Resolved
Resolved - The Panel having seriously considered the evidence before it from Trading Standards Officers and evidence from the solicitor and management of Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, carefully considered the revocation of the Premises Licence held by the premises on the grounds that, in their opinion the management had breached the Licensing Objectives, had provided officers and the Panel with inconsistent and contradictory evidence, had by their own admission failed to operate due diligence when they became aware that counterfeit alcohol was being sold and had misled and obstructed subsequent officers’ investigations. Having considered the evidence and representations before it, and the seriousness this Panel places on the sale of counterfeit alcohol the Panel determined that: (1) That [name removed] be removed as the Designated Premises Supervisor for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon with immediate effect. Reasons (a) That the Panel determined that there had been a breach of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective and that the management of Abby’s had undermined that Licensing Objective when failing to report when counterfeit Alcohol was found by them on the premises. (b) That the Management of Abby’s had deliberately misled officers as to the source of the counterfeit alcohol and persistently provided contradictory evidence and evidence that was not credible to officers and the Panel. In the Panel’s view such mismanagement and culture could only be addressed through the removal of the current Designated Premises Supervisor who was responsible for current management failings. (2) That the Premises Licence held by Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon be suspended for a period of 8 weeks. Reasons The Panel, having seriously considered revocation of the Premises Licence determined that the current management of Abby’s had shown multiple failings in (i) purchasing and selling counterfeit alcohol and (ii) failure to engage appropriate authorities, and (iii) in providing evidence to officers and the Panel that was neither consistent nor credible. The Panel further determined that the culture of the current organisation needed a radical overhaul through training and the replacement of the Designated Premises Supervisor in order to operate to a standard required to secure compliance with the crime and disorder-licensing objective and to ensure that there are no further breaches of the Licensing Objectives. (3) That the premises licence held by Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, be amended as set out below: (i) That any replacement Designated Premises Supervisor appointed shall undertake appropriate training to enable him/her to undertake his/her management duties, ... view the full minutes text for item 81.