CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
Call In Committee, Monday 24 April 2017 at 6.00pm

Scrutiny Call -In Procedure Note

Decided Committee 1 paper

Call In Committee decided this item on Monday 24 April 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item5

Resolved

Decision Session on 20 March 2017. It would then hear the views of Members/ public on the matter and have the opportunity to ask questions of all the parties to both the original decision and the reasons for Call-In. The Committee were requested to apply the following test when considering the Call-In request: · Were in the context of the Call-In grounds all the relevant factors taken into account by the Cabinet Portfolio Holder when reaching the decision? · Was the decision a reasonable one for the Cabinet Portfolio Holder to have made in the circumstances?
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting. Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Solihull's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Call In Committee

PROCEDURE NOTES FOR CHAIRING A CALL-IN COMMITTEE

The Chairman will:

1. Welcome everyone to the meeting and advise those present that the meeting is being webcast.

2. Remind Members that the meeting has been convened to deal with a call-in request relating to a decision made by Councillor K Hawkins at his Environment, Housing and Regeneration Cabinet Portfolio Holder (CPH) Decision Session on 20 March 2017 in respect of the Meriden Park Adventure Playground.

3. The Members to be advised that the Committee will consider whether, in the context of the grounds to the Call-in Notice), all relevant factors were taken into account by the Cabinet Member) in reaching the decision and that it was a reasonable one, in the circumstances (See paragraph 12 below)

4. Refer to the documents circulated with the agenda, comprising the Call-In Notice, the documents submitted as part of the decision-making process and the Cabinet Member’s written response to the grounds cited in the Notice.

5. If any additional documents are circulated at any stage during the meeting, Members should be allowed time to read the papers before the meeting continues.

6. Invite the Members who requested the Call-In to explain the reasons for doing so i.e. the grounds cited in the Call-In Notice. The Call-In Committee can ask questions of these Members if any further clarification of the grounds is needed.

7. Invite the Cabinet Member, Councillor K Hawkins to respond, in the context of the grounds to the Call-In Notice:

 The scope of the decision  The factors taken into account when reaching the decision  The reason for the decision

8. Invite Members of the Call In Committee to question the Cabinet Member.(The Cabinet Member may ask a supporting officer to respond to questions relating to points of fact or technical matters; this should be permitted, although Members should recognise that it is the decision-maker who is being called to account).

9. Members should:  Not ask leading questions  Avoid criticism of Officers who are not in a position to respond  Speak once only in relation to a specific point

10. If any other interested parties are present at the meeting and have previously indicated that they wish to make representations (which should be related to the grounds in the Call-In Notice), they should be allowed to address the Committee at this point. Any representations should be directed to the grounds contained in the Call-In Notice and should not repeat evidence that has already been presented in the consideration of this issue. Each representation will be limited to 4 minutes per speaker. The Committee will not hear multiple representations from the same interested party or group and the Chairman has overall discretion as to the number of speakers.

11. If information is received from other interested parties, Members of the Committee should be invited to ask questions, and the Cabinet Member should then be asked if he (or a supporting officer) wishes to respond to any new points raised.

12. Once all relevant parties have been given the opportunity to raise any new points relevant to the debate, invite Members to consider the Call-in request: The following tests may be applicable:

 In the context of the Call-In grounds, were all relevant factors taken into account by the Cabinet (Member) when reaching the decision?  Was the decision a reasonable one for the Cabinet (Member) to have made in the circumstances?*

(*Note: In this context unreasonableness should relate to an illogical or perverse decision rather than just a difference of opinion)

13. If the Committee is not satisfied on either of these points then the options are:

 To ask the Cabinet Member to reconsider the decision, giving reasons why, or  To refer the matter to full Council.

14. If the Committee is satisfied that the decision was reasonable and properly made, there is no need for further scrutiny and the decision becomes effective.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Scrutiny Call -In Procedure NoteReport 82 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 11 attended
MA
Councillor Maggie AllenCommittee Member, present
DB
Councillor David BellCommittee Member, present
DE
Councillor Debbie EvansCommittee Member, in attendance
JF
Councillor Jo FairburnCommittee Member, in attendance
RH
Councillor Robert HallCommittee Member, in attendance
PH
Councillor Peter Hogarth MBECommittee Member, present
MD
Councillor Mrs Diana Holl-Allen MBECommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Stephen HoltCommittee Member, present
MP
Councillor Mark ParkerCommittee Member, present
GS
Councillor Glenis SlaterCommittee Member, present
DM
Councillor Dr Mark WilsonCommittee Member, in attendance

More from Solihull Call In Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 May 2021 Election of a chairmanThat Councillor Mrs D Holl Allen be appointed as Chairman for this meeting of the Call-In Committee. Decided Open
24 May 2021 Papers considered by the cabinet portfolio holder for environment and highwaysDecision Session of 22 April 2021 were noted. Noted Open
23 Jul 2020 Election of ChairmanThat Councillor T Dicicco be appointed as Chairman for this meeting of the Call-In Committee. Decided Open
23 Jul 2020 Papers Considered by the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and HighwaysDecision Session of 23 June 2020 were noted. Noted Open
24 Apr 2017 Election of ChairmanRESOLVED That Councillor P Hogarth MBE be appointed as Chairman for this meeting of the Call-In Committee. Councillor... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies