Item27
Resolved
The panel partially upheld the first ground of appeal of procedural deficiency in that: 1. The panel believed there was poor judgement in using the holder of POST NO. S3008362 as the HR advisor to the investigating officer but that by doing so it did not materially affect the outcome. 2. The panel considered that the letters sent to the holder of POST NO. S3006841 indicated that the three initial charges, if proven, could result in a penalty of action short of dismissal. Subsequently an additional allegation was included and management indicated that with this additional allegation it could constitute gross misconduct and result in dismissal. When the additional allegation was found to be unproven the original indication of a penalty of action short of dismissal should, therefore, have remained. The panel partially upheld the second ground of appeal of fairness of the decision in that: 3. The panel did not uphold the appeal against allegation one because they believed that POST NO S3006841 did not follow the accepted team procedure with regard to making home visits. 4. With regard to allegation two the panel found that there was no corroborative evidence on management claims that information was modified and/or falsified on the whiteboard and therefore upheld the appeal on this point. 5. The panel did not uphold the appeal on allegation three which was founded but the panel took into consideration the holder of POST NO S3005874’s statement to the holder of POST NO S3005625 that she was worried she had not responded appropriately. 6. The panel also considered the holder of POST NO. S3006841’ s mitigation in relation to his personal circumstances. The panel upheld the third ground of appeal of severity of the decision in that: 7. In view of the panel’s decision in relation to the three allegations, the decision was that the penalty of summary dismissal was too severe and would therefore substitute a penalty of final written warning.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk