Resolved
Resolved - That, having listened to and carefully considered all of the evidence and submissions put forward by the police, and the legal representative and the management of the Bell Hotel, Old Town, the Panel has reached the following conclusions: The Police have provided compelling evidence of a history of breaches of the Licensing Objectives, including, the protection of children from harm and there was evidence of sales of alcohol to underage persons and poor management relating to the premises. Having considered the evidence given on behalf of the management of the Bell Hotel, including an admission that sales of alcohol to minors occurred 19 th March 2011 by both the Designated Premises Supervisor and a member of staff on separate occasions, the Panel was not satisfied that any compelling evidence was put forward that breaches of the licensing objectives would not continue as a result of serious and systematic failures in the management of the premises. The Panel, conscious of its duty to ensure that the licensing objectives are met, have decided that the appropriate decision is to remove [name removed] as Designated Premises Supervisor with immediate effect. Reasons 1. The Panel noted that following the review of the Premises Licence on 12 th November 2010 the management of the Bell Hotel had failed to properly implement the recommendations of that Panel resulting in additional underage sales. 2. That despite being told by an underage test purchaser that they had no proof of age identification the Designated Premises Supervisor proceeded to serve the underage tester an alcoholic beverage. 3. The Panel was not satisfied with the management’s explanation of training methods. It heard evidence from the Police that a member of staff caught selling alcohol had confirmed she had not received training in the six months that she had worked at the bar. Records for refusals were recorded on an ad-hoc basis in a diary. The Panel determined that [name removed] was either unwilling or incapable of fulfilling his responsibility to train staff. 4. The Panel was conscious of its responsibility to secure compliance with the Protection of Children Licensing Objective and heard no compelling evidence to suggest [name removed] would be capable ... view the full minutes text for item 3.