That application No. 5870/12/00570/LAPREM be refused for the following reasons:- ( i ) Having considered all of the evidence, the Sub-Committee is of the view that granting the extension would not promote the licensing objectives in that there would be a significant risk of increased public nuisance to residents in the area. (ii) The Sub-Committee considered imposing conditions to deal with this but do not consider that there are appropriate conditions which would be reasonable and/or proportionate to deal with the issue of public nuisance.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1On 3rd February 2006 an application for a new premises licence was received from Pizza Hut (UK) Ltd requesting late night refreshment until 00:30 every day. Representations were received and a subcommittee hearing was held on 27 April 2006.
1.2The subcommittee resolved to issue a premises licence but with reduced hours as set out below:
1.3There was only one condition proposed in the operating schedule which was attached to the licence which is set out below:
1. Notices will be displayed reminding patrons to leave quietly and respect the local residents.
1.4On 11 June 2012 an application to transfer the premises licence was received from A Team PH Limited which was granted and remains in place.
2 APPLICATION TO VARY
2.1On 6 July 2012 an application was received from the new premises licence holders to vary the premises licence as set out below:
Late Night Refreshment
Everyday 23:00 – 03:00
Opening Hours
Everyday 10:00 – 01:00
2.2There are no additional conditions proposed in the operating schedule of the application.
3 REPRESENTATIONS
3.1Valid representations were received against the variation application from the following parties:
Applicant Applicant Representation Objection Name Address Type Type Cllr Sue Stears Civic Offices, Other Persons Prevention of Cllr Colin Stears Sutton Public Cllr Roger Thistle Nuisance
[name removed] Offices, Responsible Prevention of Environmental Sutton Authority Public Health Officer Nuisance Page 9 Agenda Item 4
4. REPRESENTATIONS
4.1The representation from the ward Councillors is set out below:
This is a residential area and people living above have already expressed concern about them overrunning into the night and preventing them sleeping.
They have a very loud door alarm which is set off whenever the door is opened and closed and this should certainly not be permitted to be activated into the night.
They have no parking for mopeds, other than their own frontage, which is badly damaged and a trip hazard; further coming and goings of delivery mopeds from this frontage, into the night, would unreasonably disturb residents above and to the sides, during their normal sleeping hours.
4.2The representation from the Environmental Health Department is attached in full at appendix A.
5 CONSIDERATIONS
5.1In determining this application consideration must be given to the promotion of the licensing objectives, the London Borough of Sutton Licensing Policy and the Section 182 guidance issued by the secretary of state.
5.2The subcommittee may find that sections 2.33 to 2.40, 9.27 to 9.40 and 10.21 of the section 182 guidance of particular relevance to this application.
5.3Any decision of the subcommittee can only apply to the amendments sought in the variation application.
5.4It should also be noted that since the amendments to the Licensing Act 2003 any decision must be made if it is deemed appropriate rather than necessary
Options
6.1The following options are available to the subcommittee:
1. Grant the variation as applied for 2. Grant with appropriate conditions 3. Grant with amended hours 4. Refuse the application Agenda Item 4 Page 10
Appendix A
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.