That the implementation of the following recommendations take effect from the date of Annual Council on 13 May 2014: a) the Scrutiny Committee changes to a fixed membership of 9 members plus a Chairman and Vice Chairman with all members of the committee being independent of the Cabinet Advisory Committees; b) the membership of the Cabinet Advisory Committees increase from 10 members to 12 members including the relevant Cabinet and Deputy Cabinet Members on each of the Cabinet Advisory Committees; c) Members be able to sit on more than one Cabinet Advisory Committee; d) with the number of Cabinet Advisory Committees remaining at 5 the Committees should normally meet 4 times a year; e) the Advisory Committees be able to choose their own Chairman; f) the Governance Committee continue to investigate future Governance arrangements in general to allow the newly elected administration in 2015 to consider future governance; g) Portfolio Holders to individually present a report to each ordinary Full Council meeting in the same way the Chairmen of the Select Committees did previously; h) a comprehensive training plan for Members be developed for implementation in May 2015; and i) no Member to be Chairman of more than one Advisory Committee.
Word for word from the decision Sevenoaks published for this meeting.Source: cds.sevenoaks.gov.uk
The governance structure of the Council changed in May 2013, with an ‘early indication’ survey undertaken in October 2013.
This second survey was open from the 3 February to the 14 February, with a response rate of 68.5% (37 of 54 members have responded).
Context
• 70% of respondents had completed the earlier survey, with 72% not having changed their opinion since the last survey; • Of those responding 86.5% said that they had formed an opinion on how the new governance arrangements were working; • 54% of respondents had no special responsibility; and
• A majority of respondents (56%) were backbenchers.
Advisory Committees
• A majority (60%) did not think that Portfolio Holders should Chair Advisory Committees; • 68% said there should be more meetings of the Advisory Committees, with 65% agreeing that 6 Advisory Committee meetings would be about right; • 27% of respondents agreed that the Council would work better with 3 Advisory Committees with more frequent meetings; • 57% of respondents would prefer if Councillors were allowed to sit on 2 Advisory Committees, with 70% of all respondents saying that they think they would have a wider understanding of the work of the Council if they were able to sit on more than one Advisory Committee.
Working Groups
• 60% of respondents believe that working groups work effectively.
Cabinet & Portfolio Holders
• 51% of respondents think there should be more Portfolio Holders (43% disagree); • 51% believe responsibility for matters would be clearer with smaller Portfolio Briefs and more Portfolio Holders (43% disagree); and • 51% think there should be fewer Deputy Portfolio Holders (41% disagree). Scrutiny Committee
• 46% of respondents would prefer Scrutiny to change to a fixed membership rather than the current ‘Pool’ system (32% disagree, with 22% saying that they do not know).
Effectiveness • 56% of respondents believe that the new working arrangements do not improve accessibility of Portfolios and reduce remoteness; • 62% do not feel more engaged in decision making or more able to influence decisions made; • 60% do not feel that training and councillor development has improved; • 58% do not believe that succession planning for Cabinet has improved; • When asked whether the new system has let to an improvement on the previous working arrangements 43% said yes, 43% said no, with the remaining 14% saying that they do not know.
Comments
Respondents were provided with an opportunity to record any comments they had in relation to the questions in the survey. Set out a below is a summary of the issues raised in the 19 comments provided.
Advisory Committees
• They are their to advise the Portfolio and it is therefore right that the Portfolio Holder is able to chair the meeting • Advisory Groups should be able to choose their own Chairman but not adverse to this being the Portfolio Holder if so selected • Preference that they are independently chaired to improve backbencher involvement • Concern that 4 meetings is insufficient • Preference for sitting on more than one Advisory Committee
Working Groups
• Are really helpful in reducing feelings of remoteness and add value to the Council at no additional financial cost • Are a way in which member involvement can increase • Are a way of keeping down the number of Advisory Committee meetings as work can be carried out between meetings • Suggested that all Advisory Committee Members should be involved in working groups • Not all working groups have been effective • Working group subjects could be more substantial • Could be seen as a demotion of the role of Councillors
Cabinet & Portfolio Holders
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.