Resolved – (1) That the Ethical Framework update be noted. (2) That the Director of Law and Democratic Services report to the next meeting on the issue of possible guidance for members in relation to invitations to comment on instances of school openings or closures. (3) That the indication from the Committee on Standards in Public Life, of its intention to undertake a review in 2014/15 of the standards regime under the Localism Act arrangements, be noted and that the Director of Law and Democratic Services provide updates as necessary following any such review. (4) That it be noted that no dispensations had been granted by the Monitoring Officer since the last meeting. (5) That the adoption of the Independent Persons Protocol, appended to the report, be further considered after the Independent Persons have met with the Director of Law and Democratic Services to review the draft protocol and to discuss related issues, including the adoption of the code by other authorities and the role of the Hoey Ainscough Associates Ltd. (6) That it be noted that revised nominations were awaited from the Swindon Area Committee of the Wiltshire Association of Local Councils in respect of the two Parish Council vacancies on the Committee. (7) That the issues reported in relation to member and Parish Councillor training be noted.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
Local Government Lawyer - Probity watchdog attacks Localism Act standards regime Friday, 18 January 2013 17:34 Appendix 2
The Committee for Standards in Public Life has placed the post-Localism Act local government standards regime on a 'watching brief' saying the lack of available sanctions and independent scrutiny risked damaging public confidence in the probity of local government.
In its review of best practice in the public sector, Standards Matter, the committee said that while it supported the principle of devolved responsibility for standards, the absence of these features meant that some local authorities were at risk of failing to bring their members to account. It said that it would keep an eye on developments and investigate the effectiveness of the regime if that became necessary.
The committee's report highlighted authorities with a single dominant political party in control and rural authorities with a high proportion of independent members as being at the highest risk of member misbehaviour.
The report said: “Prime responsibility for maintaining high standards of behaviour must always lie with individuals and organisations, not with external regulation. We welcome therefore the intention behind the Localism Act 2011 to encourage a greater sense of local responsibility for standards and to address some of the more vexatious and disproportionate aspects of the local government standards regime.
“[However] we have other concerns about the new arrangements which apply even in those authorities where strong leadership on standards does exist. The first is that under the previous arrangements local authorities had the power to suspend members for varying periods of time as a sanction against poor behaviour.
“The only sanctions now available, apart from through the use of party discipline, are censure or criminal prosecution for deliberately withholding or misrepresenting a financial interest. We do not think these are sufficient. The last few years have seen a number of examples of inappropriate behaviour which would not pass the strict tests required to warrant a criminal prosecution, but which deserves a sanction stronger than simple censure. Bullying of other members or officers is one category of offence which will be difficult to deal with adequately under the new arrangements. “
1/3 Local Government Lawyer - Probity watchdog attacks Localism Act standards regime Friday, 18 January 2013 17:34 Appendix 2
The report expressed concern that the provisions for external involvement in the member disciplinary process. Prior to the Localism Act, standards committees were independently chaired by individuals who were not themselves members of the local authority. Since the Localism Act came into force, local authorities are now inly required to appoint at least one independent person whose views it will seek, and take into account, before making its decision on an allegation that it has decided to investigate.
“We doubt that this will be sufficient to provide assurance that justice is being done and, equally important, that it is seen to be done.” the committee said. “Where powers to regulate standards are devolved to promote local responsibility and leadership, care should always be taken to ensure that there is independent scrutiny, that the results of such scrutiny are made publicly available and that those who have responsibility for imposing sanctions have adequate legal or other powers to do so.”
The Committee for Standards in Public Life also identified a growing “generic” risk to public probity created by new governance arrangements, such as elected mayors and elected police and crime commissioners, and new models of service delivery, such as academy schools and the outsourcing of public services. It urged the commissioners of outsourced services to put ethical issues at the top of the agenda when designing and procuring new providers.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.