CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swindon Borough Council
Licensing Panel, Friday 27 January 2012

Application to Review Premises Licence - Tatras, 184 Victoria Road, Swindon

Noted Licensing 3 papers

Licensing Panel noted this item on Friday 27 January 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item75

Resolved

Resolved – The Panel carefully considered all of the evidence and submissions put forward by Trading Standards Officers and the management and representative of Tatras , 184 Victoria Road, Swindon and reached the following conclusions: Trading Standards had provided compelling evidence of breaches of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective. There was evidence of the sale of illegal tobacco and poor management practices relating to the business. Having considered the evidence given by the management of Tatras the Panel was not satisfied that any compelling evidence was put forward that breaches of the Licensing Objectives would not continue. The Panel, conscious of its duty to ensure that the Licensing Objectives are met, and having considered the evidence before it, the Licensing Act 2003, the Secretary of State’s Guidance and the Council’s Licensing Policy determined that the appropriate decision was to revoke the Premises Licence. Reasons for Decision 1. The Panel was satisfied that there were serious and consistent breaches of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective. 2. The Panel was satisfied that, due to the serious nature of the breaches of the Licensing Objectives, that this would not be addressed through the imposition of additional conditions on the Premises Licence. 3. The Panel was satisfied that [name removed] fully understood that he was breaching the Licensing Objectives, as evidenced by his admissions to the Panel that he understood the law relating to the sale of tobacco when he signed the Trading Standards Visit Acknowledgement form on 29 th June 2011. 4. The Panel determined that there was a deliberate attempt to breach the Licensing objectives through the sale of non-duty paid tobacco as evidenced by such tobacco being hidden n the premises and his failure to co-operate with Trading Standards Officers. The also noted that legitimate tobacco products were being sold on the premises. 5. The Panel felt that as a result of the poor management of the premises relating to the sale on non-duty paid tobacco and failure to keep acceptable financial records that [name removed] was failing to meet the standards required to uphold the Licensing Objectives. 6. The Panel found that [name removed] and [name removed] were not credible witnesses as demonstrated by contradictory evidence presented to the Panel. The Chair reminded both parties that they had the right of appeal against this decision to the Magistrates Court and that any such appeal should be made within 21days ... view the full minutes text for item 75.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting. Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swindon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Licensing Panel

Report following an application to review the premises licence for Tatras, 184 Victoria Road Licensing Panel Date:27 January 2012

Author: Head of Licensing Wards Affected: Eastcott

Purpose • To review the premises licence by Shorish Hamid Mustafa for Tatras, 184 Victoria Road, following an application by Trading Standards.

Recommendation Licensing Committee is asked : - • In the light of the application, to determine any action that is necessary, having regard to the extensive remedial powers available.

1. Reasons 1.1 The Licensing Panel has a statutory duty to undertake the functions of the Licensing Authority, where these have been delegated by the Licensing Committee.

2. Detail

2.1The review application is attached as Appendix One.

2.2The application has not been joined by any other party.

2.3The review is brought under the crime and disorder licensing objective.

2.4It is reported that on 11 September 2011 and again on 18 September 2011 and 25 September 2011, Trading Standards were able to obtain evidence that foreign-labelled non duty-paid tobacco was sold and that the goods in question were not on open display.

2.5On 2 October 2011 with the premises licence holder present, Trading Standards entered the premises and seized a significant quantity of foreign labelled, non duty-paid [and in some cases counterfeit] cigarettes and loose tobacco. The products were not stored in the cigarette gantry but were hidden amongst shelving or were stored within a hidden cupboard. In addition to the tobacco, cash totalling around £1500 which was found in a paper bag under the counter was seized.

Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Lionel Starling on 01793 466118 or e-mail [email protected]. Report following an application to review the premises licence for Tatras, 184 Victoria Road Licensing Panel Date:27 January 2012 2.6 The premises licence holder, [name removed], is said to have lied under caution both at the time of the goods seizure and subsequently at interview.

2.7Officers say that they found irregularities in respect of accounts detailing income and the employment of staff.

2.8The detailed evidence provided by Trading Standards is set out in Appendix One.

2.9The evidence is not about the sale of alcohol but evidence of the illicit sale of tobacco has indirect relevance in terms of the light it might shed on the sale of age restricted products in general but also has direct relevance, in that the sale of contraband goods is a licensing matter.

2.10The Statutory Guidance issued under section 182 Licensing Act 2003 provides detailed advice where it is held that premises are being used for a criminal purpose. That will not be the case simply because there is evidence that offences have been committed. A judgement that premises are being used ‘to further crimes’ might be indicated by such considerations as the scale of unlawful activity, evidence of deliberate concealment, attempts to avoid detection or to mislead investigators and evidence of any active steps which have been taken by the premises licence holder to seek out illicit goods [as opposed to passively responding to an offer of illicit goods].

2.11On the face of it, all of those features are present here.

2.12The Guidance says “There is certain criminal activity that may arise in connection with licensed premises, which the Secretary of State considers should be treated particularly seriously. These are the use of the licensed premises …. [list follows] …. and for the sale of smuggled tobacco and alcohol.”

2.13The Guidance continues “Where reviews arise and the licensing authority determines that the crime prevention objective is being undermined through the premises being used to further crimes, it is expected that revocation of the licence – even in the first instance – should be seriously considered”.

2.14If it is deemed that those parts of the Guidance are relevant, the onus is on the panel to put the safety of the community first, before the commercial interest of the trader.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendix 1Appendix 1 381 KB Download
PDF
Appendix 2Appendix 2 70 KB Download
PDF
Application to Review Premises Licence: Tatras, 184 Victoria Road, SwindonReport 47 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
73Appointment of ChairDecided
75Application to Review Premises Licence - Tatras, 184 Victoria Road, SwindonThis decision

On this subject at Swindon

Search all
  1. Application to Review Premises Licence - Tatras, 184 Victoria Road, SwindonThis decision
  2. Application to Review Premises Licence in respect of Baileys News Agent, 2 Cheney Manor Road, Swindon, SN2 2NSDecided
  3. Application for a review of the Premises Licence in respect of Simply Fresh Retail Limited (Premier Local), 160 Cricklade Road, Swindon, SN2 8AGNoted
  4. Application to Review a Premises Licence in respect of Abbys, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, SN1 2AFDeferred
  5. Application to Review the Premises Licence held by Longs Bar, Victoria Road, SwindonNoted
  6. Application to Review the Premises Licence of the Nine Elms Public House, Old Shaw Lane, SwindonNoted

More from Swindon Licensing Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Jul 2026 Appointment of ChairThat Councillor Manro be elected as Chair for the Panel for the current meeting. Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the previous meeting of the Panel held on 30 September 2024 be confirmed as a true record and sig... Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 Determination of a Full Variation of a Premises Licence application at 4 Victoria Road, Old Town, Swindon, SN1 3AJResolved : That the variation to the premises licence to be an off-licence be granted but with the operating hours li... Decided Open
29 Feb 2024 Appointment of ChairResolved - Councillor Junab Ali Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ali took the Chair.) Decided Open
28 Jul 2023 Appointment of ChairResolved – That Councillor John Ballman Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ballman took the Chair.) Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies