Item20
Resolved
Decision That the Environment Development & Scrutiny Panel requests that the Portfolio Holder reconsiders his decision that the Star Lane toilets are surplus to the Council’s requirements and the panel recommend that no further decision is taken by the Portfolio Holder until the end of November 2004 in order to allow the Stamford Town Council, before that deadline, to make a formal written response setting out its position concerning the possible acquisition of the toilets. The meeting of the panel had been called following the decision taken by Councillor Peter Martin-Mayhew, Portfolio holder for Housing Services, which had been the subject of a call-in requested by three members of the panel. The decision had been that the Star Lane toilets in Stamford were surplus to the Council’s requirements and had been called-in for the following reasons:- · Stamford residents wanted the toilets to be retained. · Inadequate consultation had taken place about costs of refurbishment as a special expense area for Stamford to provide informed judgement. · No investigate of design to eliminate manning needs as used extensively in Cambridge. The Chairman advised members that he had no problem with the decision that had been taken but had signed the call-in in order that the Stamford Councillors could express their views and welcomed the Portfolio holder, Councillor Peter Martin-Mayhew to the meeting. The Corporate Manager Democratic and Legal Services advised the Panel on the call-in process and the decisions that were available to the Panel. He circulated to members a copy of the evidence and background documents relating to the call-in. Panel members then put their case for keeping the Star Lane toilets at Stamford. The main issue raised related to the work that had been undertaken by Stamford Town Council investigating the possibility of acquiring the toilets and the correspondence that had been undertaken between the Council and the Stamford Town Council on the subject. Other issues related to the public’s concern at losing the toilets and the distance from one side of town to the Red Lion Square toilets in an emergency. Also the loss of the asset that the Star Lane toilets represented to the Council. The Chief Executive reminded the Panel that the issue to dispose of the Star Lane toilets had been discussed at the Cabinet meeting on 12th July but no call-in had been requested following that meeting. Also no formal tender had been received from the Stamford Town Council although the marketing agents for the Council were aware of their interest. Councillor Sandall replied that the Stamford Town Council had been led to believe that there was a possibility of a Special Area Expense to cover the provision of toilets for Stamford and therefore had not actively followed the tender route. Following the Panel member’s submissions the Portfolio Holder then explained his position. He informed members that he could not look at Stamford in isolation he had to be seen to be fair to all the towns within the district. He had considered everything that had been ... view the full minutes text for item 20.
Word for word from the decision South Kesteven published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.southkesteven.gov.uk