Resolved
RESOLVED that (1) the undermentioned planning application BE APPROVED subject to the conditions in the report and/or indicated below: #( Item 6) Application No 2014/0343 One non – illuminated post mounted entrance sign, and 4 externally illuminated fascia signs and 2 wall mounted information signs on proposed customer shopping collection building at Asda Stores Ltd, Heol Y Mynydd , Gorseinon [name removed] (agent) addressed the Committee. #( Item 7) Application No 2014/0344 Customer shopping collection building and canopy at Asda Stores Ltd, Heol Y Mynydd , Gorseinon . [name removed] (agent) addressed the Committee. #( Item 9) Application No 2014/0146 Change of use from video rental store ( Class A1) to Estate Agents ( Class A2) at former Blockbuster Video Express, 448 Gower Road, Killay . [name removed] (agent) addressed the Committee. (2) the undermentioned planning applications BE REFUSED subject to the reasons in the report and / or indicated below: ( Item 2) Application No 2014/ 0005 Incorporation of land into residential curtilage on land to the rear of 11 Llys Le Breos , Mayals . Application refused contrary to the officers recommendation for the following reason:- Reason The proposal would represent an incongruous form of development which would be detrimental to the visual amenities of the area contrary to the provisions of Policy EV1 and EV26 of the City and County of Swansea Unitary Development Plan ( 2008). Report was updated as follows:- Page 20, this application was reported to Committee at the request of Councillor Linda Tyler-Lloyd. #( Item 3 ) Application No 2014/0379 Retention of front wall and fencing to a maximum height of 2m at 5 Clyne Crescent, Mayals . [name removed] (applicant) addressed the committee. (3) the undermentioned planning application BE REFERRED to the Development Management and Control Committee with a recommendation that it be approved, contrary to the officers recommendation on the grounds that the new dwelling would serve a long standing sawmill business which makes a significant contribution to the rural economy and would not result in a detrimental impact upon the character and appearance of the area. #( Item 5 ) Application No 2013/1745 Detached dwelling in association with sawmill (outline) at Cilibion Saw Mills, Cilibion . [name removed] (applicant) addressed the Committee. The report was updated as follows: Page 40 – Bullet points 6 – 12 should read 1 – 6. Letter from Gower Chiropractic Centre confirming that the applicants father had been treated for joint conditions. (4) that the Welsh Government be informed that had the appeal not been made, the City and County of Swansea would have refused the application contrary to the officers recommendation, for the undermentioned reason: #( Item 8) Application No 2013/1366 Retention and completion of replacement dwelling ( amendment to planning permission 2011/1339 granted on 28 March 2013) at 27 Slade Road Newton [name removed] ( objector) addressed the Committee. It was requested that it the Welsh Government be informed that the majority of members voted in favour of this decision. Reason Retention of the dwelling, by virtue of its siting, scale and height would have a Detrimental impact upon the residential amenities of the occupiers of neighbouring dwellings contrary to the provisions of Policies EV1, EV2 and HC2 of the City and County of Swansea Unitary Development Plan ( 2008) The report was updated as follows: Page 64 and 65 – Site History Planning Application Ref 2010/0483 and 2011/1339 relate specifically to this site. Page 67, second paragraph the site was occupied by a low lying small detached bungalow which has been demolished. The meeting ended at 4.10p.m.