CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Sefton Metropolitan Borough Council
Cabinet, Thursday 3 September 2026

Fleet Replacement Street Cleansing

Refused Executive 1 paper

AI summaryCabinet approved purchase of 13 new street cleansing sweepers, replacing the leased fleet and saving about £150,000 a year from 2027/28, with a £0.948m saving over five years compared to leasing.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedDelegated authority to Assistant Director to award contract
Money£0.948m saving, five yearsAround £150,000 a year from 2027/28
What happens nextProcurement exercise to followExisting leases end when new vehicles arrive
Who it affectsStreet Cleansing Service and residentsCleaner streets across the borough

What was decided

Cabinet approved a pre-procurement exercise to purchase 13 Small Mechanical Sweepers for the Street Cleansing Service, using capital fleet funds from the 2026 budget. Report P1, P4, P26

Cabinet granted delegated powers to the Assistant Director of Operational In-House Services, in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Street Scene, to award the contract. Report P2, P5, P36

Cabinet rejected the option of continuing to lease the fleet, after officers found purchasing would be £0.948m cheaper over five years. Report P38, P39

Why

Officers found leasing has become significantly more expensive because of mileage caps, damage fees and annual inflation of at least 5%, while Public Works Loans Board borrowing now offers better value. Report P11, P12, P13, P42

The new vehicles have lower emission engines and modern multi-purpose attachments, helping the Council meet its Net Zero target by 2030 and improving operational resilience. Report P17, P18, P20, P46

Frontline staff trialled several vehicles and fed back to the Transport Department on service and cost efficiency. Report P10, P15, P49

What happens next

Officers will run a pre-procurement exercise and tender for 11 three and a half tonne and 2 five tonne sweepers. Report P4, P14, P35

The existing operating leases will be ended and the current vehicles returned once the new fleet is procured. Report P27

Public Works Loans Board loan repayments will begin in 2027/28, freeing about £33,000 a month in 2026/27 while leases are wound down. Report P24, P29

The money

  • £79,703 Purchase cost per 3.5 tonne sweeper, 11 vehicles Report P23
  • £95,757 Purchase cost per 5 tonne sweeper, 2 vehicles Report P23
  • £1,068,247 Total purchase cost for 11 three and a half tonne vehicles Report P23
  • £1,224,669 Total five year cost for all 13 vehicles at 5.13% PWLB rate Report P23, P24
  • £244,933 Annual revenue cost to be met from existing service budget Report P25
  • £393,150 Current annual leasing cost of the existing fleet Report P28
  • c£150k Estimated annual saving from 2027/28 against current lease cost Report P28
  • c£33k Additional monthly saving in 2026/27 once leases end Report P29
  • £30,242 Average lease cost per vehicle per year Report P41
  • £393,146 Total annual lease cost for the 13 vehicles Report P41
  • £2,172,380 Total five year cost of continuing to lease the fleet Report P41
  • £0.948m Lower cost of purchasing compared with leasing over five years Report P39
  • 5.13% Current Public Works Loans Board annuity loan interest rate Report P23, P24

Options considered

  • Chosen: Purchase 13 Small Mechanical Sweepers using a Public Works Loans Board loan. Lower whole life cost, supports Net Zero 2030 target and modernises the fleet Report P22, P23, P34, P39
  • Rejected: Continue with operating leases for the existing fleet. Costs are significantly higher, with annual inflation of at least 5% and extra mileage and damage fees Report P11, P12, P38, P39, P42

Implications

  • Financial: Switching to purchase saves around £150,000 a year from 2027/28 and £0.948m over five years compared with leasing. Report P28, P39
  • Financial: Capital cost is already within the approved capital programme; the £244,933 annual revenue cost is met from existing service budgets. Report P25, P26
  • Climate: New vehicles have lower emission engines and high efficiency vacuum systems, supporting the Council's Net Zero 2030 target and reducing urban air pollution. Report P17, P18, P46
  • Risk: Not proceeding would leave Street Cleansing facing significantly higher fleet costs. Report P31
  • Other: Multi-purpose vehicles with interchangeable attachments give operational flexibility and resilience, useful during more frequent extreme weather. Report P20, P34
  • Legal: No legal implications identified. Report P30
  • Equalities: No equality implications identified; positive impact noted for children and young people from a cleaner borough. Report P43, P45
  • Staffing: No staffing or HR implications. Report P33

Who and where

  • Street Cleansing Service staff and management Report P1, P8, P15
  • Residents across the borough, particularly in high footfall areas Report P8, P18, P45
  • Children and young people in the borough Report P45
  • Council Transport Department Report P7, P10, P15

Timeline

  • Following expiry of the call-in period: Decision implemented and pre-procurement exercise can begin Report P53, P54
  • 2026/27: Existing leases ended; savings of about £33,000 a month while loan repayments have not yet started Report P27, P29
  • 2027/28: Public Works Loans Board loan repayments begin and annual saving of around £150,000 starts Report P28, P29
  • 2030: Council's Net Zero target date that the new vehicles help to meet Report P17

Plain English for the jargon

  • Public Works Loans Board (PWLB): A UK government body that lends money to local authorities for capital projects, used here to fund the sweeper purchase.
  • Small Mechanical Sweepers: Vehicles from 2.5 to 5 tonnes used to clean high footfall areas, pavements, channels and street paving.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item46

Resolved

The proposal to purchase a new fleet of 13 Small Mechanical Sweepers for the Street Cleansing Service would provide a more cost-effective and sustainable solution than continuing with operational leasing arrangements, delivering lower whole-life costs and improved value for money for the Council. The replacement fleet would support the ongoing delivery of efficient and resilient street cleansing services across the Borough, provide operational flexibility through modern multi-purpose vehicle technology, contribute towards the Council’s fleet renewal programme, and assist in achieving the Council’s Net Zero ambitions through the introduction of lower-emission vehicles. The procurement was also necessary to replace the existing leased fleet and ensure continuity of service provision. Alternative Options Considered and Rejected: Lease Option The option to continue to lease the fleet via operating lease was rejected given the significantly higher costs compared to the option of purchasing these directly. Purchasing resulted in a lower cost of £0.948m over the five years compared to leasing.
Word for word from the decision Sefton published for this meeting. Source: modgov.sefton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Sefton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet, 5 pages

Summary

This report requests approval to undertake a procurement exercise to renew the Street Cleansing fleet of Small Mechanical Sweepers on behalf of the Street Cleansing Service.

To grant delegated authority to the Assistant Director of Operational In-House Services, in consultation with Cabinet Member for Street scene to approve any subsequent procurement exercise.

Recommendation(s):

(1) Cabinet note the request contained within this report and grant approval to commence the pre-procurement exercise to purchase a number of Street Cleansing Mechanical Brush Sweepers as detailed within this report utilising the Capital Fleet funds approved in the Budget Report for 2026.

(2) Grant delegated powers to the Assistant Director of Operational In-House Services in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Street scene, to award the contract from the procurement exercise to the preferred supplier.

1. The Rationale and Evidence for the Recommendations

As part of the ongoing Fleet Renewal Programme for the Council the Transport Department have evaluated options for the revised Street Cleansing operational requirements. Historically the service has favoured operational lease agreements due to changes in service delivery and access issues with a range of different type and size vehicles being utilised throughout the year, season dependent.

These vehicles known as Small Mechanical Sweepers, are used to clean high footfall areas, pavements, channels and street paving. The vehicles have proven fundamental in the provision of Street Cleansing and assist in achieving increased coverage of cleansing across the borough.

The Street Cleansing Service has evaluated its core operation with greater emphasis on mechanisation being the most beneficial and cost effective for service provision as per the review detailed in the Corporate Transformation Project, Pillar 2: Better Outcomes & Sustainable Services.

As a result, the Transport Department have arranged for colleagues in Street Cleansing to trial several vehicles on the market with a view to purchasing utilising budget allocated within the existing capital programme.

Whilst leasing this specific type of vehicle does provide variety and options to interchange models, the lease market has become increasingly more expensive with rising costs such as mileage caps, and higher fees for damages.

The vehicle leasing market has shifted significantly, and the financial advantages it once offered over purchasing and ownership have reduced considerably.

In contrast, the option to purchase utilising the Public Works Loans Board (PWLB) in the current market is far more favourable, highly beneficial and represents a greater return on investment in assets for the Council. The Street Cleansing fleet includes 13 x Small Mechanical Sweepers.

These vehicles vary in size and specification, ranging from 2.5t used on pedestrianised areas, up to 5t for use on main arterial routes and carriageways.

The Transport Service have worked collaboratively with operational staff and management to identify vehicles that successfully align both service delivery and cost efficiency.

It is essential, given the pressure on financial resources across the Council that the service re- address the current financial position and adopt the most suitable cost-effective approach to maximise the return on investment.

A primary aim and objective when looking to purchase new vehicles is to assist in achieving the Councils Net Zero target by 2030.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Fleet Replacement Street CleansingReport 5 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 31 attended
MA
Cllr. Marion AtkinsonChair, present
LD
Cllr. Liz DowdMember, apologies
PH
Cllr. Phil HartMember, present
PH
Cllr. Peter HarveyMember, present
CH
Cllr. Christine HowardMember, present
PL
Cllr. Paulette LappinMember, present
IM
Cllr. Ian MoncurMember, present
DR
Cllr. Diane RoscoeMember, present
JW
Cllr. Joanne WilliamsMember, present
PP
Phil PorterOfficer, expected
CM
Chris MoisterOfficer, expected
SW
Stephen WatsonOfficer, expected

All 31 on the meeting page

On this subject at Sefton

Search all
  1. Fleet Replacement Street CleansingThis decision
  2. Vehicle Replacements - Refuse Collection Fleet and Specialist Transport VehiclesApproved
  3. Vehicle Replacements - Refuse Collection Fleet and Specialist Transport VehiclesRefused

More from Sefton Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Sep 2026 Minutes of the Previous MeetingDecision Made: That the Minutes of the meeting held on 23 July 2026 be confirmed as a correct record. Decided Open
3 Sep 2026 Review of Adult Social Care Charging PolicyThe recommendations in the report had been developed following a review of Adult Social Care charging arrangements, e... Approved Open
3 Sep 2026 Approval of Legal Documentation for Academy Conversions – Voluntary ConversionsThe Archdiocese of Liverpool had determined that all Catholic schools in Sefton would become part of the Pope Francis... Agreed Open
3 Sep 2026 Procurement of Supported Lodgings Accommodation for Young People Aged 16+The proposed procurement would secure a compliant, regulated and more financially sustainable Supported Lodgings arra... Refused Open
3 Sep 2026 Corporate Microsoft O365 and Azure Cloud EnvironmentThe Council’s Microsoft provisions were currently provided under contract by Phoenix Software Ltd. The contract start... Refused Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies