Resolved
View the decision text for item 11.
Co-operative Executive decided this item on Wednesday 20 January 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
View the decision text for item 11.
Cabinet Wed 20th Jan 2021 Page 1
Street Tree Partnership Working Strategy Consultation Feedback
Agenda Item 12 Background (Section 2 of the consultation feedback report)
Dec 18 Aug 2019 Mar 20 Jul to Oct 20 Page 2
Joint position Sheffield Street Tree Sheffield Street Tree Consultation on statement between Strategy Development Working Strategy Sheffield Street Tree SCC, Amey & Sheffield Group begins to meet signed off by SCC & Working Strategy Tree Action Groups Independently chaired other partners Steering Group by the chief executive published following of the Sheffield & mediated talks Rotherham Wildlife Development Trust Agreed that future management of Sheffield City Council’s street trees to be set out in a new street tree strategy Approach to the consultation (Section 3)
Consultation asked Live on Citizen Launched at Chair of strategy for views on: Space on 16th Jul & Sheffield Tree Week development group Page 3
The vision ran for 12 weeks 2020 (online) chair wrote directly to 65 organisations The six outcomes to promote & enhance & 49 TARAs inviting Sheffield City Council a response Street Trees & their long-term benefits Proposed actions to deliver Representation on the new Sheffield Street Tree Partnership 282 responses received 271 (96.0%) from individuals 11 (4.0%) from organisations
Some voluntary response bias in the consultation response sample Comparison of socio-demographic characteristics Analysis of of individual respondents with the general population of Sheffield, consultation response Page 4
consultation sample indicates:
respondents Over-representation of 55-74s; people from white backgrounds; people living in the West and South West of the city (Section 4) Under-representation of young people aged 16-34; people from BAME backgrounds; people living in the East and North East of the city
Broadly speaking, this type of response bias is common in consultations that are open to the general population of Sheffield, even if explicit attempts are made to boost the sample Several respondents expressed support Some challenge to the working strategy for failing to address the adverse effects that street trees can cause including: Negative impact of street trees if poorly maintained Causing damage to or creating hazards on the Comments on pavement Creating access issues by limiting pavement width the overall especially for wheelchair/mobility scooter users Page 5
Negative mental health impact of street trees strategy blocking light from homes Limiting parking options (Section 5) Some concerns about the current and future role of Amey, the Council & STAG in the future management of street trees Importance of maintaining a progressive attitude, resolving conflicts and ensuring that a wide range of views are taken into consideration We want to see a network of street trees that Sheffield can be proud of: well-maintained and cared for; resistant to the threats of disease and climate change; and delivering many benefits for people and our environment. These benefits include:
Supporting our wildlife – Wildlife habitats & corridors Enhancing our city – Status as a ‘green city’; attracting & retaining students, new workers, investors, visitors Cleaning the air that we breathe – Producing oxygen & providing fresh air Page 6
Vision Improving our health and wellbeing – Green, natural environment; nature ‘on your doorstep’ Helping to reduce our carbon emissions – Offsetting or (section 6) mitigating carbon emission rather than reducing Helping combat the effects of climate change such as flash floods and rising temperatures – Climate emergency; providing shade
Additionally:
Enhancing the local community & being part of the heritage & history of an area Improving the aesthetics of a place Providing a source of food Six outcomes proposed:
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Item 12: PresentationReport | 325 KB | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
STWS Consultation Feedback Report 070121Report | 1.3 MB | Download |
PDF |
Sheffield Street Tree Partnership Working Strategy: Consultation FeedbackReport | 469 KB | Download |
Follow Co-operative Executive at Sheffield and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Apr 2022 | The Sheffield Tobacco Control Strategy and Future Commissioning Model 2022-2027.View the decision text for item 8. | Decided | Open |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Parks Tennis ProcurementView the decision text for item 9. | Decided | Open |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Procurement of an Adult Social Care Mental Health Recovery Framework for people with eligible mental health needsView the decision text for item 10. | Decided | Open |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Procurement for the Care and Support services in Extra Care SchemesView the decision text for item 11. | Decided | Open |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Procurement of an Enhanced Supported Living FrameworkView the decision text for item 12. | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.