CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
Planning Committee, Wednesday 13 March 2019 at 6.00pm

PL/2017/01568/PPFL - 27 Lowbrook Lane

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 13 March 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item8

Resolved

Refused as per recommendation. [name removed] and Councillor Richard Holt spoke against the application whilst [name removed] spoke in support. Councillor Holt left the room whilst the application was considered.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting. Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Solihull's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Executive summary

The application is for a new detached dwelling to be built on land to the rear of 27 Lowbrook Lane. The application site is within the Green Belt.

None of the exceptions to development in the Green Belt are considered to apply in this instance. Therefore, the proposal represents inappropriate development in the Green Belt, which is by definition harmful. Furthermore it is recognised that the development would harm the openness of the Green Belt. Therefore, there would be both definitional and specific harm to the Green Belt. Substantial weight should be given to this harm.

It is not considered that the case for very special circumstances provided by the applicants is sufficient to outweigh this harm.

The application is therefore recommended for refusal BACKGROUND

This application was reported to your Planning Committee on Wednesday 1st November 2017. The application was recommended for approval by officers and your Committee resolved to approve the application. This decision was subsequently subject to a Judicial Review. The Claimant’s case was that the Council’s decision to grant planning permission was legally flawed on the following grounds:

1. Failure to take into account harm to the openness of the Greenbelt; 2. Flawed approach to very special circumstances; 3. Failure to take into account the likely harm to a TPO tree and/or irrational approach to the TPO and/or absence of reasons; 4. immaterial considerations taken into account in the Officer Report.

The Court found for the Claimant pursuant to grounds 1 & 2 of their claim.

Please note that at the time this decision was made the NPPF 2012 was the relevant document, which has since been updated.

Ground 1 summary – failure to take into account harm to the openness of the Greenbelt

[name removed] found that the original Officer’s Report (OR) did not give substantial weight, as required by the NPPF, to the obvious harmful impact of built form on previously un-built land. The OR acknowledged that the development was harmful but then proceeded to regard that harm as not material. [name removed] held that this approach discounts the obvious spatial impact of the development by the absence of visual impact.

The Judge found that the Officer had misunderstood and/or misapplied paragraph 88 of the NPPF [2012] and that as a result of the error the Committee were significantly misled.

Ground 2 summary – Flawed Approach to Very Special Circumstances

The original OR identified economic and social benefits, including boosting housing supply and the creation of construction jobs, benefits to the character of the area and highway safety as being Very Special Circumstances (VSCs). [name removed] found this approach to VSCs to be flawed because the officer report had given these neutral weight in the planning balance and thus could not outweigh the harm caused by the proposal in terms of its inappropriateness and any other harm.

Ground 3 - Failure to take into account the likely harm to a TPO tree and/or irrational approach to the TPO and/or absence of reasons

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
PL/2017/01568/PPFL: 27 Lowbrook LaneReport 197 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

12 of 12 attended
MA
Councillor Maggie AllenCommittee Member, present
DB
Councillor David BellChairman, present
RG
Councillor Robert GrinsellVice-Chairman, present
AH
Councillor Andy HodgsonCommittee Member, present
MD
Councillor Mrs Diana Holl-Allen MBECommittee Member, present
RH
Councillor Richard HoltCommittee Member, present
JR
Councillor Jim RyanCommittee Member, present
AS
Councillor Angela SandisonCommittee Member, present
GS
Councillor Glenis SlaterCommittee Member, present
PC
Paul CowenOfficer, present
SE
Stuart EvansOfficer, present
RW
Ruth WitherspoonOfficer, present

More from Solihull Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Jun 2026 Birmingham Airport Night Flying Policy Sub-CommitteeRESOLVED That Councillors Bob Grinsell (Chairman), Jane Lamden and David Hoey were elected to sit on the Birmingham A... Decided Open
27 May 2026 Appointment of chairmanRESOLVED Councillor Bob Grinsell was elected Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27. Decided Open
27 May 2026 Appointment of vice-chairmanRESOLVED Councillor James Bradley was elected Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27. Decided Open
21 May 2025 Appointment of ChairmanRESOLVED Councillor Bob Grinsell was elected Chairman for the Municipal Year 2025/26. Decided Open
21 May 2025 Appointment of Vice-ChairmanRESOLVED Councillor Prish Sharma was elected Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year 2025/26. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies