CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swansea Council
Scrutiny Programme Committee, Monday 14 August 2017 at 4.30pm

Pre-decision Scrutiny of Cabinet Reports.

Noted Scrutiny 1 paper

Scrutiny Programme Committee noted this item on Monday 14 August 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item22

Resolved

RESOLVED that: 1) The pre-decision scrutiny process and role of the Committee is noted; 2) The Committee considers the Cabinet reports and proposals (agenda items 8 & 9); 3) The Committee agree any views on the proposed decision that are to be raised with Cabinet.
Word for word from the decision Swansea published for this meeting. Source: democracy.swansea.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swansea's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Programme Committee

Report of the Chair

Scrutiny Programme Committee – 14 August 2017

PRE-DECISION SCRUTINY OF CABINET REPORTS

Purpose This report provides guidance on pre-decision scrutiny ahead of consideration of the Cabinet reports on:

a) All Council Catering Commissioning Review (agenda item 8) b) Planning & City Regeneration Commissioning Review (agenda item 9)

Content This covering report is focussed on the role of the Committee in undertaking pre-decision scrutiny.

The actual Cabinet reports which are being considered by Cabinet on 17 August are included in the agenda within items 8 and 9.

Councillors are  note the pre-decision scrutiny process and role of the being asked to Committee  consider the Cabinet reports and proposals (agenda items 8 & 9)  agree any views on the proposed decision that are to be raised with Cabinet

Lead Councillor Councillor Mary Jones, Chair of Scrutiny Programme Committee Lead Cabinet Tracey Meredith, Head of Legal, Democratic Services Member / and Business Intelligence Officer(s) Report Author Brij Madahar, Scrutiny Team Leader Telephone: 01792 637257 [email protected]

1. Introduction

1.1It has been agreed that all commissioning review final reports to Cabinet should undergo pre-decision scrutiny. The Scrutiny Programme Committee will carry out pre-decision scrutiny or delegate reports to be considered to relevant Scrutiny Panels.

1.2A decision on the following commissioning review final reports is being taken by Cabinet on 17 August:

 All Council Catering Commissioning Review (Report of the Cabinet Member for Service Transformation & Business Operations) This report concerns school meals, commercial catering & social services catering and outlines a range of options for future service delivery of catering and recommendations made to proceed with a preferred option.

 Planning & City Regeneration (Joint Report of the Cabinet Members for Culture, Tourism & Major Projects and Commercial Opportunities & Innovation)

This report will outline an options appraisal for the Planning & City Regeneration Service and recommendations on the most viable future service options for the service area.

2. Role of the Committee

2.1The purpose of pre-decision scrutiny:

 It entitles scrutiny to discuss proposed Cabinet reports, where a clear recommendation(s) exists, before decisions are taken by the Executive.

 Acting as a ‘critical friend’, it enables scrutiny to ask questions about a report to develop understanding and inform and influence decision-making, for example asking about: - the rationale for the report - robustness of the proposed decision and decision-making process - potential impact and implications (including policy/budget issues) and risks - how different options have been considered - the extent of consultation undertaken etc.

 It enables scrutiny to report its views and any issues to Cabinet. The chair, on behalf of the Committee, can attend the Cabinet meeting to share the views of scrutiny on the report prior to Cabinet decision. This may include giving support, providing other suggestions on the way forward, or flagging up any concerns.

 The views of scrutiny are required to be formally considered by Cabinet before it makes the decision and feedback should be given including explanation for any rejection of views expressed.

2.2Relevant Cabinet Members will attend the meeting to respond to questions and issues raised. Relevant officer(s) involved in the development of the report(s) will also be present to assist the Committee and provide appropriate advice. 2.3 The Committee (through the chair) will write to the relevant Cabinet Member with its views following pre-decision scrutiny. The chair will have the opportunity to attend the cabinet meeting on 17 August to verbally feedback the Committee’s views, conclusions and recommendations about the report(s).

3. Cabinet Response

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Pre-decision Scrutiny of Cabinet Reports.Decisions 69 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

18 of 26 attended
CA
Cyril AndersonCommittee Member, present
DA
David Anderson-ThomasCo-Optee, present
CB
Carl BillingsleyOfficer, absent
PB
Peter BlackCo-Optee, present
SC
Sybil CrouchCommittee Member, apologies
JC
Jan CurticeCommittee Member, present
CE
Ceri EvansCommittee Member, apologies
WF
Wendy FitzgeraldCommittee Member, present
LG
Louise GibbardCommittee Member, present
DH
David HelliwellCommittee Member, present
TH
Terry HenneganCommittee Member, present
CH
Chris Holley OBECommittee Member, present

All 26 on the meeting page

On this subject at Swansea

Search all
  1. Pre-decision Scrutiny of Cabinet Reports.This decision
  2. Pre-decision Scrutiny - Culture Strategy 2026-2031.Noted
  3. Pre Decision Scrutiny Feedback - Oracle Project Closure Process and Transition to New Operating Model. (Verbal)Noted
  4. Pre-Decision Scrutiny: National 20 Mph Default Speed Limit Including Consideration of the Exemptions Process.Decided
  5. Pre-Decision Scrutiny - Covid Recovery and Investment.Decided
  6. Pre-Decision Scrutiny: Proposed Lease to Mumbles Community Council under the Community Asset Transfer Policy.Decided

More from Swansea Scrutiny Programme Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
29 Jul 2026 Call In of Cabinet Decision - Proposed Sale of Swansea.com Stadium.Resolved that: 1) The sale of the Council’s freehold to Swansea City AFC be agreed subject to the detailed heads of t... Agreed Open
29 Jul 2026 Exclusion of the Public.Resolved that the public be excluded for the following item of business. (Closed Session) Decided Open
14 Jul 2026 Minutes.Resolved that the Minutes of the Scrutiny Programme Committees held on 14 April and 21 May 2026 be approved and signe... Approved Open
14 Jul 2026 Role of the Scrutiny Programme Committee.Resolved that: 1) The co-option of Scrutiny Performance Panels conveners to the Committee be renewed. Decided Open
14 Jul 2026 Scrutiny Programme Committee - Co-opted Member.Resolved that Councillor Peter May be appointed as a non-voting co-opted Member for the 2026-27 municipal year. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies