CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Sutton
Planning Committee, Wednesday 4 December 2024 at 7.00pm

DM2024/01256 - 11 Crichton Road Carshalton SM5 3LS

Decided Planning 6 papers

Planning Committee decided this item on Wednesday 4 December 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item41

Resolved

To GRANT ... view the full minutes text for item 41. Recorded Vote Title Type Recorded Vote text Result DM2024/01256 - 11 Crichton Road Carshalton SM5 3LS Committee Report A poll vote on the officers’ recommendation was held in accordance with Standing Order 31.4 Drawn View Recorded Vote for this item
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Sutton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Summary

1.1The application seeks planning permission for the change of use from Class E (GP Surgery) to Class C4 (HMO) to provide 6 rooms and provision of cycle and bin storage at the front.

1.2This application has been referred to the committee because 39 letters of objection have been received and the application has been de-delegated by Cllr Moira Butt.

Recommendation

2.1To GRANT planning permission, subject to the conditions outlined at Appendix B.

Summary of reasons for recommendation

2.2The loss of the GP’s surgery is considered acceptable as alternative provision is made nearby and importantly, changes to the Use Classes Order in 2020 mean that a GP’s surgery can change to a number of other commercial, business and Service uses under Class E of that order without planning permission. This is a material consideration of substantial weight which tilts the planning balance towards a recommendation to approve in the context of the Council’s Development Plan. On this basis, and noting that it is possible to use a single family dwelling as a small HMO within Class C4, it is considered that the proposed use is acceptable within this residential area.

2.3The proposed development would help meet an identified need for housing delivery in Sutton and a nationally recognised need for HMOs.

Report Page 1 Agenda Item 7 Page 44 DM2024/01256 11 Crichton Road, Carshalton, SM5 3LS

2.4There would be no external changes made to the property so there would be no impact on the character and appearance of the area subject to further details of the bin and cycle stores, to be secured by condition.

2.5The proposed scheme would provide adequate living accommodation for the future occupiers and would not result in harm to the amenities of neighbouring properties in terms of increased noise and disturbance or loss of light, privacy and outlook.

2.6The proposal would not result in an adverse impact on parking provision or highway and pedestrian safety.

3 Background and Key Information

Conditions

3.1The conditions attached to this application are included at Appendix B.

Site and surroundings

3.2The application site comprises 11 Crichton Road, a two storey semi-detached building on Crichton Road. The property was used as a doctor’s surgery since 1989 but has been vacant since the beginning of 2024. Formerly known as Carshalton Fields Surgery, it has closed and relocated, merging with Wallington Family Practice, with all patients now being seen at the Jubilee Health Centre in Wallington. The immediate area is residential in character.

3.3The site has a mixed PTAL rating of 2 which indicates a poor level of public transport accessibility. The site is not located within a Controlled Parking Zone (CPZ) and is in close proximity to Carshalton Beeches Railway Station.

Site specific designations

3.4There are a number of Tree Protection Orders (TPOs) on the site.

Planning History

3.5S1989/33528 - Use of premises as a doctor's surgery.

3.6S1990/34485 - Erection of a car port and refuse enclosure at side (to comply with Condition 2 and amendment to Condition 3 of previous approval application No. S89/33528/FUL).

3.7S1992/37224 - Erection of a single-storey flank extension and formation of new entrance porch incorporating refuse store, all in connection with existing doctors surgery.

Report Page 2 Page 45 Agenda Item 7 DM2024/01256 11 Crichton Road, Carshalton, SM5 3LS

4 Application Proposals

4.1Planning permission is sought for the change of use from Class E (GP Surgery) to Class C4 (HMO) to provide 6 rooms and provision of cycle and bins storage at the front.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
11 Crichton Road PLAN Appendix AAppendix 6.3 MB Download
PDF
Addendum Report: Planning Committee 04 December 2024.docxAddendum 104 KB Download
PDF
Petition HMOAppendix D 209 KB Withheld: personal details
PDF
DM2024_01256: Appendix B: Draft Decision: 11 Crichton RoadDecisions 62 KB Download
PDF
DM2024_01256: Appendix C: Address List: 11 Crichton RoadAppendix 35 KB Download
PDF
DM2024_01256: Planning Committee Report: 11 Crichton RoadReport 240 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 12 attended
RC
Councillor Richard CliftonChair, present
JM
Councillor Jayne McCoyVice-Chair, present
AH
Councillor Amy HaldaneCommittee Member, apologies
PO
Councillor Patrick OgbonnaCommittee Member, present
DB
Councillor David BartolucciCommittee Member, apologies
EJ
Councillor Edward JoyceCommittee Member, present
EA
Councillor Eric AllenCommittee Member, present
PM
Councillor Patrick MagnusCommittee Member, present
TS
Councillor Tony ShieldsCommittee Member, present
TF
Councillor Tim FosterCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Sam CumberSubstitute, present as substitute
TF
Councillor Trish FiveySubstitute, present as substitute

More from Sutton Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
5 Aug 2026 Minutes of the previous meetingRESOLVED : 1. That the minutes of the meeting held on 10 June 2026 be agreed as an accurate record. 2. That the minut... Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2025/00363 - Garages To The Rear Of Sandringham Court And Buckingham Court, Dorset Road, Belmont SM2 6NGAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00287 - 48 Hallmead Road, Sutton SM1 1RDAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2026/00106 - 21 Morton Gardens, Wallington SM6 8EUAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open
5 Aug 2026 APPLICATION NO. DM2025/01315 - 15 Surrey Grove, Sutton SM1 3PWAgreed View Recorded Vote for this item Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies