Motion Submitted by Councillor Pugh - Commercial Confidentiality and Exempt Information
DecidedCommittee1 paper
AI summarySefton Council to hold third party training for all councillors on commercial confidentiality and exempt information rules, in a format agreed with party leaders.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedFor all councillors, run by a third party
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextThird party training to be arrangedFormat to be agreed with party leaders
Who it affectsAll councillorsOn confidentiality and exempt information rules
What was decided
The Council agreed to organise a training seminar for all councillors on the legitimate extent of commercial confidentiality and exempt information regulation. Report P13
The seminar is to be run by a third party, such as the LGA, in a format agreeable to party leaders. Report P13
The Council acknowledged an inevitable conflict and tension between the need for commercial confidentiality and the public interest in accountability. Report P11, P12
Why
The Council notes what it describes as the excessive use of waivers and the appreciable impact on the revenue budget of the council's commercial undertakings and regeneration schemes. Report P9
It recognises that in these areas councillors lack sufficient information to provide proper assurance to their constituents. Report P10
The Council believes in maximum transparency and openness in the use of public money and that councillors have a duty to ensure council taxpayers' money is spent in an efficient, transparent and accountable way. Report P7, P8
What happens next
Officers and party leaders to make arrangements for a third party, such as the LGA, to deliver the training seminar for all councillors. Report P13
Options considered
Chosen: Motion on commercial confidentiality and exempt information, as moved by Councillor Pugh and seconded by Councillor Shaw. Put forward as a notice of motion at the Council meeting on 17 September 2026 Report P1, P3, P4
Implications
Governance: Introduces a new councillor training programme on transparency, commercial confidentiality and the regulation of exempt information. Report P13
Financial: The motion flags concerns about the revenue budget impact of excessive use of waivers in commercial and regeneration schemes. Report P9
Risk: The Council identifies a recurring tension between commercial confidentiality and public accountability, said to be commonly exemplified at the council. Report P12
Who and where
All councillors, who will be offered the training seminar Report P13
Council taxpayers, whose money the motion says should be spent efficiently, transparently and accountably Report P8
External contractors and the council's commercial and regeneration schemes, where the use of waivers is noted Report P9, P11
Timeline
17 September 2026: Motion moved and seconded at the Council meeting Report P2, P3, P4
Plain English for the jargon
LGA: Local Government Association, a national body that supports and represents councils in England and Wales.
Waiver: A procurement decision to award a contract without a full competitive process, bypassing normal tendering rules.
Exempt information: Information that a council may withhold from public disclosure under the Local Government Act 1972, such as commercially sensitive or contract related material.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item60
Resolved
Commercial Confidentiality and Exempt Information This Council (1) believes in maximum transparency and openness in the use of public money (2) believes that all councillors have the duty to ensure that council taxpayers’ money is spent in an efficient transparent and accountable way (3) notes that the use of waivers has decreased in volume and value as reported to Audit & Governance Committee in August 2026. (4) recognises that the report to Audit & Governance Committee, including the exempt ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
Word for word from the decision Sefton published for this meeting.Source: modgov.sefton.gov.uk
(I) believes in maximum transparency and openness in the use of public money
(2) believes that all councillors have the duty to ensure that council tax payers’ money is spent in an efficient transparent and accountable way
(3) notes the excessive use of waivers and the appreciable impact on the revenue budget of the council’s commercial undertakings and regeneration schemes
(4) recognises that it is in these areas where councillors lack sufficient information to provide proper assurance to their constituents
(5) acknowledges that there is a need for the council to observe a degree of commercial confidentiality both in it’s own commercial dealings and it’s relationship with external contractors
BUT notes (6) the inevitable conflict and tension between that need and the public interest and accountability- a conflict commonly exemplified in this council
And therefore in the interest of maximum openness and transparency agrees to organise a training seminar for all councillors on the subject of the legitimate extent of commercial confidentiality and exempt information regulation - to be organised by a third party (such as the LGA) in a format agreeable to party leaders.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Treasury Management Outturn 2025/26That the Treasury Management position during 2025/26 and the update to 31 July 2026, to review the effects of decisio...
Membership of Committees 2026/27That the revised membership of the Planning Committee, as set out below, be appointed until the Adjourned Annual Coun...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.