Item3
Resolved
RESOLVED: That (1) the Premises Licence for Another Place, 60 South Road, Waterloo, be suspended until the premise is re-inspected by Merseyside Police and Merseyside Police are satisfied that the Premises has sufficient polycarbonate / plastic vessels to comply with the Condition of the Licence referred to in (3) below: (2) such inspection to take place within 24 hours of the Premises Licence Holder notifying the Police that the premises is ready for inspection; (3) the Conditions of the Licence be modified as follows: · polycarbonate / plastic containers shall be used after 21.00 hours. In the event that polycarbonate / plastic bottles cannot be provided by the suppliers, all drinks shall be dispensed and served in polycarbonate / plastic containers; and · all glassware must be removed from use by customers by 22.00 hours. Reasons: The Sub-Committee has heard representations from Constable Woods on behalf of Superintendent Johnson and the response from [name removed] and his witnesses, [name removed] and [name removed]. This Interim Review follows a serious glassing incident that occurred at the Premise on the evening of Sunday 16 September 2012. This was a very serious incident, as a result of which [name removed] sustained serious injuries to his face and which resulted in the removal of glass from his eye. Constable Woods’ evidence was that an incident took place at the Premise and relied on CCTV evidence, which was viewed by the Committee, as to the circumstances surrounding that incident. It is clear that [name removed] was assaulted. That is not in dispute. It is clear that persons in the premise cleaned up after the incident and Constable Woods has said that as a result of this action the crime scene was compromised. Constable Woods confirmed that a member of staff called the Emergency Services. [name removed] said that [name removed] family had cleaned the scene to assist the staff and that there had been no malicious intent in this. Maria Hunter, a Personal Licence Holder was in charge of the Premise at the time. [name removed] gave emergency first aid to [name removed] and called the Emergency Services. She encouraged [name removed] to wait for Police attendance. Whilst there may be a dispute as to the preservation of the crime scene, there can be no dispute that a serious crime took place that evening. That crime took the form of an assault involving the use of a glass. This premise has previously been reviewed by a Sub-Committee for a serious glass incident. The Sub-Committee does not accept that just because this type of incident happens, they should not take appropriate steps to prevent any similar incidents happening at this premise in the future. The Sub-Committee considers that the modification of conditions to insist on the use of polycarbonate glasses / vessels after 9 pm is appropriate. The Licence has been suspended to allow the Premises Licence Holders to have time to ensure that there are sufficient polycarbonate glasses / vessels in place. [name removed] indicated that there were adequate polycarbonate glasses / vessels on the premises, however, that was not sufficient assurance for the Sub-Committee that the premise could continue to operate under the terms of the modified Licence. The Sub-Committee was concerned that the staff did not understand the need to preserve the crime scene pending the arrival of Merseyside Police and also by the actions of door staff in allowing patrons to continue entering the premises. It may well be that Merseyside Police and in particular, Constable Woods, may wish to meet with the Premises Licence Holders and all staff to explain the steps that should be taken should any incident take place on the premise that is crime related. The Sub-Committee considers that modification of conditions regarding the use of polycarbonate glasses should prevent a further incident of this nature. Whilst the Sub-committee has only considered events at these premises, they are aware that [name removed] made allegations of similar incidents at other premises in the area. The Sub-Committee suggests that if he is aware of issues or crime and disorder at other premises he should report such matters to Merseyside Police and in particular, Constable Woods for investigation. The matter will be listed for a Summary Review at 10.00 am on Wednesday 17 October 2012, at Bootle Town Hall when the Licensing Committee will review the position and both parties can present further evidence.
Word for word from the decision Sefton published for this meeting.
Source: modgov.sefton.gov.uk