Item9
Resolved
Universal Credits – Stop and Reverse In moving the motion, Councillor Lizzie Kelly highlighted the plight of residents affected by the introduction of Universal Credit (UC). She indicated that the introduction of UC appeared to have been driven by ideological reasons and she felt it was unfortunate that the Government had not published the Impact Assessment on UC. Councillor Kelly mentioned that the government had ignored warnings of the potential of UC and that UC was having a negative impact on claimants. Councillor Kelly stated that the government should consider scrapping UC instead of trying to fix the system. In seconding the motion, Councillor John Gardner indicated that UC was likely to increase inequality and could potentially destroy the welfare system. Councillor Gardner stated that UC was driving claimants into poverty and this could force some people to turn to crime. The Leader of Council pointed out that after conducting pilots for UC, the Local Government Association (LGA) submitted a report highlighting the following flaws of the system: · Delays in initial payments were likely to lead to rent arrears · Some claimants would not prioritise rent paying · Online only application arrangements were not feasible in view of limited internet access, for some claimants · Daily reporting would be costly – particularly for those relying on public transport · The punitive UC sanctions regime · Constant reporting of change of circumstances could result in payment discrepancies The Leader of the Opposition acknowledged that the system was beset with problems. However, Opposition Members agreed with UC in principle because it was aimed at encouraging people to work rather than relying on benefits. The Leader of the Opposition was not prepared to support the motion, due to what he considered to be inflammatory language used in parts of the motion. Other points raised in the debate included: · It was a fallacy that UC was a good idea in principle · Single-parent families were in the majority of those affected by UC · UC affected more female claimants than males · UC was driving a lot of families to rely on food bank donations · UC was not fully funded and fully resourced as envisaged in the Dynamic Benefit Report · UC appeared to have been designed to fit into the Government’s austerity agenda An amendment was moved by Councillor Robin Parker CC and seconded by Councillor Andy McGuinness as follows: · Deletion of the third and fourth sentences of the first paragraph of the motion, from the words “that underpinning the Act …” to “… welfare since the 1930s”; · Deletion of the first and second bullet points under “Council believes”; and · Deletion in the third bullet point under “Council believes” of the words “an entirely new” and their replacement with “a review of the …” Upon being put to the vote, this amendment was lost. Upon the substantive motion being put to the vote, it was
Word for word from the decision Stevenage published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.stevenage.gov.uk