That a decision on whether or not to demolish the public conveniences at Sutton Green be deferred and the parks team collate additional information for inclusion in a further report, as follows: · The cost of refurbishing and reopening the conveniences, including bringing them up to Disability Discrimination Act standards · The cost of maintaining them · How the conveniences could be policed to minimise the chance of vandalism / anti-social behaviour, this to include the viability of a coin-operated facility · What other conveniences there are in that part of the Town Centre · Confirmation via the Legal Division of the name of the current ‘Lord of the Manor’ and whether a beneficial (as opposed to continuous) change of use within the existing structure would be illegal.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
Report of the Executive Head of Street Scene Services
Sutton Green – Public Conveniences
Ward Location: Sutton North Author(s) and Contact Phone Number(s): Peter O’Connell, Executive Head of Street Scene Services – 020 8770 6400 Mark Dalzell, Head of Parks Service – 020 8770 4695 Area Served: Not applicable Lead Councillor: Councillor Colin Hall, Lead Councillor for the Environment
Report for Decision
Summary The public conveniences at Sutton Green have been closed to the public since 2003, due to the vandalism and other antisocial behaviour that they used to attract when they were open. The toilet block building is unsightly and detracts from the appearance of the green and the surrounding area. Legal Counsel has recommended that the building be demolished in order to present the land as if it had never existed. Recommendations I recommend the Committee to: Agree to the demolition of the toilet block, subject to obtaining consent from the Lord of the Manor 1. Background 1.1 The public conveniences on Sutton Green were built on land registered as village green under the Commons Registration Act 1965. The reputed owner of the village green, including the public conveniences, is [name removed] (Lord of the Manor). 1.2 The public conveniences were closed to the public in 2003 as a budget saving due to ongoing vandalism and other antisocial behaviour which occurred prior to this time.
1 Agenda Item 9 Page 18
2. Issues 2.1 Legal Counsel has advised the following in relation to the public conveniences on Sutton Green: a) As building on a village green is a criminal offence, it was probably a criminal offence to have erected the building in the first place b) The London Borough of Sutton could not now change the use of the building, as to do so would continue and worsen the offence. c) It is arguable that, now that the London Borough of Sutton’s attention has been drawn to the potential illegality of the building, it should be removed d) LBS would need to obtain the permission of the Lord of the Manor prior to doing anything to the toilet block. e) It would not be acceptable to turn the toilet block into something else, as converting it would be both an offence and a public nuisance. 2.2 Bearing in mind the above, Legal Counsel has concluded that there are only three options open to the Council: a) Leave the building as it is and maintain the status quo b) Put the building back as a public toilet c) Demolish the building and restore to grass Of these three options, Legal Counsel’s opinion is that the safest option would be to demolish the building and present the land upon which the toilet block is sited, as if the building had never existed. 2.3 Reopening the toilets would have substantial costs attached, both for initial renovation, but also in terms of future maintenance, as it is likely that they would again be subjected to vandalism, on top of the cleaning regime required. 2.4 The estimated cost of demolishing the building is £12,400 + VAT. 3. Financial Implications 3.1 The work is being funded from the scheme E084 Sutton Town Centre Improvements capital budget for 2007/08. There is currently a budget of £100k for 2007/08, of which £34k has been spent to date. Financial provision has already been released in the sum of £50K, to enable more general improvements to Sutton Town Centre. The £34K spend has reduced this balance to £16k and this sum is therefore available to fund the demolition work. 4. Influence of the Council’s Core Values 4.1 This is a practical demonstration of the Council’s commitment to enhancing the quality of the open character of the Borough as it will improve the appearance of the area thus helping to engender pride of place. Background Papers None.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.