Resolved
Resolved – The Panel carefully considered all of the evidence and submissions put forward by Trading Standards Officers and the management and representative of Tatras , 184 Victoria Road, Swindon and reached the following conclusions: Trading Standards had provided compelling evidence of breaches of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective. There was evidence of the sale of illegal tobacco and poor management practices relating to the business. Having considered the evidence given by the management of Tatras the Panel was not satisfied that any compelling evidence was put forward that breaches of the Licensing Objectives would not continue. The Panel, conscious of its duty to ensure that the Licensing Objectives are met, and having considered the evidence before it, the Licensing Act 2003, the Secretary of State’s Guidance and the Council’s Licensing Policy determined that the appropriate decision was to revoke the Premises Licence. Reasons for Decision 1. The Panel was satisfied that there were serious and consistent breaches of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective. 2. The Panel was satisfied that, due to the serious nature of the breaches of the Licensing Objectives, that this would not be addressed through the imposition of additional conditions on the Premises Licence. 3. The Panel was satisfied that [name removed] fully understood that he was breaching the Licensing Objectives, as evidenced by his admissions to the Panel that he understood the law relating to the sale of tobacco when he signed the Trading Standards Visit Acknowledgement form on 29 th June 2011. 4. The Panel determined that there was a deliberate attempt to breach the Licensing objectives through the sale of non-duty paid tobacco as evidenced by such tobacco being hidden n the premises and his failure to co-operate with Trading Standards Officers. The also noted that legitimate tobacco products were being sold on the premises. 5. The Panel felt that as a result of the poor management of the premises relating to the sale on non-duty paid tobacco and failure to keep acceptable financial records that [name removed] was failing to meet the standards required to uphold the Licensing Objectives. 6. The Panel found that [name removed] and [name removed] were not credible witnesses as demonstrated by contradictory evidence presented to the Panel. The Chair reminded both parties that they had the right of appeal against this decision to the Magistrates Court and that any such appeal should be made within 21days ... view the full minutes text for item 75.