That listed building consent be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 1) The works to which this consent relates shall begin before the expiration of three years from the date of this consent. In pursuance of section 18 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. 2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: 11-003(08)002, 11-003(02)001 and layout of front window received on the 2 March ... view the full minutes text for item 45.
Word for word from the decision Sevenoaks published for this meeting.Source: cds.sevenoaks.gov.uk
4.7- SE/12/00571/LBCALT Date expired 27 April 2012
PROPOSAL: Replace existing single glazed windows with white painted wooden double glazed windows.
LOCATION: 10 St Ediths Road, Kemsing TN15 6PT
WARD(S): Kemsing
ITEM FOR DECISION
This application was originally reported to the Development Control Committee on 24 May 2012. It was called to Committee by Councillor Stack as she believes the weight being given to the justification for doing the work is inappropriate and therefore disagrees with the recommendation. The application was deferred so that further information could be submitted by the applicant regarding the need to replace the windows.
RECOMMENDATION: That listed building consent be REFUSED for the following reasons:-
The Local Planning Authority is not satisfied the need for the replacement windows has been demonstrated to be appropriate for the listed building as supported by the National Planning Policy Framework.
Introduction
1 This application was deferred from the May Committee (Appendix A – previous report) for the submission of a conditions survey of the windows to be replaced by the applicant. This report has now been received and the report is attached in Appendix B for Members’ information.
Comments from SDC Conservation Officer on Report from Gulliver Timber
2 It is interesting to note that the company does not actually make any recommendations on individual windows. The majority of the windows appear to have wet rot, whilst the remaining sashes are swollen. This is in part consistent with my own conclusions.
3 No indication is given as to whether these windows can be repaired, as all conservation guidance and principles advise, but the report concludes with a ‘catch all‘ phrase about an assumed desire for uniformity not supported by any rational argument. This demonstrates, in my view, a lack of understanding or knowledge of conservation principles.
4 Many listed buildings have been extended over the centuries, resulting in elements of different eras, styles and details, including windows. These become part of the history and evolution of the building and to make alterations introducing uniformity both loses historic fabric and damages the overall character. Thus uniformity is neither required nor desirable.
5 If only one window in a listed building needs to be replaced because it is beyond repair then this is not an argument for condemning all the windows in that (Item No 4.7) 1 building. Perfectly sound or readily repaired timber frames should not be discarded for the sake of installing new material. This is not sustainable on any reasonable terms or as required by the NPPF (especially paragraphs 132 and 133), EH Conservation Principles (paragraph 149 in particular) or the Practice Guide to PPS5. Paragraph 179 of the latter document for example states:
6 ‘The fabric will always be an important part of the asset’s significance. Retention of as much historic fabric as possible is therefore a fundamental part of any good alteration or conversion, together with the use of appropriate materials and methods of repair. It is not appropriate to sacrifice old work simply to accommodate the new.’
7 There would be no public benefit resulting from the works proposed and indeed considerable historic fabric would be lost and the overall character of the listed building damaged. My recommendation for refusal of consent therefore stands.
Officer’s further appraisal
8 As set out in paragraph 23 of the previous committee report there needs to be a clear and convincing justification for the replacement of the historic fabric of a designated heritage asset.
9 The applicant has submitted a report from Gulliver’s, who are a timber treatment specialist. The report does not deal with the windows individually but has grouped them by their rooms. Therefore it is not apparent to the individual condition of each and every window. It implies that the condition of every window in each room is the same.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.