Resolved
RESOLVED that planning permission be refused for the reasons set out below: I. Unsustainable mix and balance of households The proposed conversion to a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) results in an excessive concentration of HMOs within the immediate area, with 20% of eligible buildings within the defined 40m radius being within HMO use as a consequence of this proposal. Exceeding the Council’s adopted 10% threshold results in an adverse impact on the overall character and amenity of the area surrounding the application site in terms of the mix and balance of households and the availability of a wider choice of accommodation types in the local community, whilst also setting an unwelcome precedent for other similar cases where the 10% threshold is breached. Therefore, the proposal will be contrary to saved Policies SDP1(i) and H4(ii) of the City of Southampton Local Plan Review (Amended 2015), Policy CS16 of the Local Development Framework Core Strategy Development Plan Document (As amended 2015) as supported by section 9 (Policy and Methodology) in the Houses in Multiple Occupation Supplementary Planning Document (Approved May 2016) which states ‘Planning permission will not be granted i) where the proportion of HMO dwellings will exceed 10% of the residential properties’ and therefore this scheme cannot be supported. II. Inadequate (Waste / Servicing) The existing accommodation is currently physically divorced from its refuse storage with no clear area for storage within the flat, and no rear access to the ‘associated’ store to the rear of the site. Residents are expected to take rubbish down the stairs, exit the building onto Portswood Road and then walk along Portswood Road before doubling back into the unmade rear service lane where the refuse store is located; some 210m away from the front door. The conversion of the upper floors to a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) would rely on an inadequate refuse and recycling arrangement to the rear of the site, with no direct access to the store. This deficiency should be resolved before a more intensive use is ... view the full minutes text for item 7.