CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Sutton
Carshalton Forum, Wednesday 14 July 2004 at 7.30pm

Matters Arising

Agreed Committee 1 paper

Carshalton Forum agreed this item on Wednesday 14 July 2004. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item5

Resolved

Resolved : That John Phillips, Heritage Manager, report back to the Forum regarding the Grotto when further information was available. Electricity Failure – It was reported that [name removed], Old West Street Residents’ Association, would be able to up-date the Forum at the next meeting. Tree Pruning Resolved : That Councillor John Dodwell speaks to [name removed] outside the meeting, regarding her neighbour’s tree. Signage for Carshalton Village – [name removed], Woodstock Residents’ Association, circulated a paper outlining a proposal for a Heritage sign marking the entry into the Carshalton conservation area. Members discussed this proposal and the following points were raised: · Agreement would be needed before any funding could be sought · Installing a sign might be dependent upon Transport for London’s approval · The sign would have to be in keeping with a Heritage site · A previous proposal for a sign was rejected on the grounds that it would add to the general ‘clutter’ of signage · If approved, it was felt more appropriate for the sign to be situated in the centre of Carshalton Resolved : (a) That the installation of a Heritage sign in the centre of Carshalton be agreed in principle. (b) That the proposal to install a Heritage sign in the centre of Carshalton be referred to the Carshalton and Clockhouse Area Committee for discussion.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Sutton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Carshalton Forum

Page 7 Agenda Item 5 London Borough of Sutton 5b Strategy Committee – 8 June 2004

REFERENCES FROM THE CARSHALTON FORUM (21/4/04)

ISSUES RAISED BY MEMBERS OF THE FORUM State of the Grotto – Cllr Hamish Pollock raised the poor state of the Grotto as an issue. Cllr Angela Baughan had previously suggested that the Council submit a Heritage Lottery Bid. Resolved: A reference to the Strategy Committee be made outlining the Forum’s concerns about the state of the Grotto.

The Executive Head of Leisure and Parks has provided the following information:

Background The Grotto in Carshalton dates from about 1724 and was part of the garden linked to Carshalton Park House. Construction of the house was started but never finished and it is likely that the garden was never fully completed. The Grotto though, certainly was finalised. The front and inside of the Grotto was originally decorated with glass waste, sea shells and ‘coral’ made from lead. There was a statue of Neptune on the top. The Grotto was poorly restored about 1914. Almost all the present brick front dates from this time. The central chamber has more original features. The brick culverts beneath the structure also date back to the initial build. Despite the damage, the building is an important example of an early 18 Century Palladian style garden feature. It is Grade 2 listed and is on the English Heritage Register of listed buildings at risk.

Current Building Condition/Vandalism The building is very vulnerable to vandalism and has had graffiti sprayed onto it on numerous occasions. This has been cleaned off but the process of cleaning is gradually eroding the surface of the brickwork. In the past the Parks Service has contacted a specialist graffiti removal company to undertake cleaning work. The Parks Service do not have the £5,000 quoted to carry out this work. There is concern that if money is spent removing graffiti it may well reappear. We have looked at wax coating the surfaces. This will make graffiti easier to remove. This is not satisfactory as it does not provide protection for the brick underneath which still has to be removed along with the graffiti by jet washer. The wax coating then has to be reapplied. However, the Grotto chamber has not been vandalised as the entrance gate has been secured for many years. A good deal of litter has however, been thrown into it. Page 8

Restoration Work In conjunction with the Council’s Heritage Service, I will investigate the funding options available, including the Heritage Lottery Fund (HLF) to restore the Grotto. From recent experience however, the HLF seem to be more interested in educational projects, rather than pure building restoration.

Security The buildings fundamental problem is security. If this cannot be improved any restoration work will be undermined by vandalism. The options available include: (a) Fence around the structure. This will be very intrusive and may not be effective. The view of the Grotto along the canal could be preserved by using a ha-ha (sunken wall) but this would be costly. In the last few weeks we have discovered that the archaeology of the site may be more complicated than previously thought. This could have implications for the construction of a ha- ha. (b) Install a CCTV system to monitor the site and perhaps deter vandals. (c) Endeavour to change attitudes towards this structure. The Heritage Service has said that at present the Grotto does not look very interesting and most park visitors probably don’t know what it is. It may be possible to install an audio system and lights within the Grotto chamber. If they were linked to a movement detector they could come on as park users approached the Grotto door. It is difficult to know what effect this would have on vandals who tend to attack neglected and uncared for buildings. An active audio system might alter perceptions. It may also give the feeling that the site is being actively monitored.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
14075BReport 17 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 21 attended
CL
Christine LindsayPublic, expected
AB
Councillor Angela BaughanChair, expected
JD
Councillor John DodwellCommittee Member, expected
PG
Councillor Peter GeiringerCommittee Member, expected
JM
Councillor Joe MageeCommittee Member, expected
CM
Councillor Charlie MansellCommittee Member, expected
CP
Councillor Chris PenningtonCommittee Member, expected
HP
Councillor Hamish PollockCommittee Member, expected
AT
Councillor Andrew TheobaldCommittee Member, expected
AC
Alistair CruickshankPublic, expected
MC
Maurine CoultPublic, expected
JF
John FaulknerPublic, expected

All 21 on the meeting page

On this subject at Sutton

Search all
  1. Matters ArisingThis decision
  2. Minutes and matters arisingAgreed
  3. Minutes and matters arisingAgreed
  4. Minutes and Matters ArisingAgreed
  5. Matters arisingNoted
  6. Minutes of previous meeting and Matters ArisingNoted

More from Sutton Carshalton Forum

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Jul 2007 Appointment of chair and vice chairAgreed: (i) That Councillor Pollock be Chair of the Carshalton Forum for the municipal year 2007/08. (ii) That subjec... Agreed Open
3 Jul 2007 Appointment of community representativesAgreed : (i) That the Community Representatives for 2006/07be re-appointed for 2007/08. (ii) To note the requests to ... Agreed Open
3 Jul 2007 Matters arisingAgreed: (i) To note that alterations on the Ecology Centre had been carried out with the Heritage Manager’s approval.... Agreed Open
3 Jul 2007 Changes to the council's area working structureAgreed: (i) To note the comments made at the meeting on the proposed new structure and that any further comments be s... Agreed Open
3 Jul 2007 Update from references to area committeeAgreed: (i) To note the update regarding the railings and wall opposite Carshalton Ponds which advised that the Counc... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies