Resolved – (1) That a public consultation exercise be held in respect to the adoption of legislation for the licensing of sex shops. (2) That, further to (1) above, officers be instructed to prepare a report to this Committee setting out proposals for the consultation, including (a) how consultations will be carried out, (b) the processes involved, (c) information to be included within the consultation process and (d) and list of consultees.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
2.1That Members confirm that they would not wish the Council to adopt the legal framework for licensing sex shops at this time.
Financial implications
3.1If the legislation is not adopted there will be no direct financial implications.
3.2If a licensing system is adopted, officers will prepare a further report, recommending an appropriate fee structure, to cover the additional costs to the Council.
3.3Any preparatory work, up to the making of a resolution and the advertising of that resolution cannot be reclaimed from fees. The cost of a comprehensive consultation exercise is estimated at £700 and the additional cost of the obligatory press advertisements would be approximately £750. These costs are not recoverable and would have to be absorbed from existing budgets.
4 Social, Environmental, Staffing and Legal/Human Rights Implications
4.1Social implications. The system of licensing provided by the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1982 was intended to protect children from harm, to discourage the activities of organised crime, to prevent offence to members of the public through indecent displays and to limit the number and location of sex establishments. It has limited effectiveness in achieving some of these aims but offers almost nothing on the last of these points. 4.2 Environmental implications. There are no direct environmental implications but a decision to adopt the legislation could do considerable damage to prospects to revitalise the town centre.
4.3Staffing implications. There are no immediate staffing implications. Should a licensing system be introduced, there would be an additional burden on the Licensing team, unless relieved by additional staff resources. Additional staffing would be essential in the short term, to cope with applications. The trades unions have not been consulted.
4.4Legal / Human Rights implications. The restrictions on the circumstances in which sex establishments are allowed to trade are determined by the public interest. In contemporary society, there is a general acceptance that people should be free to purchase sexually explicit items if they wish, provided that they cause no harm to others, do not corrupt children and do not give gratuitous offence. As with many aspects of human rights, there is a balance to be struck, between the rights of the individual (which includes the rights of businesses) and the need to protect the vulnerable.
4.5All other risk implications. Since this is adoptive legislation, it is hard to see how the exercise of that discretion in either direction would be open to challenge. Loss of livelihood is a possible and legitimate outcome of licensing so no liability attaches to it. A successful appeal against any refusal to grant a licence, should the legislation be adopted, would leave the Council liable for both its costs and those of the other party. An indirect effect of adopting now could be that work on drinks licensing and gaming law would be undermined, leading to costly errors and omissions. Not adopting the legislation entails no obvious risk whereas adopting it brings in tangible and potentially substantial risks.
4.6Links to corporate plan. The report has some, albeit limited, association with the community safety and economic prosperity aspects of the Corporate Plan.
5 Detail
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Appointment of Sub-Committees and PanelsResolved – (1) That an Ad Hoc Licensing Sub-Committee be appointed, having the functions as set out in the ‘Swindon B...
Review of Statement of Licensing PolicyResolved – That Council be recommended to adopt the revised Statement of Licensing Policy, as set out in Appendix 1 t...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.