Resolved – (1) That the head of Licensing be authorised to prepare a formal response to the consultation paper on the deregulation of Schedule One of the Licensing Act 2003 based upon his proposed response and Members’ comments expressed at this meeting. (2) That the Head of Licensing be authorised to prepare a covering letter setting out the key issues raise by Members on the effect of the proposed amendments to the Licensing Act 2003, including the adverse affect any such proposals will have on the localism agenda. (3) That the Chair and Vice-Chair be authorised to approve the Head of licensing’s formal response on the deregulation of Schedule One of the Licensing Act 2003. (4) That a copy of the cover letter and formal response to the consultation paper on the deregulation of Schedule One of the Licensing Act 2003 be forwarded to all Members of this Committee, Swindon’s Members of parliament and partner organisations for their information.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
Q1. In the commercial arena, businesses already have licences so there would be little effect. It is unlikely that there would be significantly more events held under a revised regime, as trhey nearly all entail the sale of alcohol. Removing the need for temporary event notices altogether for low risk activities would provide a small financial benefit to community organisations. The primary block to community activity is fear of the various copyright agencies. Reform of the Licensing Act will have no effect unless that is addressed.
Q2.
Q3. The cost of obtaining and maintaining an authorisation for alcohol and entertainment is the same as that for an authorisation for alcohol only, so most of the alleged savings to business are illusory. The cost of defending actions in the courts will hugely increase costs for the businesses concerned. The formal enforcement route advocated would place substantial cost pressures on local authorities, the Police and the courts.
Q4. The proposals would lead to a sharp increase in enforcement costs. Licensing hearings are cheap to run and quickly concluded. Specialist legal services are rarely necessary. Litigation is protracted and legal costs can quickly become prohibitive. The proposals would be very expensive indeed. Cost savings are an illusion.
Q5. Enforcement through the courts is slow, happens after the event and does not engage residents. The proposals would boost the number of noise complaints dramatically, by undermining public confidence and delaying remedy.
Q6. The belief that the changes would have any significant impact on numbers of events is unfounded, so the assumptions made are unsafe, for the reasons stated above. The ‘per annum’ comment in relation to community premises which do not attract a fee is somewhat misleading, as on an ‘annual’ basis they entail no work at all.
Q7.
Q8. The much higher cost of litigation versus administrative control has not been accounted for.
Q9.
Q10. The meaning of the question is unclear.
Q11 and Q12. Events at 10,000 attendance and above are mostly organised by reputable, experienced operators. The biggest risk area is in the band between 1000 and 5000 because those attract amateur organisers. The cut-off point should be 500, in line with the temporary event notice rules.
Q13. There is a strong argument for taking the demographic into account. Events which attract whole families have a built in authority structure at a micro level so they are more stable and pose less risk. That is not about size of event as such.
Q14. Only a handful of premises would fall between the continuing need for an alcohol licence and a reliance on temporary event notices rather than a licence. Locally, they could be counted on the fingers of one hand but they pose low risk. Terraced pubs and some 1970’s estate pubs would take advantage of relaxation to provide live music, karaoke and discos so there would be surge of noise complaints.
Q15. The cut-off point for events outdoors should be 999, with the 499 indoor limit left as it is. In a field, the physical risks are of a much lower order and moving to a place of safety is a simple matter.
Q16. Most authorities recognise that 23:00hrs is a critical time in terms of noise impact on households. Live music and karaoke is less controllable and can have an intrusive character (screeching voices, poor tuning, bass penetration etc.) so the cut-off should be 10:00hrs.
Q17. Noise tolerance is related to community engagement and frequency. It is not absolute. Different rules are needed for one event per year and six events a year. Different rules are need for the local carnival and an invasion of bikers.
Q18. The existing regime works well in most cases.
Q19. A code of practice would be followed by good operators and ignored by bad. It would achieve nothing whatever.
Q20. This operates on a false premise. Licensing is an efficient, responsive and preventative mechanism. Prosecution is slow, expensive and remote.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Appointment of Sub-Committees and PanelsResolved – (1) That an Ad Hoc Licensing Sub-Committee be appointed, having the functions as set out in the ‘Swindon B...
Review of Statement of Licensing PolicyResolved – That Council be recommended to adopt the revised Statement of Licensing Policy, as set out in Appendix 1 t...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.