CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swindon Borough Council
Licensing Panel, Friday 27 May 2011

Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, Swindon

Noted Licensing 4 papers

Licensing Panel noted this item on Friday 27 May 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item3

Resolved

Resolved - That, having listened to and carefully considered all of the evidence and submissions put forward by the police, and the legal representative and the management of the Bell Hotel, Old Town, the Panel has reached the following conclusions: The Police have provided compelling evidence of a history of breaches of the Licensing Objectives, including, the protection of children from harm and there was evidence of sales of alcohol to underage persons and poor management relating to the premises. Having considered the evidence given on behalf of the management of the Bell Hotel, including an admission that sales of alcohol to minors occurred 19 th March 2011 by both the Designated Premises Supervisor and a member of staff on separate occasions, the Panel was not satisfied that any compelling evidence was put forward that breaches of the licensing objectives would not continue as a result of serious and systematic failures in the management of the premises. The Panel, conscious of its duty to ensure that the licensing objectives are met, have decided that the appropriate decision is to remove [name removed] as Designated Premises Supervisor with immediate effect. Reasons 1. The Panel noted that following the review of the Premises Licence on 12 th November 2010 the management of the Bell Hotel had failed to properly implement the recommendations of that Panel resulting in additional underage sales. 2. That despite being told by an underage test purchaser that they had no proof of age identification the Designated Premises Supervisor proceeded to serve the underage tester an alcoholic beverage. 3. The Panel was not satisfied with the management’s explanation of training methods. It heard evidence from the Police that a member of staff caught selling alcohol had confirmed she had not received training in the six months that she had worked at the bar. Records for refusals were recorded on an ad-hoc basis in a diary. The Panel determined that [name removed] was either unwilling or incapable of fulfilling his responsibility to train staff. 4. The Panel was conscious of its responsibility to secure compliance with the Protection of Children Licensing Objective and heard no compelling evidence to suggest [name removed] would be capable ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting. Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swindon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Licensing Panel, 4 pages

Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, Swindon Licensing Panel Date:11 May 2011

Author: Head of Licensing Wards Affected: Old Town and Lawns

Purpose • To review the premises licence held by Steven Brownell for the Bell Hotel, High Street, following an application by the Police.

Recommendation Licensing Committee is asked : - • In the light of the application, to determine any action that is necessary, having regard to the extensive remedial powers available.

1. Reasons 1.1 The Licensing Panel has a statutory duty to undertake the functions of the Licensing Authority, where these have been delegated by the Licensing Committee.

2. Detail 2.1 In the course of routine tests of the effectiveness of management arrangements to prevent the sale of alcohol to customers under the age of 18, volunteers acting on behalf of the Police were able to purchase alcohol from the premises.

2.2This is not the first occasion on which such shortcomings have been found and the premises licence has already been reviewed, in November 2010. That review also involved failed test purchases. Under-aged volunteers were able to enter the premises without hindrance and purchase alcohol on 27 February 2010 and again on 6 August 2010. On the first occasion the volunteers were aged 15 and 17. On the second occasion, the volunteers were aged 14 and 16.

2.3The decision of the last review hearing is shown at Appendix One. The decision has had no practical effect as yet, as the matter is still the subject of an appeal.

2.4The basis of this new review is as shown on the application, attached as Appendix Two.

Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Lionel Starling on 01793 466118 or e-mail [email protected]. Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, Swindon Licensing Panel Date:11 May 2011 2.5 The Police have not suggested any particular remedy to the hearing. When proposals are put forward by responsible authorities have they indicative status only and do not bind the panel in any way.

2.6Test purchases involving volunteers were only introduced by the Police in 2010 and the Bell Hotel was notified in advance along with other members of Pubwatch that test operations of this kind would be taking place. The failure of the venue to attend Pubwatch will have meant that they missed out on some of the discussion about test purchases but they were also given written notification.

2.7The most recent test purchase took place on Saturday 19 March 2011 at 22:35hrs. On this occasion both volunteers were aged 15.

2.8A significant feature of the most recent failure is that one of the illegal sales was made by [name removed] the premises licence holder and designated premises supervisor. He was sufficiently doubtful to ask for proof of age from the volunteer but still went through with the sale, after establishing that the volunteer was not able to provide any proof of age.

2.9A witness statement from Special PC Martyn Ainsworth is presented at Appendix Three, in support of the application.

2.1023 different bars and pubs were tested on that evening but The Bell was the only one to fail.

2.11The Police say that they checked training records and found that the member of bar staff who served the second volunteer had received no documented training and that there was no entry for her in the training records, despite the fact that she had been working there for around six months.

2.12It is in order to determine the application, even though the appeal on the first review decision is still waiting to be heard.

2.13There is no renewal procedure for premises licences, which therefore continue indefinitely under normal circumstances. To compensate for this, review procedures are available. There are safeguards against vexatious or repetitive reviews.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendix 1Appendix 1 3 pages Download
PDF
Appendix 2Appendix 2 7 pages Download
PDF
Appendix 3Appendix 3 2 pages Download
PDF
Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, SwindonReport 4 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
1Appointment of ChairDecided
3Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, SwindonThis decision

Who was there

3 of 3 attended
AB
Councillor Andrew BennettMember, present
RH
Councillor Richard HurleyMember, present
SW
Councillor Steve WakefieldMember, present

On this subject at Swindon

Search all
  1. Application to review the premises licence for the Bell Hotel, High Street, SwindonThis decision
  2. Application to Review Premises Licence in respect of Baileys News Agent, 2 Cheney Manor Road, Swindon, SN2 2NSDecided
  3. Application for a review of the Premises Licence in respect of Simply Fresh Retail Limited (Premier Local), 160 Cricklade Road, Swindon, SN2 8AGNoted
  4. Application to Review a Premises Licence in respect of Abbys, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, SN1 2AFDeferred
  5. Application to Review the Premises Licence held by Longs Bar, Victoria Road, SwindonNoted
  6. Application to Review the Premises Licence of the Nine Elms Public House, Old Shaw Lane, SwindonNoted

More from Swindon Licensing Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Jul 2026 Appointment of ChairThat Councillor Manro be elected as Chair for the Panel for the current meeting. Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the previous meeting of the Panel held on 30 September 2024 be confirmed as a true record and sig... Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 Determination of a Full Variation of a Premises Licence application at 4 Victoria Road, Old Town, Swindon, SN1 3AJResolved : That the variation to the premises licence to be an off-licence be granted but with the operating hours li... Decided Open
29 Feb 2024 Appointment of ChairResolved - Councillor Junab Ali Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ali took the Chair.) Decided Open
28 Jul 2023 Appointment of ChairResolved – That Councillor John Ballman Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ballman took the Chair.) Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies