FOR (51) Councillors N Bardsley, J Barrow, G Butler, K Calder, D Carroll, L Chapman, S Charmley, T Clarke, S Davenport, J Dean, P Dee, D Evans, R Gittins, S Harris, A Hartley, N Hignett, R Hughes, V Hunt, I Jones, M Jones, S Jones, N Laurens, C Lea, E Lynch, R Macey, P Milner, D Minnery, D Morris, P Moseley, A Mosley, C Motley, P Mullock, P Nutting, K Pardy, W Parr, T Parsons, M Pate, L Picton, E Potter, K Roberts, M Shineton, R Tindall, D Tremellen, K Turley, D Turner, C Wild, B Williams, L Winwood, M Wood, T Woodward, P Wynn AGAINST (10) A Boddington, R Evans, H Fraser, N Green, N Hartin, R Huffer, J Keeley, H Kidd, V Parry, D Vasmer That the amendments to the Pay and Reward Policy be approved as ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Word for word from the decision Shropshire published for this meeting.Source: www.shropshire.gov.uk
1.1As a council we are experiencing significant difficulties recruiting and retaining qualified and skilled staff. The policies and strategies that we have previously employed to combat this (market supplements, honoraria etc.) are reducing in effectiveness and inevitably, there will be greater negative impact on services if this issue is not addressed.
1.2There is evidence from a number of sources of the issues. The initial feedback from the peer review highlighted pay and reward as a barrier to achieving council aspirations. The recent LGA report also evidence the necessity to improve pay to attract and retain staff.
1.3In social care particularly children’s social workers are moving to neighbouring authorities and it is becoming increasing difficult to recruit to the vacancies.
1.4This report sets out the background to the proposed amendments to the Pay and Reward Policy Statement that was previously approved by full council as part of the Financial Strategy. The amendments are required to implement the proposed changes to pay and reward.
Recommendations
2.1That Full Council consider and approve the amendments to the Pay and Reward Policy as set out in Appendix 1.
3.1Pay in the public sector and local government in particular has been restricted since 2010, with no annual pay award in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2014 and any increases capped at 1% since 2016.
3.2In 2011, Shropshire Council made other changes to terms and conditions of employment. Incremental progression through a grade was frozen for two years, sick-pay entitlement was reduced and a number of allowances including essential car user allowance were removed.
3.3The most significant of the changes on the workforce was the cut in pay. Whilst the lowest pay grades were protected the remainder of the workforce was subject to the cut in pay. The reduction was implemented over two years and was a real terms cut of 4.4%. Furthermore, since 2012 this differential from the nationally negotiated rates has increased to 5.71% at its highest.
3.4Terms and Conditions of Employment in Local Government are normally determined by collective bargaining – for workers in local government and schools, pay and other terms and conditions are determined by a negotiating body; the National Joint Council (NJC) for local government services. The NJC is made up of representatives of the employers and the recognised trade unions. In the absence of any local collective bargaining, the changes to terms and conditions were achieved through dismissing and re-engaging the workforce.
3.5Senior pay, which is negotiated differently through the Joint Negotiating Committee for Chief Officers of Local Authorities (JNC) was also impacted by these changes including the cut to pay. In addition to this in, 2013 the top two grades were in effect removed cutting Chief Executive Pay from £180,000 pa to £99,000 pa and reducing Director Pay from £145,000 to £97,000 pa.
4.0Impact of Shropshire Council Pay Rates Being Lower than the National Pay Rates
4.1The impact of these lower rates of pay compared to the rates paid by other local authorities is now impacting significantly on Shropshire Council’s ability to recruit and retain staff with the right skills, knowledge and experience. This is evidenced in a number ways. Failure to fill vacancies and needing to re-advertise in some
Contact: [email protected] 2 cases multiple times. Inability to recruit to certain roles is placing a reliance on agency staff that is expensive and unsustainable.
4.2This is not just limited to areas that have in the past been difficult to recruit to, as we are now experiencing difficulties recruiting to more generalist posts e.g. finance officers and IT technicians.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.