AI summarySolihull Cabinet Member rejects a Public Space Protection Order for school-gate engine idling, instead expanding the Young Lungs at Work education campaign and using Civil Parking Enforcement officers to issue warning notices for 12 months.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedRejects PSPO and Traffic Order; approves warning notices
Money£22,400 per school year estimatedCost of redeployed Civil Enforcement Officers on idling
What happens next12 month monitoring, then reportFurther Cabinet Member report due March 2027
Who it affectsSchools, parents, drivers in SolihullEngine idling enforcement near school entrances
What was decided
The Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure will not introduce a Public Space Protection Order or Traffic Order on engine idling at this stage, and will instead expand the Young Lungs at Work educational campaign across all primary schools in the Borough, subject to funding in the February Assets and Priority setting report. Report P7
Civil Parking Enforcement officers will issue formal warning notices to any motorist found idling near a school entrance who will not switch off their engine when asked, as part of the Council's Civil Parking Enforcement powers. Report P8, P58, P59
The situation will be monitored for 12 months and a further report will be brought to the Cabinet Member in March 2027 on the results. Report P9, P10
Why
Solihull has been compliant with the NO2 objective of 40µg/m3 for several years, and Defra has not queried the Council's Annual Status Report on potential exceedances, so no school needs interventions beyond the current Air Quality Action Plan. Report P25, P24, P29
Officers consider that a PSPO for idling is a poor fit with the anti-social behaviour criteria, that enforcement requires asking the driver to switch off first, and that the £100 fine is unlikely to cover administrative and enforcement costs. Report P46, P47, P48, P54
The Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board unanimously supported more hard-hitting education, supported an enforcement strategy using Fixed Penalty Notices, and did not support a PSPO. Report P71, P72, P73
What happens next
Civil Parking Enforcement officers will start official conversations with idling motorists during their daily school gate parking enforcement duties, escalating to formal warning notices where drivers refuse to switch off without good reason. Report P58, P59
The Council will consider whether the back-office enforcement system should be upgraded to enable anti-idling Fixed Penalty Notices, and whether a full enforcement service would be viable. Report P59, P77
An education, conversations and warning notice dataset, together with spot checks by the education team, will be reported back to the Cabinet Member in March 2027. Report P59
The money
£22,400 Estimated annual cost of redeploying two Civil Enforcement Officers to idling enforcement at all 80 schools twice yearly Report P76
just over £1,500 Spent in 24/25 on banners, leaflets and lamp post signs for 10 Young Lungs at Work campaigns Report P79
in the region of £200 per school Average indicative cost of continuing campaign materials at each school in future years Report P79
approximately £5,000 Budget allocated this financial year from the Highway Management existing operations revenue budget for the Young Lungs at Work campaign Report P80
£100 Fixed Penalty Notice level available under a PSPO for idling, rising to a fine not exceeding level 3 (£1000) on conviction Report P48
£20 Fixed Penalty Notice available to local authorities for idling under the Road Traffic (Vehicle Emissions) (Fixed Penalty) (England) Regulations 2002 Report P52
£70 Penalty Charge Notice level available through a Traffic Management Order under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 Report P53
Options considered
Rejected: Introduce a Public Space Protection Order covering engine idling at schools. Scrutiny Board did not support it; criteria fit poorly with anti-social behaviour test; administrative and enforcement costs unlikely to be offset by £100 fines Report P7, P46, P47, P48, P73
Rejected: Introduce a Traffic Order to enable Penalty Charge Notices for idling. No PSPO or Traffic Order to be proceeded with at this stage Report P7
Chosen: Continue and expand the Young Lungs at Work educational campaign across all primary schools. Officer observations show short-term impact on driver behaviour; supports scrutiny recommendation subject to funding Report P33, P35, P71, P79, P80
Chosen: Have Civil Parking Enforcement officers issue warning notices to idling drivers near school entrances and monitor for 12 months. Balances education, engagement and targeted enforcement while gathering evidence on whether an enforcement service business case is viable Report P57, P58, P59
Implications
Financial: Estimated £22,400 per school year to redeploy two Civil Enforcement Officers to idling enforcement, and a further cost to upgrade the back-office system to issue anti-idling Fixed Penalty Notices; a new area-based PSPO enforcement service would cost significantly more. Report P76, P77, P78
Legal: Use of Civil Parking Enforcement powers to issue warning notices is approved; no new PSPO or Traffic Order is being made, so existing legislation under the Road Traffic (Vehicle Emissions) (Fixed Penalty) (England) Regulations 2002 and the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 is not being used to issue Fixed Penalty or Penalty Charge Notices at this stage. Report P52, P53, P81
Risk: Council's financial position means the appetite to take on any further financial risk is low; enforcement income is expected to be minimal because officers must ask the driver to switch off before any fine. Report P76, P83
Equalities: No equality implications identified at this stage as everyone would be treated equally and no specific road user group targeted. Report P84
Staffing: Civil Parking Enforcement officers will take on additional idling conversations and warning notice duties as part of their existing school gate enforcement work. Report P58, P59
Other: Contributes to Council Plan ambitions on health, supporting children and young people, climate change, and making Solihull an attractive place, with limited contribution to the vibrant economy ambition. Report P63, P65, P66, P67, P68, P69
Who and where
Parents, carers and drivers collecting children from Solihull primary schools Report P12, P31, P35
All 10 schools that took part in the 2024/25 Young Lungs at Work campaign and 10 further schools in 2025/26 Report P31, P35
Solihull residents and pupils exposed to vehicle emissions around school gates Report P13, P21
Timeline
End of 2024: Petition and motion received by the Council on health implications of engine idling at school pick-up and a request for a PSPO Report P1
2024/25 academic year: 10 schools took part in the Young Lungs at Work - Engines Off campaign, reaching about 8,000 pupils' parents and carers Report P31
6 August 2025: Economic Development Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board reviewed an Air Quality report covering West Midlands health data including Solihull Report P20
2025/26 academic year: Young Lungs at Work campaign being delivered at a further 10 schools Report P35
May and September 2025: Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board considered the issue and made unanimous recommendations Report P2, P71
2026-01-20: Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Decision Session approved the package of note, education, warning notices, 12 month monitoring and a further report in March 2027
February (Assets and Priority setting report): Decision on funding to continue and expand the Young Lungs at Work campaigns Report P7
March 2027: Further report to the Cabinet Member on warning notice outcomes and whether an enforcement service business case is viable Report P10
Plain English for the jargon
Car idling: Leaving a vehicle's engine running while stationary, for example while waiting to collect a child from school
Public Space Protection Order (PSPO): An order under the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014 that restricts activities in a defined public area where behaviour is having a detrimental effect on the quality of life of those in the locality
Fixed Penalty Notice (FPN): A financial penalty that can be issued for certain offences, here including the £20 idling FPN under the 2002 Regulations and a £100 FPN under a PSPO
Penalty Charge Notice (PCN): A £70 charge that could be issued under a Traffic Management Order for idling
Diffusion tube: A passive NO2 monitor used by Solihull Council at 30 sites to report annual mean Nitrogen Dioxide levels to Defra
Young Lungs at Work: The Council's education campaign for primary schools and parents on the effects of car idling and engine switching off
Civil Parking Enforcement: The Council's existing civil enforcement function, used here as the route for officers to talk to idling drivers and issue warning notices near school entrances
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5
Resolved
The Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure RESOLVED to: 1) Note the contents of the report and the views of the Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board. 2) Agree not to proceed with introducing a Public Space Protection Order or Traffic Order at this stage. 3) Agree to continue to expand the use of the “Young lungs at work” educational campaigns across all primary schools in the Borough in future years, subject to funding being made available in the February Assets and Priority setting report. 4) As part of the Council’s Civil Parking Enforcement powers, approve the Civil Parking Enforcement officers issuing warning notices to any motorist found parked idling un-necessarily in the immediate vicinity of a school entrance and who would not switch off their engines when asked to do so. 5) Agree to monitor the situation for 12 months to see if motorist’s behaviours improve through issuing of warning notices or if a business case could be developed to support investment into an enforcement service. 6) Agree to receive a further report in March 2027 providing an update on these results.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
Report to CPH Environment and Infrastructure Decision Session
Executive summary
At the end of 2024, a petition and motion were received by the Council in respect of the health implications caused by motorists leaving car engines running whilst waiting to collect children from schools (engine idling) across the Borough and a request to establish a Public Space Protection Order (PSPO).
Papers were presented to Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board in May and September 2025 to help with the review process. The views of the Board are also referred to in this report.
This report considers the health implications and the available air quality monitoring data, as well as details of the education and enforcement options. The report considers the cost implications and sets out a proposed action plan to help improve air quality outside schools.
2. Decision(s) Recommended
The Cabinet Member is asked to:
(a) Note the contents of the report and the views of the Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board.
(b) Agree not to proceed with introducing a Public Space Protection Order or Traffic Order at this stage. (c) Agree to continue to expand the use of the “Young lungs at work” educational campaigns across all primary schools in the Borough in future years, subject to funding being made available in the February Assets and Priority setting report.
(d) As part of the Council’s Civil Parking Enforcement powers, approve the Civil Parking Enforcement officers issuing warning notices to any motorist found parked idling un- necessarily in the immediate vicinity of a school entrance and who would not switch off their engines when asked to do so.
(e) Agree to monitor the situation for 12 months to see if motorist’s behaviours improve through issuing of warning notices or if a business case could be developed to support investment into an enforcement service.
(f) Agree to receive a further report in March 2027 providing an update on these results.
3. Matters for Consideration
What is car idling? – This is where a driver leaves the engine of a motor vehicle running or “ticking over” whilst stationary to help keep the vehicle warm or cool whilst waiting to collect a child from school.
These emissions contain harmful gases which contribute towards climate change and are linked to negative health implications such as asthma and other lung diseases. Albeit, in very small quantities compared to the emissions issued by passing traffic generally.
Older carbon fuelled vehicle engines are the biggest contributors to the problem due to high levels of nitrogen oxide and other particulates emitted through their exhaust system. Research suggests that all carbon fuelled vehicles have a negative impact on the quality of the air, if engines are left running unnecessarily.
Whilst the petition raised the issue specifically about roads in the vicinity of schools in the Borough, similar problems occur at many other locations, including places of employment, railway stations, retails centres, sporting and religious venues.
In addition, there are many other types of activity that may also contribute to poor air quality at a particular location that may be equally harmful and make the monitoring and evaluation process very difficult.
4. What options have been considered and what is the evidence telling us about them?
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow CPH Environment and Infrastructure Decision Session at Solihull and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.