Resolved
The Interim Assistant Director (Finance & Estates) presented a report in respect of opting in to the Public Sector Audit Appointments (PSAA) process for the appointment of external auditors covering the period April 2023 to March 2028. In response to a series of Members’ questions, the Strategic Director (CF) commented as follows: · the PSAA process for the appointment of auditors would comprise 89 lots and 2 development lots. The PSAA would allocate auditors, and whilst it was possible that Ernst & Young would be appointed again for SBC, there was no way of knowing. The PSAA was endeavouring to attract “new” audit firms to participate in the process; · the scale annual audit fee was quite low in value (approx. £49,000), but because of the increased rigour required by the Government in the audit of local authority accounts the likelihood of “add-on” fees was increased. This was particularly the case should an authority (like SBC) have a Housing Revenue Account and substantial Capital Programme, which increased the complexities and risk levels of the audit; · at present, most of the Hertfordshire local authorities were audited by Ernst & Young. Going forward, the authorities in each lot would not necessarily be audited by the same audit company; · the nationwide shortage of auditors (and the specialist nature of local authority audit) would lead to the conclusion that to opt-in to the PSAA process would seem a prudent approach, both in terms of the resilience and experience of those undertaking the audit. To opt out would place the Council at risk of a sub-standard audit or possibly being in a position where it was unable to appoint any suitable audit firm; and · there was no monetary fine for being late in the finalisation of an audit, although there would always be a knock-on impact on future audits. The exception was for Housing Benefits audits, whereby the Department of Work & Pensions could fine authorities for a late return. Fortunately, they had chosen not to do so during the Covid pandemic. It was