CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
Planning Committee, Wednesday 30 March 2016 at 6.00pm

PL/2016/00340/MINFHO - 148 Cropthorne Road, Shirley

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 30 March 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item11

Resolved

Refused for the following two reasons:- i) The dormer window by reason of its bulk, scale and design has led to an addition that is poorly integrated with the design of the original house resulting in a discordant structure that detracts from the visual amenity of the application property and appears as an incongruous addition to the street-scene. Therefore, the development would be contrary to Policy P14 and P15 of the Solihull Local Plan, House Extension Guidelines SPD 2010 and NPPF; and ii) The dormer window by reason of its bulk, scale and design has led to an overbearing, oppressive and intrusive structure which affords opportunities for overlooking of the neighbouring garden, resulting in a loss of privacy at these properties. Therefore, the development would be contrary to Policy P14 and P15 of the Solihull Local Plan, House Extension Guidelines SPD 2010 and NPPF. Enforcement action is to be taken forthwith pursuant to the actions required by the Enforcement Notice currently in force. [name removed] spoke in support of the application.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting. Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Solihull's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Executive summary

The amendments proposed to address the Planning Inspectors dismissal of an appeal against an enforcement notice remain cosmetic in nature. (The Inspector stated that only the full removal of the dormer would satisfy him). Consequentially , in terms of the wording of that decision, Officers can not conclude that the objection in principle to this development has been overcome as whilst the proposed alterations reduce the visual harm to the street scene, and reduce the impact on neighbour amenity such that they are both now considered neutral in the planning balance, short of removing the dormer the principle objection of the Inspector can not be overcome. Therefore, whilst on balance, in principle terms the report could only ever conclude that the application should be refused.

Members may share the view of the Inspector that the dormer itself is so harmful as to require its total removal, in which case a full refusal should be advanced. Members may also reasonably come to a view that they consider that the alterations proposed overcome the harm posed, and approve the application. An alternative approach, and that which is proposed, would be to refuse the application on the basis of the in principle harm caused by the development, but to take a view, subject to a further period of compliance, as to whether to pursue further enforcement action. It is this latter option that is proposed to Members as an acceptable compromise position, but recognising that a view could be taken anywhere along the scale of decision options set out above.

The Head of Development and Regulatory Management considers that this is a complex matter that requires a decision in the context of a member site visit, to appreciate the site context, and opportunities for the setting of a precedent, and to consider the expediency of pursuing further enforcement action. The matter is therefore advanced to Planning Committee for a decision.

KEY PLANNING ISSUES

The following key planning issues are material to the determination of this application:

 Background  Principle of development  Whether the proposed amendments have satisfactory addressed the original reasons for refusal  Enforcement procedure

CONSULTATION RESPONSES

Non Statutory Consultees

The following Non-Statutory Consultee responses have been received:

SMBC Drainage - No objection

PUBLICITY

The application was advertised in accordance with the provisions set down in the Town and Country Planning (General Development Procedure) Order 2015.

One response was received. All correspondence has been reviewed and the main issues raised are summarised below (Planning Committee Members have access to all third party correspondence received):

Design and Character

 The previous planning application was refused and upheld at appeal and the new application proposed relatively minor changes; and  The applicant should build what they have consent for. It is noted that as part of the application bundle, two letters citing agreement to the proposed modifications by immediate neighbours, following discussions with the applicant were submitted.

PLANNING ASSESSMENT

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
PL/2016/00340/MINFHO: 148 Cropthorne Road, ShirleyReport 131 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 11 attended
HA
Councillor Howard AllenCommittee Member, expected
DB
Councillor David BellChairman, expected
LB
Councillor Linda BrownCommittee Member, expected
SD
Councillor Stuart DavisVice-Chairman, expected
MD
Councillor Mrs Diana Holl-Allen MBECommittee Member, expected
JP
Councillor Jeff PottsCommittee Member, expected
JR
Councillor Jim RyanCommittee Member, expected
AS
Councillor Angela SandisonCommittee Member, expected
JW
Councillor John WindmillCommittee Member, expected
JC
James CarpenterOfficer, expected
SG
Sherrie GrantOfficer, expected

More from Solihull Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Jun 2026 Birmingham Airport Night Flying Policy Sub-CommitteeRESOLVED That Councillors Bob Grinsell (Chairman), Jane Lamden and David Hoey were elected to sit on the Birmingham A... Decided Open
27 May 2026 Appointment of chairmanRESOLVED Councillor Bob Grinsell was elected Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27. Decided Open
27 May 2026 Appointment of vice-chairmanRESOLVED Councillor James Bradley was elected Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27. Decided Open
21 May 2025 Appointment of ChairmanRESOLVED Councillor Bob Grinsell was elected Chairman for the Municipal Year 2025/26. Decided Open
21 May 2025 Appointment of Vice-ChairmanRESOLVED Councillor Prish Sharma was elected Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year 2025/26. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies