SE/16/01857/WTPO - Pippin Cottage, The Green, Leigh TN11 8QJ
RefusedCommittee1 paper
Development Management Committee refused this item on Thursday 8 September 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
That consent be refused for the following reason The Council was not satisfied, when balancing the commercial and environmental benefits of the trees, that there was sufficient evidence to justify the loss of these visually very important mature oak trees within the Leigh Conservation Area. The proposed works would result in harm to the amenity value of the trees in the local area and significant harm to the Conservation Area with the loss of these trees. (Cllr. Gaywood was absent from the Chamber at the commencement of this item and took part in debate but took no part in the voting thereon.)
Word for word from the decision Sevenoaks published for this meeting.Source: cds.sevenoaks.gov.uk
PROPOSAL: Removal of 2 Oak trees, T1 and T2 (TPO).
LOCATION: Pippin Cottage, The Green, Leigh TN11 8QJ
WARD(S): Leigh & Chiddingstone Causeway
ITEM FOR DECISION
This application has been referred to Development Control Committee at the discretion of the Chief Planning Officer, due to the potential for a claim against the Council and the public interest response to it.
RECOMMENDATION: That consent be GRANTED subject to the following condition:
1) That the trees are replaced with two new trees of a suitable species, variety and size and at a suitable location to be agreed.
Description of Proposal
1 Removal of two mature Oak trees, T1 and T2 of TPO 10 of 2003 from within the garden of Pippin Cottage, The Green, Leigh, TN11 8QJ.
Description of Site
2 Detached residential dwelling located on the north eastern edge of The Green at Leigh. The trees are located adjacent to the south western boundary of Pippin Cottage overlooking The Green.
Constraints
3 TPO 10 of 2003
4 Leigh Conservation Area
5 Areas of Archaeological Potential
Policies & Material Considerations
6 National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF)
7 National Planning Policy Guidance (NPPG).
Planning History
8 13/03720/WTPO application to fell T1 mature Oak tree and carry out a 30% reduction on T2 – granted.
9 An application (13/03720/WTPO) to fell T1 and reduce T2 by up to 30% was received and validated on the 12th of December 2013. The application was
(Item 5.1) 1 reviewed and consent was granted for the applied for works dated the 31st of January 2014.
10 The reasoning for the grant response was that the applicant had demonstrated that the trees were implicated in the subsidence of the south western ground floor area of the house. Level monitoring had been carried out showing the seasonal changes in levels at the effected part of the dwelling. Soil samples showed shrinkable desiccated clay. Root samples were taken from the area of the affected foundations and tests showed Oak species to be present. T1 and T2 were the only Oaks within the area that could affect this south western corner of the house. There are other trees within the south western vicinity of Pippin Cottage but only Oak roots were found and identified.
11 The 2013 consent has now expired with the consented works not having been carried out.
Consultations
Leigh Parish Council
12 Leigh Parish Council strongly objects to the removal of the Oak trees, and would like to suggest that a crown reduction is carried out and root barriers installed instead.
Representations
13 A petition has been received from [name removed] against the cutting down of the two Oak trees. This petition has 443 signatures upon it. The signatories have signed this petition as they want Sevenoaks District Council to save the two Oaks from being cut down.
Chief Planning Officers Appraisal
Background Information
14 In considering an application, the NPPG advises that the Local Planning Authority (LPA) should assess the impact of the proposal on the amenity of the area and whether the proposal is justified, having regard to the reasons and additional information put forward in support of it (NPPG TPO’s paragraphs 89-100).
15 The NPPG provides guidance on how an LPA should consider applications for works to TPO trees, and this forms the basis of the assessment below.
16 In certain circumstances, compensation may be payable by the local planning authority for loss or damage which results from the authority refusing consent where protected tree roots are implicated. This is a material consideration when assessing whether to grant consent for the works proposed.
17 A new application for works to the TPO trees (16/01857/WTPO) was submitted dated 14th of June 2016. This application is the same as the 2013
(Item 5.1) 2 application but with the difference that the applicant wishes to fell T2 as well as T1 instead of reducing its size.
Principal Issues
18 The principal issues, as set out in the NPPG, are:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.