CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Sutton
Planning Committee, Wednesday 3 April 2024 at 7.00pm

DM2023/01097 - 27-29 High Street, Carshalton SM5 3AX

Refused Planning 5 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 3 April 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item75

Resolved

That planning permission be refused for application No. DM2023/01097 Recorded Vote Title Type Recorded Vote text Result DM2023/01097 - 27-29 High Street, Carshalton SM5 3AX Committee Report A poll vote on the officers’ recommendation to refuse planning permission was held in accordance with Standing Order 31.4, when there voted: Agreed View Recorded Vote for this item
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Sutton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Summary

1.1The application proposal is for the demolition of the existing single storey building and erection of a three storey building to provide two commercial units (Class E) at ground floor and 9 self contained residential units (Class C3) at first and second floor with associated amenity areas, provision of off-street car parking at the rear, together with refuse and cycle storage and landscaping.

1.2This application has been referred to the Planning Committee because the planning agent is a relative of a member of staff from the Council.

Recommendation

2.1To REFUSE planning permission, for the following reasons:

Summary of reasons for recommendation

2.2The design of the proposal would fail to preserve and enhance the Carshalton Village Conservation Area and would cause unacceptable harm to its character.

2.3The proposal would fail to provide a minimum of 50% of all dwellings on the site as having three bedrooms or more and is therefore unacceptable in principle.

2.4The proposal would result in an unacceptably adverse impact on neighbour amenity to adjacent residential properties. Agenda Item 6 Page 42 DM2023/01097 27 - 29 High Street, Carshalton, SM5 3AX

2.5The proposal would fail to deliver an acceptable standard of accommodation for the future occupiers.

2.6The proposal would result in an unacceptably adverse impact on the safe and efficient operation of the public highway.

2.7It has not been demonstrated that the proposed development would deliver the necessary reduction in CO2 emissions by way of renewable energy.

2.8It has not been demonstrated that internal potable water consumption for each of the dwellings will be limited to 110 litres per person per day.

2.9The proposal would result in an unacceptable loss of trees within the Carshalton Village Conservation Area and fails to provide high quality landscaping by design.

2.10It has not been clearly demonstrated that the proposed development would not result in a net loss of biodiversity on site.

2.11The proposal is unacceptable in terms of the lack of a completed S106 agreement to secure CPZ restrictions.

3 Background and Key Information

Reasons for Refusal.

3.1The reasons for refusal of this application are attached at Appendix B.

3.2Site and surroundings

3.3The application site is located in a prominent location within the Carshalton Village Conservation Area and is within the Primary Shopping Frontage of Carshalton District Centre.

3.4The site comprises a single storey building which is currently in use as a pharmacy (Use Class E) and has a large area to the rear which is overgrown and currently disused. The application site is located in Carshalton Village Conservation Area within an area of 'good' levels of public transport accessibility (PTAL 4).

3.5Directly to the west of the site is The Forge, a three storey mixed use commercial and residential building which as-built is unauthorised. Although an appeal (ref: APP/P5870/C/21/3289021) was determined and allowed by the Planning Inspectorate, this was subject to a condition, the wording of which means that the ultimate outcome of whether or not the main structure will remain, and in what exact format, is as yet unknown.

3.6To the west are The Almshouses 1-4 The Green, a row of terrace single storey dwellings which are to the rear of the Forge. To the north is The Grove Hall, which is currently Page 43 Agenda Item 6 DM2023/01097 27 - 29 High Street, Carshalton, SM5 3AX

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
6) Planning Committee Report: DM2023_01097: 27: 29 High StreetReport 393 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
6A) DM2023 01097 27-29 High Street Appendix A PLANAppendix 997 KB Download
PDF
6B) DM2023_01097 27: 29 High Street Draft Decision Appendix B.docxDecisions 53 KB Download
PDF
Addendum Report: Planning Committee 03 April 2024.docxAddendum 127 KB Download
PDF
Wednesday 3 April 2024: Planning Committee: Applicant_Agent: Mat SmithReport 111 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

11 of 11 attended
RC
Councillor Richard CliftonChair, present
JM
Councillor Jayne McCoyVice-Chair, present
SC
Councillor Sam CumberCommittee Member, present
TF
Councillor Trish FiveyCommittee Member, present
AH
Councillor Amy HaldaneCommittee Member, present
PO
Councillor Patrick OgbonnaCommittee Member, present
EA
Councillor Eric AllenCommittee Member, present
PM
Councillor Patrick MagnusCommittee Member, present
TS
Councillor Tony ShieldsCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
TF
Councillor Tim FosterCommittee Member, present
PG
Councillor Peter GeiringerSubstitute, present as substitute

On this subject at Sutton

Search all
  1. DM2023/01097 - 27-29 High Street, Carshalton SM5 3AXThis decision
  2. APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00202 - Land Opposite 284 - 286 High Street, Sutton SM1 1PQAgreed
  3. APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00124 - Land Outside 78 - 82 High Street, Sutton SM1 1EZAgreed
  4. APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00125 - Land Outside 78 - 82 High Street, Sutton SM1 1EZDecided
  5. DM2025/00952 Elm Grove Estate 216 - 220 High Street Sutton SM1 1NUAgreed
  6. DM2025/01068 Elm Grove Estate 216 - 220 High Street Sutton SM1 1NUApproved

More from Sutton Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
5 Aug 2026 Minutes of the previous meetingRESOLVED : 1. That the minutes of the meeting held on 10 June 2026 be agreed as an accurate record. 2. That the minut... Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2025/00363 - Garages To The Rear Of Sandringham Court And Buckingham Court, Dorset Road, Belmont SM2 6NGAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00287 - 48 Hallmead Road, Sutton SM1 1RDAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00106 - 21 Morton Gardens, Wallington SM6 8EUAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2025/01315 - 15 Surrey Grove, Sutton SM1 3PWAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies