as cooked chicken and hot bread. The café/restaurant hours will be restricted, closing for business between 8 and 9 p.m. The Sub-Committee are reassured by the obvious working relationship between the parties and the assurance by the applicant that this will continue. The Sub-Committee take this opportunity to advise all parties that should any problems regarding any of the Licensing Objectives arise in the future, which relate to the store, then the residents do have the right to request a review at that time.
Word for word from the decision Sefton published for this meeting.
Source: modgov.sefton.gov.uk