RESOLVED – Conditional approval but with condition 3 amended to reflect that the brick wall facing the courtyard of no.46 be rendered white. Councillor Slater was not in attendance and Councillor Cornock abstained from voting. [name removed] and Councillor Davis spoke against the application whilst [name removed] spoke in support.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
This application seeks consent for a first floor extension above the existing footprint of the bungalow, 48 Widney Manor Road, as well as a single storey front extension and a single storey side extension.
The proposed extensions would result in a two storey dwelling with two storey front projecting gable to the right side of the dwelling when viewed from the streetscene as well as a two storey rear projection. A further single storey side extension would be incorporated into the side and a single storey front canopy above the office and hall would be created.
The overall result would be two-storey dwelling with an eaves height of 4.7m and a maximum height to the ridge of 7.2m. The front projecting gable would measure 4.0m in width and would project forward by 0.7m creating a box bay window. The front canopy would have an eaves height of 2.3m and a maximum height of 3.5m.
The existing flat roof garage would be altered to incorporate a pitched roof garage with an eaves height of 2.5m and a maximum height to the ridge of 4.6m. This would link to a single storey rear extension and would create one single cat slide roof element which would link to the main dwelling in places.
The first floor element above the existing single storey rear bedroom projection would result in a two storey rear projection with a depth of 2.9m and a width of 2.9m with an eaves height of 4.7m and a height to the ridge of 6.3m. A single storey side extension would be created adjacent to the boundary with no.46 which would measure 1.6m in width and 10.3m in depth with an eaves height of 2.0m and a maximum height of 2.3m.
During the lifetime of the application it was noted that the elevations omitted to show one of the proposed side facing windows and that the block plan did not indicate the first floor rear extension. Amended plans are expected prior to a decision being made at committee.
CONSULTATION RESPONSES
Network Rail : No objections
Conservation Officer : No objections
Neighbours Notified : 26/02/2014
REPRESENTATIONS
Seven objections have been received in connection with this application which include one objection from Councillor Tildesley. In summary these object to the proposal for the following reasons:- New building would be inappropriate for its surroundings Would detract from Malvern Park Farm and conservation area Would set dangerous precedent Applicants should have purchased a two storey house if this is what they required Single storey dwellings are more sympathetic to the area and should be retained Bungalows were built for a reason – to allow homes for the elderly Development would spoil amenities of natural light, noise, visual outlook to residents Concerns over legal covenants on the land Windows to side elevation of no.46 will suffer loss of light and be dominated by the new dwelling Shortage of bungalows in the area Design is considered to be brash and the rear elevation with expose landing and Juliette balcony would have an adverse impact on the character and appearance of road Block plan 1:500 does not show two storey rear extension Neighbouring properties would be severely overlooked
POLICY
Local Plan (December 2013)
P14 – Amenity P15 – Securing Design Quality P16 – Conservation of Heritage Assets & Local Distinctiveness Government Guidance
National Planning Policy Framework
SPG/SPDs
House Extension Guidelines SPD 2010
PLANNING HISTORY
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.