CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swansea Council
Cabinet, Thursday 17 August 2017 at 2.00pm

Pre Decision Scrutiny Feedback - All Council Catering - Commissioning Review.

Noted Executive 1 paper

Cabinet noted this item on Thursday 17 August 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item39

Resolved

RESOLVED that: 1) The presentation be noted.
Word for word from the decision Swansea published for this meeting. Source: democracy.swansea.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swansea's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

CITY AND COUNTY OF SWANSEA ———————————————————————————————————————————————

DINAS A SIR ABERTAWE To/ Please ask for: Scrutiny Gofynnwch am: Councillor Clive Lloyd Direct Line: Cabinet Member for Service Llinell Uniongyrochol: 01792 637257 Transformation & Business e-Mail [email protected] Operations e-Bost: Our Ref SPC/2017-18/1 Ein Cyf: Your Ref BY EMAIL Eich Cyf: Date 16 August 2017 Dyddiad:

Summary: This is a letter from the Scrutiny Programme Committee to the Cabinet Member for Service Transformation & Business Operations following the meeting of the Committee on 14 August 2017. It is about the Cabinet report on the All Council Catering Commissioning Review.

Dear Councillor Lloyd,

Pre-decision Scrutiny of Cabinet Report: All Council Catering Commissioning Review Gateway 2 Report

The Scrutiny Programme Committee met on 14 August to consider the report that you are presenting to Cabinet on 17 August, and give a view on the proposed decision.

We noted that your report concerned school meals, commercial and social services catering (including staff catering in the Civic Centre and Guildhall), and outlines a range of options for future service delivery. Your report recommended creating a single in-house managed catering function which will consolidate existing catering functions, and provides a Business Plan to take this forward, develop more commercial opportunities, and make services more efficient. We noted that there were some areas outside of the scope of the review for various reasons, namely the Mansion House, outdoor education centres, and the Cultural Services portfolio (e.g. leisure centres).

Thank you for meeting with the committee and for your engagement in the process, along with the lead officer, and answering questions. What follows is the view of the Committee, which we ask Cabinet to take into consideration before making its decision on the report.

OVERVIEW & SCRUTINY / TROSOLWG A CHRAFFU CITY AND COUNTY OF SWANSEA / DINAS A SIR ABERTAWE GUILDHALL, SWANSEA, SA1 4PE / NEUADD Y DDINAS, ABERTAWE, SA1 4PE www.swansea.gov.uk / www.abertawe.gov.uk In the short time available to consider the report the Committee broadly understood and had no objection to the proposals. However we had a number of observations for your attention:

• We recognised that there is a lot of work to be done to implement the business plan, which you state will take some time, and felt that this merited further scrutiny. We will consider how progress can be monitored by scrutiny, in order to keep abreast of developments, achievements, and assess impact.

• With regard to recommendation ‘e’, the committee was particularly interested in how you will develop the relationship with schools, recognising associated challenges and risks to plans given their autonomy with delegated budgets, which means they can seek alternative catering provisions.

• The committee felt that the integrated in-house service will need to clearly demonstrate that it is competitive, balancing value for money and quality of the offering, in order to win business from schools and other customers. We highlighted the need to take into account that staffing costs would potentially be higher with an in-house service given the Council’s wage commitments.

• We were also interested in knowing more about the internal controls (recommendation ‘g’) that are necessary to support the business model.

• Given that the sale of the Civic Centre is a significant part of city centre regeneration plans, and that the implementation of the business plan will take some time, we questioned the wisdom of investing in catering facilities at the Civic Centre at this time.

• We asked about the achievability of projected savings over the 3 year business plan, which appeared to be fairly ambitious (£338k in 2020/2021).

• The Committee would like to have seen more evidence in the report to support the rejection of outsourcing as the best way forward.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Pre Decision Scrutiny Feedback: All Council Catering: Commissioning Review.Decisions 40 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 25 attended
RS
Rob StewartChair, present
JB
June BurtonshawCommittee Member, present
MC
Mark ChildCommittee Member, present
WE
William EvansCommittee Member, apologies
RF
Robert Francis-DaviesCommittee Member, present
DH
David HopkinsCommittee Member, apologies
AL
Andrea LewisCommittee Member, present
CL
Clive LloydCommittee Member, present
JR
Jennifer RaynorCommittee Member, present
MT
Mark ThomasCommittee Member, present
CS
Chris SiversOfficer, in attendance
MN
Martin NichollsOfficer, expected

All 25 on the meeting page

On this subject at Swansea

Search all
  1. Pre Decision Scrutiny Feedback - All Council Catering - Commissioning Review.This decision
  2. Pre-decision Scrutiny - Culture Strategy 2026-2031.Noted
  3. Pre Decision Scrutiny Feedback - Oracle Project Closure Process and Transition to New Operating Model. (Verbal)Noted
  4. Pre-Decision Scrutiny: National 20 Mph Default Speed Limit Including Consideration of the Exemptions Process.Decided
  5. Pre-Decision Scrutiny - Covid Recovery and Investment.Decided
  6. Pre-Decision Scrutiny: Proposed Lease to Mumbles Community Council under the Community Asset Transfer Policy.Decided

More from Swansea Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
16 Sep 2026 Minutes.Resolved that the Minutes of the meeting(s) listed below be approved and signed as a correct record: 1) Cabinet held ... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Public Space Protection Order Scheme. *Resolved that: 1) The findings of the Public Spaces Protection Order Review be approved. 2) The introduction of a new... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Local Authority Governor Appointments.Resolved that: 1) The following nominations recommended by the Director of Education in conjunction with the Cabinet ... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Revenue and Capital Budget Monitoring 1st Quarter 2026/27.Resolved that: 1) The comments and variations, including the heightened material uncertainties, set out in the report... Noted Open
16 Sep 2026 Quarter 1 2026/27 Performance Monitoring Report.Resolved that: 1) The Council’s performance in delivering its well-being objectives during Quarter 1 of 2026/27 be no... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies