Adoption of Harm Assessment Form for Planning Enforcement
ApprovedCommittee2 papers
CPH Managed Growth Decision Session approved this item on Tuesday 21 February 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
RESOLVED The Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Managed Growth confirmed the adoption of the amended Harm Assessment form as detailed at Appendix A of the report and approved its continued use as an additional guidance tool in the prioritisation and assessment of enforcement cases.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
1.1To report, as requested, on the use of the harm assessment form which was agreed for implementation in July 2016 subject to specified amendments and review after 6 months.
2. Decision(s) Recommended
2.1To confirm the formal adoption of the amended harm assessment form at Appendix A, and its continued use as an additional guidance tool in the prioritisation and assessment of enforcement cases. 3. Background
3.1When the initial investigation into an alleged breach of planning control finds that there is an identifiable breach, a decision must be made on whether to spend further time and resources on pursuing the matter towards some sort of resolution – either through negation or, if all else fails, through some form of formal action. In some cases, where there is only a minor technical breach which causes no significant harm and/or where a planning application would have been likely to be successful, it is not expedient to pursue the matter and the case is closed.
3.2This is entirely a matter of professional judgement, based on experience and material planning considerations on a case-by-case basis. Such decisions are documented by the investigating officer in the case notes and explained in communications to all interested parties. Nevertheless, this is a difficult and contentious area of work which is inevitably liable to complaints. It has therefore been proposed that the Council adopts a system used by some other authorities, whereby a ‘harm assessment form’ is used to apply a ‘score’ system to the breach of planning control, thereby providing a quantified assessment of the degree of harm caused, or likely to be caused by the breach. A score beyond a threshold of 5 or more, will normally mean that the case will be pursued further, though this does not necessarily mean that formal action will ultimately be considered to be expedient. Cases with a lower score will not normally be pursued any further, though owners/occupiers may be invited to remedy the matter or seek to regularise it through the submission of a planning application.
3.3Some cases will automatically be pursued and will not need to be the subject of this process – these include cases where there is a clear and significant conflict with the adopted development plan, and cases where a retrospective application has been refused.
3.4The form should be regarded as a useful tool to be used by officers in guiding and informing the decision-making process, and in prioritising cases, though the final decision remains a matter of professional judgement.
3.5This matter was initially considered by the Cabinet Member in July 2016. The adoption of the harm assessment form was approved, subject to two amendments as follows : (a) that a scoring threshold of 0-3 be applied to all assessment criteria on the Harm Assessment Form, and (b) that the final sentence at the bottom of the harm assessment form (“The trigger score may be varied according to work pressures”) be removed from the document. Those amendments were implemented immediately.
3.6It was also determined that the amended version of the harm assessment form should be implemented as an integrated part of the case notes used by enforcement officers, and that a further report should be submitted in 6 months, to report on officers’ experience of using the form and its impact on enforcement work. This is that report.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Five Year Housing Land Supply PositionThe Cabinet Member for Managed Growth: (i) Noted the Housing Delivery Test results published by MHCLG. (ii) Noted the...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.