That planning permission for application No. C2006/55541/FUL be refused for the reasons set out in the Appendix to these Minutes. Councillor Paul Scully declared a personal interest in this application because he had addressed the matter before his election to the Council. Councillor Janet Lowne declared a personal interest in this application because the resident who addressed the meeting was a friend, and did not speak on the matter thereafter or vote thereon.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
The application site comprises four detached residential properties, three of which are two storeyed houses and one of which is a bungalow. The site area is 2600 sq. metres and each property has access to Rotherfield Road.
Save for the All Saints Church of England Primary School near the application site, Rotherfield Road itself is almost wholly residential in nature. The houses are largely a mixture of pre-war detached and semi-detached two storey types, some having additional rooms in the roof. Nearby to the north there are the largely three storey commercial uses of the High Street of Carshalton Village, which is identified as a ‘District Centre’ in the Sutton Unitary Development Plan (UDP). Public open space lies to the west, being part of a canal and within the Carshalton Village Conservation Area.
The site is located within an Archaeological Priority Area as defined in the UDP. The site lies adjacent to the Carshalton Village Conservation Area to the north and west.
1.2Relevant Planning History
Of particularly relevance to the current application is a recent scheme (ref. C2005/54726/FUL) for the demolition of the existing dwellings and erection of a two storey building with roof accommodation to provide sheltered accommodation, comprising eleven 1- bedroomed and twenty two 2-bedroomed self contained flats, a guest suite, communal lounge and office, provision of refuse and buggy/cycle stores, eleven car parking spaces and a new access. This application was refused planning permission on 6 December 2005 for the following reasons:-
1 Page 50
1. The proposed building, due to its excessive bulk, height and width, would constitute an overdevelopment of the site not respecting the appearance of the streetscene and would adversely affect the character of the area and the setting of the adjacent Carshalton Village Conservation Area. The application is therefore contrary to policies G/BE1, BE1, BE2, BE36, HSG1, G/HSG1 and HSG4 of the Sutton Unitary Development Plan.
2. The proposed development would adversely affect the streetscene of Rotherfield Road and the setting of the adjacent Carshalton Village Conservation Area due to the predominance of car parking and a lack of soft landscaping within the site’s frontage. The application is therefore contrary to policies G/BE1, BE1, BE2, BE12, BE36, G/HSG1, HSG1 and HSG4 of the Sutton Unitary Development Plan.
3. The proposed building, due to likely overlooking from upper floor side and rear windows, would have an unacceptable adverse impact on the privacy of the adjoining residential occupiers and the play area of the adjacent primary school. The application is therefore contrary to policies BE4, BE18 and HSG1 of the Sutton Unitary Development Plan.
4. The proposed building, due to its bulk, height, width and proximity to the boundaries of the site would have an unacceptable adverse impact on the outlook of adjoining residential occupiers. The application is therefore contrary to policies BE4 and HSG1 of the Sutton Unitary Development Plan.
The decision was appealed and heard at a hearing held on 25 April 2006. The decision of the Secretary of State is still forthcoming.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.