Resolved That the CIPFA set out at Appendix B to the report be noted. That the outcomes to the next steps proposed by CIPFA outlined in paragraphs 3.6 to 3.14 of the report be noted. That the report and recommendations in relation to financial sustainability be referred to the SDEN Board so they can review and incorporate it into its future Business plan for future reporting to the Sutton Shareholdings Board. That the Council agree to reducing the interest charged on its loan to SDEN in line with the subsidy option available and outlined in 3.14 of the report. That the actions being taken to improve project governance in relation to major capital projects and which have been reported to the Audit and Governance Committee be noted. That, where delegation is given to officers, the outcomes of that delegation are reported back to the Committee who gave the delegation as set out in paragraph 3.12 of the report. (Note - only resolution 3,4 and 6 were subject to Council approval) Recorded Vote Title Type Recorded Vote text Result Requisition - SDEN Review Report at Council Agreed View Recorded Vote for this item
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1In accordance with procedure rule 23.4 (Requisitions), Council is asked to consider a requisition of resolutions 3, 4, and 6 of the SDEN Review report as agreed by the Strategy and Resources Committee on 1 November 2021.
2 Recommendation(s)
2.1To determine the resolutions of the Strategy and Resources Committee meeting of 1 November 2021.
Report Page 1 Agenda Item 7 Page 46 Requisition of the SDEN Review
3 Background and Key Information
3.1The requisition was submitted on 3 November 2021 by Councillors James McDermott-Hill, Neil Garratt, Tony Shields, Catherine Gray, and Tom Drummond. The requisition is set out as follows:
“Request to requisition an item from Strategy and Resources Committee meeting of Monday 1st November 2021, 7:30 pm
Cllrs McDermott-Hill, Garratt, Crowley, Gray and Drummond express their wish to requisition to the next full Council, recommendations 2.3, 2.4 and 2.6 of agenda item 7 – To receive the outcome of the CIPFA review of SDEN, including the financial model and also options to ensure its future sustainability.
We wish to requisition this item for the following reasons:
1. Hundreds of homes in New Mill Quarter depend on SDEN to provide their heating and hot water, and that any decisions regarding SDEN must take account of the need to provide a long term reliable and affordable service to those residents.
2. The need for residents to have certainty and confidence they are not going to be burdened with the financial failings of SDEN.
3. Members of the Strategy and Resources Committee were asked to vote on a short term bail out for SDEN without sight of a business plan that sets out the short to medium term strategy for SDEN.
4. Concern that the administration members of the Committee do not appear to have learned the lessons highlighted in the CIPFA report and appear determined to continue with this project whilst displaying clear optimism bias as to SDEN's financial sustainability.
The outcomes we are seeking are as follows:
1. Agree a process for members to explore the long term strategic options for SDEN as per para 3.15, and, taking account of the new SDEN business plan once it’s published, decide what its future should be and whether long term support is needed from the Council.
2. To refer the Cipfa report to the Audit & Governance Committee to consider any further recommendations on governance or financial control arising from it.
3. To agree that in the light of the Cipfa report, the fictitious houses, and non-existent Renewable Heat Incentive grant the council should refer the flawed decision-making process to the Monitoring Officer for a full investigation into how this was allowed to happen.”
Report Page 2 Page 47 Agenda Item 7 Requisition of the SDEN Review
Process
3.2The process for considering requisitions is for the relevant committee Chair to move the adoption of the minute of the decision that has been requisitioned, which members may then debate and vote upon.
3.3The draft minute of the item is attached at Appendix A.
3.4The report and appendices considered by the Strategy and Resources Committee are attached at Appendix B.
3.5Council can:
● Confirm the draft minute of the decision of the Strategy and Resources Committee; or ● Accept the actions requested by the requisitioners, as set out in paragraph 3.1.
4 The report to the Strategy and Resources Committee
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.