i) That the refurbishment of the entire Shirehall building be approved in principle, subject to a further report to be considered by Cabinet with a final business case, developed designs and final project budget. ii) That the addition of £1.15m to the capital programme to support Stage 3 of the project with delegation to the Director of Place to oversee the production of the final business case be approved. Further option appraisal work be undertaken by officers, at no additional cost and in parallel with the procurement of the design consultants, to ensure that the best value option is secured for the Council. iii) Delegates to the Director of Place, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Corporate and Commercial Support, the development of the procurement strategy for stage 3 of the design process with developed designs brought back to Cabinet and Council for approval together with the final project budget be approved. iv) Further reports be considered by the appropriate overview and scrutiny committee prior to consideration by Council.
Word for word from the decision Shropshire published for this meeting.Source: www.shropshire.gov.uk
In July 2017, the Council appointed a specialist team, led by HLM Architects and Real Estate Works, to consider options to reconfigure and refurbish the Shirehall in order to meet the Council’s priorities to make the Shirehall better suited to modern working and create income generating opportunities.
That initial piece of feasibility work is what we have referred to as Stage 1 of the project and the results were presented to Cabinet on 13th December 2017. The consultants recommended a significant investment to address the problems with the building and achieve the desired project objectives. Cabinet agreed, in principle, to move forward the option of refurbishing the entire building and progressing the necessary due diligence and feasibility work to inform the decision making process.
It was resolved:
i) That in principle agreement to move forward the option of refurbishing the entire building and progressing the necessary due diligence and feasibility work to inform the decision making as outlined in the report be approved.
ii) That following the completion of further work and due diligence a report is brought back to Cabinet and then Council with final recommendations, including detailed costings.
iii) That authority be delegated to the Director of Place in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Corporate and Commercial Support to progress all works in accordance with recommendations i) and ii) above.
It was agreed that a sum of £300,000 should be added to the capital programme to enable to project to proceed to Stage 2, which would provide significantly increased certainty around the project costs and the business case. In order to take advantage of the knowledge and experience already gained and to avoid duplication of work-streams, the decision was made to retain the
1|Page same core consultancy team for this stage and their detailed Stage 2 report is attached as Appendix 1.
Activities carried out in Stage 2 include the following areas of work:
Due diligence on the existing building, in the form of technical surveys and research into existing systems. Concept designs for the building and the external areas and spatial planning. The preparation of a workplace strategy, based on the emerging policies and aspirations around transformation and agile working, as well as good practice. Discussions with third parties to identify letting opportunities. Consultation with Directors, Officers, Members and other key stakeholders. Financial modelling and work to build the business case for the project. Early work on establishing the BREEAM and sustainability principles and options for carbon reduction and energy saving. Early work on a parking strategy.
The Stage 2 financial business case identifies an estimated cost of £24.1m and a potential yield of 7% (after borrowing), with a payback period of 11 years and a likely stabilised cash flow (assuming borrowing) of £1.8m.
The overall estimated cost of the project has increased, although this can be accounted for by additions to the project scope, including IT infrastructure and the design, build and fit out of a commercial unit with a corresponding rental and yield.
The Stage 2 report demonstrates that, despite the increased overall costs, the financing cost of the project can be met by the proposed income generation and savings that can be derived from the upgrade.
We are now requesting £1.15m capital to support the next stage of the development – Stage 3. This will finance the project up to the point of having received tenders back from main contractors and being able to present a fully detailed project budget, detailed designs and a full business case which will be presented to Council for member approval
Recommendations
It is recommended that Council:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.