Resolved
RESOLVED that: (1) the undermentioned planning application BE APPROVED subject to the conditions in the report and/or indicated below: #(Item 2) Planning Application No.2014/0769 Detached bungalow at Rear of 17 Melcorn Drive, Newton, Swansea. [name removed](objector) and [name removed](applicant) addressed the Committee. Report updated as follows - Page 22 - Policies add “Policy EV30 - Protection and improved management of woodlands, trees and hedgerows which are important for their visual amenity, historic environment, natural heritage, and/or recreation value will be encouraged.” Page 27 - 4 th paragraph add ‘Policy EV30” Page 29 – 2 nd paragraph add sentence “to mitigate against the potential noise / nuisance impact upon , an acoustic fence is proposed to the side and rear boundary. The details of which are required to be submitted via condition 6.” Page 29 – add additional paragraph : “Tree T5 (sycamore) is a TPO tree and is to be retained on site. A tree survey and tree protection plan has been submitted which demonstrate the mechanisms for protecting the TPO tree during the course of construction. As such it is considered that the development would not cause a harmful impact on the TPO tree and is compliant with Policy EV30” Page 32 - Replace plan number HG.13.34.11A site location plan dated 28 May 2014 with HG.13.34.11B revised site location plan dated 13 June 2014 and; Replace plan number HG.13.34.21A Ground floor plan dated 28 May 2014 with HG.13.34.21B Revised ground floor layout dated 21 July 2014 Approved in accordance with recommendation subject to reference to the amended plans detailed above. #(Item 3) Planning Application No.2014/0889 Replacement dwelling and detached outbuilding with associated landscaping at 89 Southgate Road, Southgate, Swansea. [name removed](objector) and [name removed](agent) addressed the Committee. Report updated as follows - Page 41 – 2 nd paragraph – replace ‘form’ with “from” (Item 7) Planning Application No.2014/0847 First floor balcony to rear elevation at Haven, Llangennith, Swansea. (Item 8) Planning Application No.2014/0816 Variation of condition 1 of Planning Permission 2009/0618 granted 17th June 2009 to extend the period of time for a further 5 years to commence works at Langland Bay House, Langland Bay Road, Langland, Swansea. 2) The undermentioned planning applications BE REFUSED for the reasons indicated in the report and/or below: #(Item 1) Planning Application No.2014/0813 Two storey side (Northern elevation) extension, addition of pitched roof to existing detached outbuilding and associated landscaping at Llwynderw Lodge, 164 Mumbles Road, Blackpill, Swansea. Report updated as follows - Replace plan number: 1494_THB 402 Rev A Proposed South Elevation dated 28 July 2014 with 1494_402 Proposed South Elevation dated 5 June 2013. Application refused contrary to officer recommendation for the following reasons:- The proposed extension by virtue of its design would be out of keeping with the character and appearance of the existing dwelling and detrimental to the visual amenities of the area contrary to the provisions of Policy EV1 and HC7 of the City & County of Swansea Development Plan (2008) and the Design Guide for Householder Development (2008). #(Item 4) Planning Application No.2014/0876 Ground mounted solar array; capacity up to 1MW, ancillary infrastructure including access track, fencing, security cameras, inverter kiosks and substation building at Webbsfield, nr Brookvale, Ilston, Swansea. The Committee agreed to extend the speaking time for both objectors and applicants. Mr ap Gwent, [name removed], Rev Cox, [name removed], [name removed] & [name removed](objectors) and [name removed](applicant), [name removed] & [name removed](in support) addressed the Committee. Six further letters of support received. Letter from Swansea Airport Manager – withdrawal of objection; “After receiving consultation with the applicant for the proposed solar farm I wish to withdraw the objection submitted on the 10 July 2014. The general consensus within the flying schools and residents is that we now believe there is little or no threat to aircraft and pilots in the vicinity of the development.” Report updated as follows - Page 57 – Ilston Community Council – 3 rd line of second paragraph – replace : ‘nature aiplanes’ with “Nature of Plans”. Page 58 – 1 st paragraph – 15 th line – replace ‘I1ston’ with “Ilston” Page 77 – 1 st line – replace ‘top’ with “to” Page 85 – Condition 3 – replace condition 3 with amended condition “No development or other operations shall commence on site until a landscaping scheme for the site including the reinstatement of the temporary construction compounds, screening of the substation and details of the removal of all trees, and any arboricultural work required is submitted to and agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The landscaping scheme shall be carried out within 12 months from the completion of the development. Any trees or shrubs planted in accordance with this condition which are removed, die, become seriously diseased within five years of planting shall be replaced by trees or shrubs of similar size and to those originally species required to be planted.” Page 86 – Condition 11 - Replace condition 11 with amended condition “The design, location, period of use and orientation of any/all new lighting provision and details of all security fencing and CCTV installed as a consequence of the proposed development shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority before any lighting, fencing or CCTV is erected, and the scheme shall be implemented and retained in accordance with the approved details unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority” Page 86 - Additional condition “12. Prior to the commencement of development details of the proposed grid connections including from the solar array to the substation shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be completed in accordance with the approved details prior to the first use of the development hereby approved unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority. Reason : In the interests of the character and appearance of the Gower AONB.”