CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swindon Borough Council
Licensing Panel, Friday 10 February 2012

Review of Premises Licence for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon

Decided Licensing 3 papers

Licensing Panel decided this item on Friday 10 February 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item81

Resolved

Resolved - The Panel having seriously considered the evidence before it from Trading Standards Officers and evidence from the solicitor and management of Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, carefully considered the revocation of the Premises Licence held by the premises on the grounds that, in their opinion the management had breached the Licensing Objectives, had provided officers and the Panel with inconsistent and contradictory evidence, had by their own admission failed to operate due diligence when they became aware that counterfeit alcohol was being sold and had misled and obstructed subsequent officers’ investigations. Having considered the evidence and representations before it, and the seriousness this Panel places on the sale of counterfeit alcohol the Panel determined that: (1) That [name removed] be removed as the Designated Premises Supervisor for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon with immediate effect. Reasons (a) That the Panel determined that there had been a breach of the Crime and Disorder Licensing Objective and that the management of Abby’s had undermined that Licensing Objective when failing to report when counterfeit Alcohol was found by them on the premises. (b) That the Management of Abby’s had deliberately misled officers as to the source of the counterfeit alcohol and persistently provided contradictory evidence and evidence that was not credible to officers and the Panel. In the Panel’s view such mismanagement and culture could only be addressed through the removal of the current Designated Premises Supervisor who was responsible for current management failings. (2) That the Premises Licence held by Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon be suspended for a period of 8 weeks. Reasons The Panel, having seriously considered revocation of the Premises Licence determined that the current management of Abby’s had shown multiple failings in (i) purchasing and selling counterfeit alcohol and (ii) failure to engage appropriate authorities, and (iii) in providing evidence to officers and the Panel that was neither consistent nor credible. The Panel further determined that the culture of the current organisation needed a radical overhaul through training and the replacement of the Designated Premises Supervisor in order to operate to a standard required to secure compliance with the crime and disorder-licensing objective and to ensure that there are no further breaches of the Licensing Objectives. (3) That the premises licence held by Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, be amended as set out below: (i) That any replacement Designated Premises Supervisor appointed shall undertake appropriate training to enable him/her to undertake his/her management duties, ... view the full minutes text for item 81.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting. Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swindon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Licensing Panel

Recommendation

Licensing Committee is asked : -

In the light of the application, to determine any action that is necessary, having regard to the extensive remedial powers available.

1. Reasons

1.1The Licensing Panel has a statutory duty to undertake the functions of the Licensing Authority, where these have been delegated by the Licensing Committee.

2. Detail

2.1The review application has been brought by Trading Standards, following the sale of a fake product.

2.2On 25 March 2011 a representative of pernod Ricard found fake ‘Jacob’s Creek’ Pinot Grigio and Semillon Sauvignon Blanc on sale.

2.3On 31 March 2011 an Environmental Health Officer carried out a test purchase of suspected counterfeit ‘Jacobs Creek’ Pinot Grigio. It was subsequently confirmed as a counterfeit item by the trademark holder.

2.4On 5 April 2011, a Trading Standards Officer visited the shop again and found no counterfeit wine on display but a gap where the fake ‘Jacob’s Creek’ had been.

2.5The proprietor subsequently claimed that he only buys stock from Batleys. A CCTV system is in place but when interviewed the owner said it does not work. It

Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Lionel Starling on 01793 466118 or e-mail [email protected]. Report following an application to review the premises licence for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road Licensing Panel Date:10 February 2012 appeared to be recording but the owner said he did not know how the system works and does not have a password for access.

2.6Trading Standards have made recommendations that some conditions be applied to the licence, irrespective of any other sanctions.

2.7The conditions proposed by Trading Standards include a requirement that a suitable CCTV system be installed, covering the sales area and capable of providing data to authorised officers on request.

2.8Trading Standards wish to see a condition that invoices and receipts in relation to alcohol premises should be retained on the premises for a period of six months from issue and that they should be shown to authorised officers on request. The intent of this is to deter further purchases from illegal undertakings.

2.9They also propose that a condition be applied to ensure that staff are properly trained and that they receive refresher training, with properly kept associated records.

2.10A full account of these matters can be found in the review application, which is attached as Appendix One.

2.11Nothing in detail is known about the contents of the bottles but it is known that complaints were first raised with the brand owner about the taste. The inference is that the contents did not actually cause harm to anyone. Nevertheless, in buying stock from a suspect source, the retailer took a chance on selling something that might have been dangerous, in order to achieve a higher mark up.

2.12With any review, it is open to interested parties and responsible authorities to make representations. These must be within the four licensing objectives but they are not limited by the grounds of the original review.

2.13No further representations have been made in this case.

2.14The Trading Standards review is under the prevention of crime and disorder objective.

2.15A copy of the existing licence is shown at Appendix Two.

2.16This hearing is not an examination into guilt or innocence in relation to alleged criminal offences. It is an exploration into matters which may impact on the licensing objectives and a determination of measures, if any, required to further those licensing objectives.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendix 1Appendix 1 185 KB Download
PDF
Appendix 2Appendix 2 102 KB Download
PDF
Review of Premises Licence for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, SwindonReport 298 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
79Appointment of ChairDecided
81Review of Premises Licence for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, SwindonThis decision

On this subject at Swindon

Search all
  1. Review of Premises Licence for Abby’s, 147 Manchester Road, SwindonThis decision
  2. Internal Audit Review - Premises ManagementNoted
  3. Application to Review Premises Licence in respect of Baileys News Agent, 2 Cheney Manor Road, Swindon, SN2 2NSDecided
  4. Application for a review of the Premises Licence in respect of Simply Fresh Retail Limited (Premier Local), 160 Cricklade Road, Swindon, SN2 8AGNoted
  5. Application to Review a Premises Licence in respect of Abbys, 147 Manchester Road, Swindon, SN1 2AFDeferred
  6. Application to Review the Premises Licence held by Longs Bar, Victoria Road, SwindonNoted

More from Swindon Licensing Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Jul 2026 Appointment of ChairThat Councillor Manro be elected as Chair for the Panel for the current meeting. Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the previous meeting of the Panel held on 30 September 2024 be confirmed as a true record and sig... Decided Open
1 Jul 2026 Determination of a Full Variation of a Premises Licence application at 4 Victoria Road, Old Town, Swindon, SN1 3AJResolved : That the variation to the premises licence to be an off-licence be granted but with the operating hours li... Decided Open
29 Feb 2024 Appointment of ChairResolved - Councillor Junab Ali Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ali took the Chair.) Decided Open
28 Jul 2023 Appointment of ChairResolved – That Councillor John Ballman Chair this meeting of the Panel. (Councillor Ballman took the Chair.) Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies