RESOLVED – Conditional approval with an amendment to condition (7) to include ‘if the retained hedge dies within five years it is replaced’, an additional condition (15) ‘to retain the hedge along the boundary with 15 Chestnut Close, in so far as it is located within the application site’. It was also agreed to remove permitted development rights. [name removed] spoke in support of the application whilst Councillor Norman Davies spoke against.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
This application is being reported to Planning Committee for the following reason(s):
The proposals are a substantial departure from the Development Plan A new section 106 agreement is required The proposals would have a significant impact outside of its immediate vicinity The proposals have given rise to substantial weight of public concern X The application has been called into Committee by a Member The application has been submitted by (or on behalf of) the Council (or it relates to Council owned land) and there has been one objection or more. The applicant is a Member or Officer of the Council (who has contact with Development Management) (or a close relative of such a person) The Head of Development Management has elected to refer the application to Committee
PROPOSAL
This application proposes the construction of a single bungalow of similar style, scale and proportions to that at number 14. This would lie facing the road at a slight angle, continuing the staggered line of dwellings but lining through with the front elevation of 14. The plot would be formed from part of the garden of number 14. Historically the eastern part of the site formed part of the substantial garden of 73 St Bernards Road.
The bungalow would measure a maximum of 14.3 metres wide by 11.6 metres in depth. The amended plan reduces the roof pitch giving a lower main ridge height of 4.9 metres and an overall hipped form. It would provide 3 bedrooms, lounge, kitchen, bathroom, WC and utility room, plus an attached single garage. CONSULTATION RESPONSES
Landscape Architect : No objection subject to conditions
Highway Engineer : No objection subject to conditions
Spatial Planning : No objection
Neighbours Notified : 28/2/14
Site Notice : 5/3/14
Press Notice : 21/3/14
REPRESENTATIONS
The application is reported to Committee at the request of Councillor Davies.
Three letters of objection have been received concerning:
proposal fails to enhance or preserve the character of the Olton Conservation Area by using garden land for development of insensitive design and scale;
reduction of buffer between neutral area and positive buildings;
proposed bungalow excessively large for plot with excessive parking provision; loss of amenity including negative impact upon tranquillity of neighbouring gardens including through noise and fumes, overlooking creating loss of privacy;
undesirable precedent;
loss of trees including adverse impact upon boundary with 15 Chestnut Close, and possible adverse impact upon some retained trees;
adverse impact upon wildlife using currently untended plot.
POLICY
Solihull Local Plan
P14 – Amenity P15 – Securing Design Quality P16 - Conservation of Heritage Assets and Local Distinctiveness
Government Guidance
National Planning Policy Framework National Planning Practice Guidance
SPG/SPDs
Olton Conservation Area Appraisal New Housing in Context 2003 SPD 1 The Historic Environment
PLANNING HISTORY
2004/2439/s [C/A tree not made TPO] re-pollard 2 no. horse chestnut trees. 58/73 [A] tpc 11203, conservation area plots 6a and 7a extension to road and erection of 2 bungalows 58/13989 [C/A] tpc 9494, conservation area plot 6a new cul de sac and 7 detached bungalows
SITE DESCRIPTION
The site comprises part of the garden of 14 Chestnut Close. The Close was expanded in the 1960s by the addition of part of the long rear garden of 73 St. Bernard’s Road (a sale subject to a restrictive covenant limiting its use to garden land, but not relevant or enforceable in planning terms).
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.