CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Somerset Council
Executive, Wednesday 5 August 2026 at 10.00am

Best Value Notice

Noted Executive 3 papers

AI summarySomerset Council Executive acknowledges a government Best Value Notice issued 15 July 2026, commissions a single Somerset Improvement and Assurance Framework, and agrees quarterly progress reports shared with MHCLG.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedCommissioned single improvement framework and agreed reporting
MoneyNo new moneyImprovement Advisory Board funded from existing budget
What happens nextFormal MHCLG response by 20 August 2026Quarterly assurance reports to Executive
Who it affectsCouncil, residents and MHCLGFocus on Children's, Adult Care and SEND services

What was decided

The Executive acknowledged the Best Value Notice issued to Somerset Council on 15 July 2026 and noted the concerns and expectations set out by MHCLG. Report P1, P6

Members commissioned the development of a Somerset Improvement and Assurance Framework as the single corporate framework for responding to the Notice and providing assurance to the Council and its stakeholders. Report P4, P6

The Executive agreed quarterly assurance reports would be presented to it, with appropriate reporting to Scrutiny, Audit Committee and Full Council, and that the Improvement Advisory Board would provide written updates to be shared with MHCLG. Report P6, P22

Why

The proposals respond directly to the Best Value Notice and the May 2026 CIPFA External Assurance Review, which concluded that urgent action is required to strengthen grip, accelerate transformation and demonstrate sustained improvement. Report P2, P8, P12

Ministers have concerns about financial sustainability, pace and impact of transformation, financial resilience, external audit actions, and continuing demand pressures in Children's Services, Adult Social Care and SEND, alongside inconsistent Ofsted and CQC assessment results. Report P2, P81

The Council considers that failure to respond could lead to reputational damage, loss of stakeholder confidence, and potential escalation by MHCLG to commission a Best Value Inspection, which could lead to statutory intervention. Report P38

What happens next

A formal response to MHCLG will be issued by no later than 20 August 2026, confirming the Council's commitment to leading its own improvement and engaging constructively with government. Report P18

The Chief Executive will review, approve and revise the Terms of Reference for the Improvement Advisory Board, supported by a review of finance capacity and capability led by the S151 Officer. Report P20, P26

By December 2026 the Council expects to demonstrate a mobilised Building Better Finance Programme, mitigation of forecast in-year overspend, delivery of transformation benefits, stronger management of demand-led services, a clear trajectory for restoring reserves, and a mature assurance framework. Report P31

The money

  • Target of 10% of net revenue Reserves Restoration Plan threshold Report P30

Options considered

  • Rejected: Do not respond to the Best Value Notice. Council must respond; failure could lead to reputational damage, loss of stakeholder confidence, and escalation by MHCLG, potentially to a Best Value Inspection and statutory intervention Report P38

Implications

  • Financial: Strengthened financial controls are being introduced, with a comprehensive review of workforce, commissioning, procurement, property, assets, fleet, income, fees and charges, and grant management, forming part of the MTFP 2027/28 and the Section 25 report in February 2027. Report P26, P27, P46, P47
  • Legal: The Best Value Notice is non-statutory and does not transfer decision-making powers; the Council's Executive, Full Council, statutory officers, Scrutiny and Audit Committee retain their constitutional roles, and any change to delegations or financial regulations must follow normal constitutional processes. Report P48, P49, P50
  • Risk: Initial risks identified include financial recovery not being delivered at pace, transformation not delivering sufficient savings, Improvement Advisory Board advice not translating into action, statutory external audit recommendations not being addressed, and weakened public confidence; each has a current score, target score and key mitigations. Report P44, P45
  • Equalities: The framework is expected to have positive equality impacts through improved sustainability and performance of services for children, adults with care and support needs, families requiring SEND support, carers and residents in financial hardship, with future service changes to be subject to their own equality analysis. Report P59, P60
  • Staffing: Sustainable improvement depends on workforce engagement, visible leadership, organisational culture, leadership development and workforce planning, supported by the Council's People Strategy and Culture Programme. Report P32, P33, P56, P57, P58
  • Governance: The proposals bring the Best Value Notice, CIPFA recommendations, external audit actions, Building Better Finance, Inspiring Innovation and the Improvement Advisory Board into a single integrated framework, supporting clearer ownership, evidence-based assurance, escalation and public reporting. Report P4, P51, P52, P53

Who and where

  • Residents of Somerset and users of council services Report P36, P59
  • Children, families and carers needing Children's Services and SEND support Report P2, P21, P59, P81
  • Adults needing care and support, and carers Report P2, P21, P59, P81
  • Somerset Council workforce and recognised trade unions Report P32, P33, P43
  • Somerset Council councillors, including Scrutiny and Audit Committee members Report P20, P41
  • Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and Somerset MPs Report P1, P5, P22

Timeline

  • 2025: Somerset Council established the Improvement Advisory Board Report P3, P15
  • May 2026: CIPFA external assurance review concluded urgent action is required Report P12, P81
  • 15 July 2026: MHCLG issued Somerset Council with a Best Value Notice Report P1, P70, P75, P76
  • 28 July 2026: Officer assurance completed on the report Report P72
  • 29 July 2026: Interim Section 151 measures took effect to address forecast overspend Report P25
  • 31st July 2026: New Chief Finance Officer (S151) took up post Report P9
  • 5 August 2026: Somerset Council Executive considered and resolved on the Best Value Notice response
  • 20th August 2026: Deadline for formal Council response to MHCLG Report P18
  • December 2026: Expected outcomes to be demonstrated, including mobilised Building Better Finance Programme and reserve recovery trajectory Report P31
  • 12 months after issue: MHCLG review point for the Best Value Notice, which may continue, be withdrawn or be escalated Report P85
  • February 2027: MTFP 2027/28 and Chief Finance Officer's Section 25 report Report P27

Plain English for the jargon

  • Best Value Notice: Formal non-statutory notification from MHCLG that ministers have concerns about a council's capacity to meet its Best Value Duty under the Local Government Act 1999.
  • MHCLG: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, the UK government department responsible for the Notice.
  • CIPFA: Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, which carried out the May 2026 external assurance review.
  • Improvement Advisory Board (IAB): Advisory body established in 2025 to provide advice, challenge and assurance on the Council's transformation and improvement activity.
  • Exceptional Financial Support: Central government support allowing a council to use capital resources to fund revenue pressures; Somerset has applied for this for 2026/27.
  • SEND: Special Educational Needs and Disabilities services for children and young people.
  • S151 Officer: The council's statutory Chief Finance Officer, designated under Section 151 of the Local Government Act 1972.
  • MTFP / MTFS: Medium-Term Financial Plan / Strategy used to set the council's budget over several years.
  • Section 25 report: Annual report by the Chief Finance Officer on the robustness of budget estimates and adequacy of reserves.
  • CQC and Ofsted: Care Quality Commission and Office for Standards in Education, the regulators whose recent assessments are referenced in the Notice.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item7

Resolved

Having been duly proposed and seconded, the Executive Resolved to:- · Acknowledge the issued to Somerset Council on 15 July 2026 and note the concerns and expectations set out by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG). · Confirm that Somerset Council would continue to lead its own improvement, whilst engaging constructively with Government, the Local Government Association, external auditors and independent advisers. · Commission the development of a Somerset Improvement and Assurance Framework as the Council’s single corporate framework for responding to the and providing assurance to the Council and its stakeholders. · Note the role and purpose of the Somerset Improvement Advisory Board as an advisory board providing advice, challenge, expertise and assurance on the Council’s transformation and improvement activity as summarised in the report and, delegate authority to the Chief Executive to review, approve, and revise the Terms of Reference for the Board to reflect the broader requirements of the . · Request that the Somerset Improvement Advisory Board maintained a clear log of key advice, recommendations and actions, and that this was used alongside the consolidated action tracker, evidence repository and regular assurance reporting to demonstrate how the Council was considering and responding to external challenge. · Agree that the Somerset Improvement Advisory Board would provide regular written updates to meetings of Executive, to be shared with the MHCLG. · Agree that quarterly assurance reports would be presented to Executive, with appropriate reporting to Scrutiny, Audit Committee and Full Council, to provide assurance on progress, risks, delivery and impact.
Word for word from the decision Somerset published for this meeting. Source: democracy.somerset.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Somerset's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive, 18 pages

Executive summary

On 15 July 2026 the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government issued Somerset Council with a Best Value Notice (see Appendix 1). The Notice is a formal notification that Ministers have concerns about the Council’s capacity to comply with its Best Value Duty under the Local Government Act 1999 and asks the Council to engage with the Department to provide assurance of improvement. The Notice is non-statutory, and the Council remains responsible for local decision- making and service delivery.

The Notice reflects concerns about financial sustainability, the pace and impact of transformation, financial resilience and management, external audit actions and continuing demand pressures in Children’s Services, Adult Social Care and Special Educational Needs and Disabilities and evidence of inconsistent performance in these services as reflected in the Authority’s most recent Ofsted and CQC assessments. These issues are also reflected in the CIPFA External Assurance Review, which was commissioned by MHCLG in response to the Council’s further request for a capitalisation direction in 2026/27. That review concluded that urgent action is required to strengthen grip, accelerate transformation and demonstrate sustained improvement.

Somerset Council has already established an Improvement Advisory Board (IAB) in 2025 to provide advice, challenge and expertise in relation to the Council’s improvement and transformation activity. The Board is advisory in status, accountable to the Council through the Chief Executive, and provides an additional layer of assurance to internal and external stakeholders. Its role is now directly relevant to the Council’s response to the Best Value Notice.

This report proposes a Somerset Improvement and Assurance Framework which brings together the Best Value Notice, CIPFA recommendations, external audit actions, Building Better Finance, Inspiring Innovation and the work of the Improvement Advisory Board into one coherent programme of accountability, delivery and assurance. This framework will build upon and embrace the existing budgetary, management, performance management, risk management, improvement and transformation programme, Annual Governance Statement and internal control assurance reporting that has been provided regularly to the Executive, Scrutiny Committee Corporate & Strategic and the Audit Committee throughout 2025/26 and 2026/27.

It is intended that the Leader of the Council and the Chief Executive will brief and engage Somerset MPs on the Best Value Notice and the Council’s improvement and Assurance Framework.

Recommendations

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Best Value NoticeReport 18 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
General Exception Notice 5 August 2026Report 1 pages Download
PDF
Somerset External Assurance Review 2026Report 54 pages Download

More from Somerset Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Oct 2026 Scrutiny Recommendations to ExecutiveThe Executive Resolved to:- 1) Consider the comments and recommendations made by the four Scrutiny Committees during ... Decided Open
7 Oct 2026 Somerset Parking Review and Charging Principles – October UpdateHaving been duly proposed and seconded, the Executive Resolved to:- a) Approve a 10% increase in all existing car par... Approved Open
7 Oct 2026 Somerset’s Local Transport Delivery Plan 2026-27 to 2029-30Having been duly proposed and seconded, the Executive Resolved to:- · agree the final Local Transport Delivery Plan, ... Agreed Open
7 Oct 2026 Adoption of reviewed Street Naming and Numbering Policy for Somerset CouncilHaving been duly proposed and seconded, the Executive Resolved to approve and adopt the Street Naming and Numbering P... Approved Open
7 Oct 2026 Medium Term Financial Plan Update 2027-28 to 2031-32Having been duly proposed and seconded, the Executive Resolved to:- a) Note the updated budget gap. b) Note the revis... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies